Why would the injector use a topical numbing cream verses a block, when the block is less painful for the patient? Is one better than the other?
Dental Block Vs. Numbing Cream - Which is Better for Cosmetic Injections?
Doctor Answers 5
Advantages and Disadvantages with Both...
Topical anesthetics are relatively easy to use. These agents are simply spread over the area before the procedure. They take approximately 10 to 15 minutes to work and are moderately effective. The administration of these agents is pain free, but doesn’t totally alleviate pain from the injection of dermal fillers.
When using injectable fillers, nerve blocks with local anesthetics are extremely effective. This procedure is performed by infiltrating local anesthetic intra-orally in the area of the infra orbital and mental nerves. This effectively provides anesthesia of the upper and lower lips and surrounding areas. This approach provides excellent anesthesia which is almost instantaneous.
When this approach is utilized, patients don’t experience pain when fillers are injected.Unfortunately, this numbness may last for 2 to 4 hours. During this period, patients may have difficulty with eating, speaking and may even drool.
Pain tolerance varies from patient to patient and for this reason anesthesia needs to be individualized. Consultation with a board certified plastic surgeon who is familiar with these anesthetic techniques is appropriate. This surgeon should be able to provide the anesthetic methods that’s appropriate for the problem.
Both are acceptable techniques
Nerve blocks are similar to the anesthesia administered by your dentist. Sometimes they work really well, sometimes not, sometimes too good, and last longer than desired.
An effective topical anesthetic should provide excellent anesthesia if properly compounded and properly used.
The block can provide profound anesthesia but may be too much for a filler injection. Therefore, I prefer topical anesthesia.
Blocks vs. Topicals: Depends on the individual
It really depends upon the individual. Some patients don't require any topical. But that is the rare patient. I think it varies for different patients. I use topical for most patients. If they are very sensitive, I may perform a dental block after using an oral topical inside their mouth first. I tried to make my patients as comfortable as they want. It is always easier for both of us when the pateint is comfortable.
You might also like...
Blocks work better
The dental blocks are more invasive than a topical cream, but are much better for pain relief. The block is performed by injecting 1 to 2 ccs of local anesthetic right next to where a major nerve group comes out of the bones of your face. The entire segment supplied by this nerve bundle then "falls asleep" for 1 to 4 hours. If the block is performed through the mouth using some numbing cream or spray at the injection site, it can be painless. There are relatively few nerve receptors inside the mouth, and those are very susceptible to the topical creams.
Topical numbing creams do work outside the mouth, but they take much longer to have effect. The numbing cream has to "soak through" the skin to have its effect on the nerve receptor. In areas with a high density of nerve receptors (around the lips!), this is really not sufficient, and the blocks are the only way to go.
The blocks do have some drawbacks. First, since a long needle is used for the injection, there is a rare possibility of a visible bruise. Second, if you numb both the upper and lower lip in the same session, all sensation will disappear from the lower eyelid to the chin for 1 to 4 hours. This lack of proprioception will make you feel like you are drooling! (Don't chew gum or eat a meal until the block wears off.) In my mind, these minor drawbacks are worth the excellent pain relief.
Anesthesia for injections is a must
Only certain types of filler injections have lidocaine in them, making the injection less painful. The most popular products, however, do not.
For nasolabial folds, eyelids, lip corners, and marionette lines I always use a "dental" block. These areas are well anesthetized with a small local anesthesia block. This block takes effect almost immediately. I like to ensure my patient's comfort because it is critical for precise injections.
Other areas, such as the frown line or the lip itself are not well covered by the dental blocks. In those instances I do use the topical cream, often in association with a formal block. The lips have too many nerves going to them to block completely. They are also very very sensitive. That is why I add the cream. Creams do work well, however, they have to be left on for a minimum of 30-45 minutes to be really effective, which is a lot of time for a patient to sit around and wait.
These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.