Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Liposuction Reviews

6 Weeks Post Arm and Back Lipo

UPDATED FROM AmyAmy

List Pros & Cons, Advice you can offer others

AmyAmy
$8,500
List Pros & Cons, Advice you can offer others

AmyAmy's provider

Michael S. Kaminer, MD

Michael S. Kaminer, MD

Dermatologic Surgeon, Board Certified in Dermatology

AmyAmy rating for Dr. Kaminer:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (5)

July 23, 2011
It looks like you have skin problem to me. Sorry.
July 23, 2011
The doctor said my skin was "exceptional" and predicted a "better than average" outcome based upon the elasticity of my skin. The only person that might post this would be a doctor himself ashamed of what he did and trying to make it look like something other than "his bad" which of course everyone knows it was ..including all other doctors.
July 23, 2011
Although it is fair to say that after him chopping away at all of the tissue connections he worsened it.
October 8, 2011
User Avatar
September 23, 2012
Hey Amy Amy,

Just out of curiosity, how are you a year out? Any updates? I've been considering getting a fat transfer from my arms and back and put the fat elsewhere. But after seeing your review, I have second thoughts. Did you ever figure out what happened? I haven't seen many people review arm or back liposuction, so it's hard to say if what happened is typical of that area. I went to a few docs, and most said they wouldn't do the back as results are either unnoticeable or the skin can start sticking to the muscle if too much is taken out. It's weird because they say that you should be able to "pinch an inch" but the fat in the back is so weird because we can grab so much but it just isn't "thick". And I definitely think that it's not due to "loose skin". It's just a weird way in which the fat spreads out. Anyway, would love to hear an update, and you can PM me if that's easier for you!

Thanks so much!

- Julia
September 23, 2012
I got my money back ..he made me state I wouldn't talk about how badly he messed up to get my money back ..so bad. I have no clue what he did wrong but suspect it didn't suck anything out ..or he just sucked terribly. I now just love myself and will never try it ever again.
September 23, 2012
by "sucked badly" I mean "he had no clue what he was doing"
User Avatar
September 23, 2012
Wow, thanks for responding Amy, so glad you got your money back. Did you experience any fat redistribution? That's the reason why I plan on getting a fat transfer from my arms to elsewhere -- I had free lipo on my flanks and all of it returned to my arms and back less than a year later. Just wondering if you experienced that, as I don't want it to happen again if I get liposuction only on my arms.
UPDATED FROM AmyAmy

The doctor FINALLY didn't say "you look...

AmyAmy
The doctor FINALLY didn't say "you look great", but agreed it looks the SAME/WORSE ..after I had my medical file and pictures and after his staff has seen them too. He is not willing to redo and only offered to refund $2500 despite agreeing that it looks the same. He blames my skin ..which he had said was superb and extremely springy ..and it did go back to the same shape just 2 weeks after procedure proving that he was right ..and you can also still grab inches of fat because it is fat not skin ..so for him to say it was skin elasticity when no fat was removed and my body perked to what it was after the trauma so quickly ..in addition to him agreeing I had great skin (even the staff were saying that during the procedure) ..is ridiculous. This is very disappointing. Can anyone recommend a doctor? Thank you.

Replies (5)

February 10, 2010
I can relate to your struggle! I have similar results. I chose to allow the Dr do a revision to my flank area. My revision was yesterday but I am hopeful. I was told the same thing, that my skin was draping and did not bounce back. My surgeon revised by removing more fat from the lower back,flank and hip area. Maybe your Dr could remove more fat just below where the rolls begin. It sounds like you were way over charged to begin with. I am not a Dr but I think another option we have if our skin folds after lipo is to have a tuck or lift. This procedure would leave a horrible scar but similar to a tummy tuck the extra skin would be gone. I have seen very impressive after photos of people who have had lower body lifts. I would get a second oppinion before I settled by accepting the refund they offered you. I wish you the best of luck!
February 11, 2010
Thank you for your comments. I got a 2nd opinion and was told that the fat was likely not suctioned out and that one always is to remove fat under a role to smooth it out. My surgeon did not do that, in fact, he removed just to the very bottom of it which apparently amplified it. They offered the same advice that you did. I was told that fat under the roll should have been removed. They actually said my skin elasticity was great. Do they use that as an excuse to cover themselves? I wouldn't have cared if he said "I didn't remove the fat under the area." unless he really didn't understand why he couldn't get the look we were seeking. How did your 2nd procedure go?
February 13, 2010
So far so good with my revision. However, I have learned from my initial surgery that I must wait several months until I can see what the actual results will be. I think revisions are common. I am grateful that my surgeon offered to do it for free. I am healing quickly. Surgery was Tuesday and its Friday and I've already gone back to normal activities. My upper back required a lot more rest and down time. What I am experiencing now is similar to what they advertise for smartlipo recovery. Are you going to have a revision?
February 11, 2010
PS I was also told that the methods they use can create sagging problems, e.g. best to use vaser over traditional and/or suction with fluid alone.
March 26, 2010
what was the doctors name I just had it done in Boston
June 29, 2011
where did you go and who was your MD?
March 26, 2010
No, I am not going to have a revision ..this has been one of the worst experiences of my life ..just dealing with coverups/lying and lack of support was stressful enough ..and I trusted this person. I'm done with any thoughts of altering myself with assistance from any kind of surgery at all. False expectations and/or just bad luck ..regardles ..never again.
April 6, 2010
Same here. One of the worst experiences I have ever had. If we had only come here before the procedure and saw the summary of 57% of people happy with lipo. Promises are made for money that aren't made or kept. The industry is not overall successful. I wish I had never gone. Perhaps if someone else had done it the result would have been different but who wants to play with odds almost equal to flipping a coin.
UPDATED FROM AmyAmy

Did it to get rid of back roll and have thinner...

AmyAmy

Did it to get rid of back roll and have thinner arms. Would not bother again.

VERY expensive! ..although is it too early to tell? It has only been 6 weeks so far. The procedure itself when they inject fluid was kinda painful ..minimal pain after the procedure itself. NO change so far ..looks a little worse and was very expensive ..right now wishing had just rid of it through diet ...unless I can expect more significant changes? ..not too sure.

Replies (5)

December 4, 2009
hmmmm... You are not just seeing things; you look exactly the same if not worse. And for THAT price, Mammas, you need to either get your money back OR tell him that he needs to do it again. He obviously did not suck the fat out. Perhaps he did smart lipo with the laser and such, but he failed to do part 2: suck the fat out once melted by the laser. 6 weeks is more than enough time to see you at least half the size that you were. I've been reading that when smartlipo first came out, the Docs thought all they had to do was simply zap the fat with the laser and then allow your body to flush/absorb the fat... Now, more experienced docs are discovering that it is a 2-step process. 1)zap the fat 2)suck OUT the fat. ...but appearently, not all of the docs got the memo... My advice: your doc is a nice guy yatta yatta, but the bottom line is that unfortunately, "nice" doesn't pay bills. So if you spend that amount of your hard earned money for a product, HE NEEDS TO FIX IT. :)
December 4, 2009
I almost forgot; be sure to ask him exactly how much fat he sucked out, just to test what his answer is going to be.
December 4, 2009
He said he took 2 pounds out? Even that doesn't seem a lot ..I looked online to see what 2 lbs looks like ..doesn't seem like a lot ..is it?
December 4, 2009
it can take up to a year to see the affects of liposuction your doctor should have told u this before you got it done but i would wait about 3months before i get concerned and also take picture thru out that is the best way to determine if change is happening
December 5, 2009
He def needs to do that again! I did traditional lipo and i saw results immediately even though the next day i was swollen! My pics are pretty helpful i think!
December 6, 2009
Thank u!