African American Rhinoplasty before & after photos
50%
6 reviews
Worth It Rating Our index shows the percentage of community members saying this was "Worth it". See cosmetic treatment rankings
African American Rhinoplasty Cost $4,800 average cost

Bi-racial, Had Nostrils and Tip Reduced 3 Years Ago - Montreal

6 posts
Comments (9)
Updated 13 Aug 2009
Posted 3 Jul 2009
Not Worth It
Spent: $1,000 in Montreal

I am biracial (black/white) and I had my nostrils and tip reduced 3 years ago. Although I liked my old nose, I didn't like the way my nostrils flared when I smiled. My doctor is the one who recommended the tip work, because he said he had to narrow my tip to match my nostrils. I didn't have an issue with my tip, but he is a reputable surgeon so I figured he knew best.

My surgeon was conservative and I was quite satisfied with the initial result (for the first year or so). But it is now three years later and my tip has become bulbous. My nose now looks bigger than it did before the surgery; it stands out. I find this very frustrating because I never even asked for the tip-plasty. I'd love to go back to my old nose which suited my face much better.

My question is, why would my tip become bulbous so long after the surgery? My pre-op tip was fine and my post-op tip was fine for the first year or so. Could this be attributed to the normal ageing process (I am age 30)? Could it have something to do with the fact that I gained about 10 pounds in the last 2 years? Could steroid injections help, or is it too late?

I have included 2 recent pictures.

This review is the subjective opinion of a RealSelf member and not of RealSelf, Inc.

My Doctor:

My rating:
I don't question the surgeon's skills, I think my problem is due to the way I heal.
Vote: 1 member found this review helpful

Comments (9)

Post a Comment
bruno vega (1 post) 14 Jul 2009
hey, im getting my nose done in 2 days, and my doctor told me due to my skin color and my race my nose will grow back again. I forgot the medical term but it fatty cells in the nose that porduce fat and make it bulbuos. My doctor recommended me laser treament after te surgery. hope it helps
Sue1979 (6 posts) 15 Jul 2009
Thanks. I wish my doctor would have warned me. I never would have thought that my post-op nose could look bigger than pre-op nose... Could laser still be beneficial three years after surgery?
mahalia (7 posts) 27 Aug 2009

Hi Mahalia, I think we met the same doctor. I have information for you in regard to your question that might help you. feel free to write me in private

:) mini (1 post) 12 Aug 2009
can i ask you who is your doctor, I live in montreal and I am plannning to have a nose surgery :) merci
Sue1979 (6 posts) 12 Aug 2009

It was {edited}. He is a good surgeon, my problems aren't related to his skills, but rather to the way I heal. That's the thing with plastic surgery, no matter how good your surgeon is, you can never be 100% of what your final result will be (your nose can keep on changing for years). Unless you are truly dissatisfied with the way you look, don't do it. Btw, most surgeons won't refuse a patient, even if they look fine. De rien :)

Edited by Sharon: We've added your provider information to the review. Thank you!
mahalia (7 posts) 19 Aug 2009
It is very difficult to find a good surgeon and lots of homework has to be done in regards to surgeon..knowing what we want versus what can be achieved is very important..I am from Montreal and African American and cannot seem to find a surgeon that has experience in ethnic noses..I met on a month ago that suggested to reduce my nostrils by going through my mouth(front teeth to get to my nostrils). I also want my tip refined but he doesn't use cartilage
miss r (2 posts) 15 Oct 2009
I am also ethnic (Indian, Middle Eastern) and am looking for a good rhinoplasty provider. I think it may be better to go to a different city. I don't want to mess with my nose!
Cindyp (2 posts) 9 Aug 2010
A lot of people suggest Dr.Swift in Westmount, but he is quite expensive. Dr.Schwarz in Westmount has done a few people I know, he seems to be good and his prices are more reasonable. I;ve also heard good things about Dr.Papanastasiou who is also in Westmount.
urbandesignr (12 posts) 8 Jul 2011
What type of laser to reduce the fat on the tip?

Post a Comment

Use of this website and the posting of any reviews or other content on this website constitutes acceptance of the RealSelf® Terms of Service. The material on this site is for informational purposes only, and is not a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment provided by a qualified health care provider. © 2011 RealSelf, Inc. All rights reserved.