Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Restylane REVIEWS

Thought I Was Going to an Eye Hollow Expert...- Bellevue, WA

ORIGINAL POST

I went to Dr. Young to correct under eye hollows...

Portland3931
$575

I went to Dr. Young to correct under eye hollows caused by a lower blepharoplasty performed by another doctor (she said she wouldn't remove fat but she did anyway while I was under general anesthesia). I had seen Dr. Young's before and after pictures showing how he corrected under eye hollows with Restylane and I was impressed. I also thought that with his fat transfer experience he'd be good at delicate under eye work.

His staff assured me that he was indeed exceptionally good at this kind of correction. Dr. Young himself stated that the thin skin under my eyes and lack of natural fat/tissue there would not be a concern. I went ahead and had 1/2 syringe of filler placed under each eye, with a small amount above the eye. After a good week of very bad swelling and bruising, I was left with very tell-tale lumps under the skin where the filler had been placed. It was and still is quite unsightly, especially in unflattering light (which seems to be everywhere!).

Dr. Young recommended massaging which I did tons of but it did not help at all. He also promised he'd make it better but when I went back at two weeks to show him how it looked his only suggestion was to put in even more. Of course that made me nervous so I opted not to take that route. I ended up going to another doctor (an oculoplastic surgeon) to put more Restylane in to smooth out the misshapen, asymmetrical, weird lumps under my eyes. This time the added filler was conservative and it helped for a while but after 5 months it is wearing off and what Dr. Young put in is again noticeable. Unfortunately I am unable to hide the strangle lumps with make-up; it just doesn't mask it. When he put the filler in I remember that I was a little concerned because he worked very quickly and was rather rough with the needle but I thought I was in the hands of an experienced expert. I was wrong.

I was hoping for natural-looking under eye contours instead of the lifeless hollowed out look I had from a bad lower bleph the year before (different plastic surgeon for the bleph).  After the filler treatment I ended up with noticeable lumpiness that is asymmetrical, unnatural, and placed oddly.

Portland3931's provider

Philip Young, MD

Philip Young, MD

Board Certified Otolaryngologist

Portland3931 rating for Dr. Young, MD:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (21)

September 13, 2012

My goodness, I am so sorry for what you have been through. Thank you very much for sharing a picture with us. Have any of the doctors mentioned that the filler might not have settled properly due to scar tissue from your previous bleph? I have no idea if that is a possibility or not, but I wonder if that could have something to do with it?

September 13, 2012
Hi Megan, good question and one I did ask. No one seems to think that the lower bleph work should complicate the placement of the filler. I have particularly thin skin and not much tissue under the eyes (even before the other surgeon removed tissue!) so I wonder if it is just difficult for the practitioner to hide the filler in my own remaining tissue. There simply isn't much volume there to smooth the Restylane into. While I was excited about the possibility of having some volume back under my eyes I definitely think the hollow look I had before was better than the weird lumpiness I have now. Can't wait for it to dissolve. Thanks!
September 13, 2012

Yes, I don't blame you. Thank goodness it will dissolve! 

September 14, 2012
Portland3931 - I have had a similar problem, under exactly the same circumstances. How are you now?
September 15, 2012

Hello MyFaze, it has been 8 1/2 months since I had the botched filler job under the eyes and only 5 months since I had a little more placed (to try to make the lumpiness less noticeable) under a different doctor with a much more conservative approach. The second attempt was somewhat successful; it helped but it was certainly not a "great" result, just made the weird lumps a little less obvious. Now the conservative filler from 5 months ago seems to be wearing off and the more heavy-handed filler from 8 1/2 months ago is again more visible and really starting to bother me. I found out about a new product called Belotero just today which reportedly goes in much, much more smoothly and works much better under the eyes. I am waiting to get more info on that. So, at the moment I am doing my homework to see which filler/which practitioner I will try next. Hopefully I will find someone who actually does convincing, natural-looking work so I can have the rested, attractive face I had dreamed of before my lower blepharoplasty. Good luck to you and susjan, too!

September 14, 2012
Hi, was interested to read your post. I had restylane put in 36 months ago, the doctor who put mine in suggested that my hollows were too deep to warrant putting in just the one dose and recommended a double dosage, unfortunately I went along with her recommendation. 36 months on I still have the same large lump under one eye, there is a slightly less of a lump under the other eye - but I can say after 36 months neither bump has gone down at all. I have now had to resign myself to the fact that I will need to visit another doctor to get it taken out. Even if it means a cut, a small scar would be preferable to walking around with what looks like under eye puffiness. I wear glasses quite a lot to try and disguise it. When I complained to the original doctor 2 months after the proceedure (not in my country of residence) they assured me that it would dissolve!
September 14, 2012
just checked, actually it's been 28 months since I had the restylane injected. I'm going to make an appointment with the PS that did my bust reduction and try and rectify the problem - what I don't understand is that after 28 months I have seen no reduction in the bumps...
UPDATED FROM Portland3931

Hi, I was asked to post a follow-up photo now that...

Portland3931
Hi, I was asked to post a follow-up photo now that I have addressed the Restylane lumpiness with a new and better product called Belotero. Belotero is new in the U.S. since March; it has been in use in Europe for years. I had it injected at Dr. Tarbet's office in Bellevue by a Merz pharmaceutical rep named Peggy. She has tons of experience and I have found her work to be a big help in smoothing out the unsightly lumpiness which resulted from the under-eye Restylane injected by Dr. Young last January. It seems to me that the Belotero does a much better job at mimicking the natural contours and fullness under the eye that I had prior to my unsatisfactory lower bleph (performed in Portland in early 2011). If Belotero had been on the market back then and if a provider would have counseled me to try it I think I would have been very happy with the results and I never would have resorted to the lower bleph to address the faint beginnings of bags under my eyes. The Belotero would have masked the barely visible rings under the eyes that were concerning me. I did not know back then that a lower bleph would prove to be such a disaster on my thin face. Now I will be working for the rest of my life to correct the lifeless, hollowed out look that resulted. Hopefully Belotero will be a long-term good thing to have in my "tool box!"

Replies (15)

November 26, 2012

Thanks for posting an update. I'm so glad to hear that the Belotero worked out nicely for you!! Please keep us posted on how it wears and what you think of it over the long run. I'll be very curious to hear!

November 27, 2012
Thanks for posting the photo's - you look great! :))
December 1, 2012
Appreciate your kind and complimentary comments, gals. Thank you!
November 29, 2012
You look great with the Belotero and I love the blonde hair and bangs on you!
November 29, 2012

Yeah, I agree with Anika1, the new 'do is very cute on you!

December 29, 2012
I had a neck lift from Dr. Young, and wasn't happy with the end result. I went back to get some of it fixed, but ended up again with results that were below par. Dr. Young mentioned each time that he saw me that he could do fillers for under my eyes. I told him each time that I wasn't interested. Reading what happened to you, I am glad I didn't let him do the work. I wish you hadn't gone through this yourself, hopefully others will read your review and think twice. I'ts good to read that you've found a solution - and your hair looks great. :-)
User Avatar
March 24, 2014
At Aesthetic Facial Plastic Surgery our Mission is to provide unwavering quality care to improve people's lives through Facial Plastic Surgery and the YoungVitalizer. We go above and beyond to help our patients. The comments that have been posted are not authenticated. We are unsure if these comments are actual patients or competing doctors. If you are an actual patient, we ask that you contact us as soon as possible so that we can help you directly at 425-990-3223 or contactusatdrphilipyoung.com. We will do everything we can to improve your situation. We wish you peace, love and happiness - Aesthetic Facial Plastic Surgery.
January 5, 2013
It is such a blessing to us that you share your experience and outcomes... I want to thank you. You look so pretty and confident now :-)
January 5, 2013
It is my pleasure, Yolanda. I haven't had a lot of luck or satisfaction since I started down this path (mainly due to the outcome of the initial blephs and chin implant in Portland) but I truly feel that the only silver lining for me is to share my story with others so that they have a better chance of making good choices and ending up with good outcomes. Thanks for your kind note!