Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Eyelid Surgery REVIEWS

Dr. Andrew Jacono Blepharoplasty Super Disappointment -Great Neck, NY

ORIGINAL POST

During my consultation I expressed the importance...

Woebegone
$4,500
During my consultation I expressed the importance of being discrete about my surgery. I didn't want anyone to know or notice I had my upper lids done. Dr. Jacono assured me I would be picture perfect in 2 to 3 weeks. I only told a few people I was having surgery so I was curious as to what people would say to me that didn't know I was going in. Would they notice? Would they comment? In my mind I thought the best compliment would be the one that I didn't get. I just wanted to look the same but refreshed. Of course I wanted to look better. Why else would I be there? At the consultation Dr. Jacono assured me he has done many of these procedures. He said it was an easy job and that I was in good hand. I trusted him so I booked my surgery. On the day of my surgery Dr. Jacono drew on my lids to mark where he would cut and I noticed the markings were high on my lids. I questioned it and he said it was fine. I was a bit embarrassed for questioning him and I thought who am I to question the doctor, he must know what he is doing. Well a lot of time has passed and I am super disappointed with how my eyes turned out. I have scars that I try to cover with a lot of makeup. The scars do not fall in the fold of my lids they are higher. My lids are now puffy and way bigger that they used to be. I really don't like the look. My eyes don't look refreshed or brighter. They look very different. I am super disappointed with the outcome. I am not happy at all. I liked the way my lids looked before surgery better and I would take them back in a second. When I wanted so desperately to be discrete about my surgery family and friends commented and not in a complimentary way. For a long time I was trying to accept my new look. I wasn't sure what to think. I didn't know if it was good or bad or if my scars would fade away. I am certain I look different and I am certain I don't like it. I met with some plastic surgeons and they told me that my eyelids need to be redone to bring down the scars and to decrease the size of my eyelids. I knew in my heart it wasn't done right. Now other doctors are telling me what I already knew.

Woebegone's provider

Andrew Jacono, MD

Andrew Jacono, MD

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

4.7 | 448 Reviews
PROFILE

Woebegone rating for Dr. Jacono:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (16)

August 22, 2013

Thanks for sharing your story.  I hope you find support in our Community.

August 23, 2013
Thanks
User Avatar
August 22, 2013
The same thing it' s appened to me....
August 23, 2013
So sorry pimpy. I know how you're feeling.
User Avatar
August 22, 2013
How long ago did you have your surgery?
August 22, 2013
I am so sorry this happened to you. You aren't alone. This "surgeon" has ruined many faces and lives. I feel that it is only a matter of time before he loses his medical license. No one should have to go through the suffering that his many victims continue to endure. Wishing you peace and healing.
August 23, 2013
Thanks jcathope. I read your page. I am sorry for what you are dealing with too.
August 30, 2013
he did a surgery on a friends nose and it is quite uneven, nostil is large and left a scar....not a very good job at all....
May 30, 2015
Im sorry to hear this. The truth is Dr. JACONO should have his liscense taken away. Most of his reviews are awful!! And he works feverishly to remove each negative comment about his work and deliberately puts positive comments in the hopes of saving his reputation. NO ONE should go to him. He RUINS your face and self esteem!
UPDATED FROM Woebegone
1 year post

s

Woebegone
I just got back from the make-up counters at the mall. I am desperate to have revision surgery, but it is costly, do I am dependent on make-up to solve my problems. I have been playing with it, trying to hide my scars and I am really upset. I want to pour a ton of make-up on my lids, but nothing can hide my scars. I feel like make-up actually accentuates the scars, and I don't like wearing a ton of make-up on my eyes, it just doesn't look good on me. And if I don't have it on my scars are even more noticeable. I feel like I can't catch a break. Whether it is on or off, I cringe at the sight of my scarry eyes. Oh how I wanted to be discrete about my eye job, but it is so evident. I am so self-conscious and extremely embarrassed.

Replies (8)

October 13, 2013
Oh so sorry to hear. I completely understand about not wanting to wear so much makeup. I hope you find a solution. You are in my thoughts.
November 10, 2013
Hi. I too am sorry for everything you are dealing with. It's just terrible and so upsetting. Thanks for your comment.
User Avatar
October 13, 2013
I had a very successful eyelid surgery but also wanted to cover the scars while they heal. I use CoverFX, it should be available where you are. It is very healthy for your skin as it was created to cover burn scars etc. I think you'll be happy with it.
November 10, 2013
Hi Brighid, I wanted to thank you for the recommendation. I bought the CoverFx. At this point I'm trying anything. The girl that helped me choose a color basically said that no make-up will help the deep grooves I have and I already knew that but I bought it anyway. I like it for my cheeks because I have some broken blood vessels and it helps there. Thanks for contacting me and giving me the suggestion.
User Avatar
November 10, 2013
You're welcome! I'm glad you like it!
User Avatar
November 10, 2013
You are very welcome, I'm glad you like it!
October 14, 2013
He did a friend of mine as well, and she had the same problem and she had them re done by another plastic surgeon, thank God they look beautiful, although you can still see some of the old scars (only if she points them out to you) the new doctor did a wonderful job......I am happy I did not go to Jacono, after reading all of the bad surgeries he has done, he was one on my list but not anymore....
November 10, 2013
Yes I read all of the bad reviews too. You are lucky.
UPDATED FROM Woebegone
1 year post

Back to the make-up counter

Woebegone
So I bought the CoverFX, it was suggested by a nice woman on this site. The problem is there is no make-up that could hide the deep, wide scars that were left behind. The woman at Sephora was honest and said that there really isn't anything that could hide the deep grooves. She was trying to camouflage them with different techniques but nothing really helped. I like the CoverFX for some of the discoloration I have on my cheeks so for that reason I bought it. I look at pictures of myself prior to surgery and I get really sad.

Replies (7)

May 30, 2015
I'm so sorry you are going through this. It's such a traumatic letdown. I went through the same thing w an upper bleph.
December 6, 2016
Hello-
It's been 3 years since your original first post. How are you? Did you ever get a revision? Read my profile. Hope your ok. Realself friend.
July 5, 2019
Do you have any pics? Am considering him for surgery.
User Avatar
November 7, 2020
I'd like to see as well as I was thinking of him or a face lift
January 30, 2021
omg...whoever is considering having surgery with this surgeon...please reconsider. He has caused so much damage to women all over. I have been in touch with him. I hope he loses his medical license.