Ask a doctor

Can a Compression Garment Smooth Hips?

I am young (20), skinny, and fit but my hips have a "violin deformity". I would prefer not to remove the fat, i.e. lipo, but to move it downward so that my hips appear smoother. Would wearing a compression garment for a length of time solve this issue? Are there any alternatives to liposuction that would apply?

Doctor Answers (15)

Body contouring garments that melt fat

+3

Conventional wisdom states that a "spanx-like" garment or bodyshaper will certainly alter your shape....temporarily. However, you do have a good point and one that I have pondered. I have observed that men that wear particulary tight belt buckles or females as well tend to develop atrophy in the suprapubic area that appears directly related to the pressure applied. I have believed that perhaps this observation could be applied elsewhere. IT is a fine balance and that is the problem. Excessive presure will cause a sore. Perhaps garments will be designed that can monitor the exact pressure. We shall see......?


Chicago Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 44 reviews

Compression versus lipo

+2

Good question.  From a non-medical standpoint, compression makes perfect sense.  Unfortunately, from a medical standpoint, it doesn't.  You could wear a compression garment all day every day for months and only result with a skin rash and discomfort.  It will not mold fat one millimeter.  However, this does not mean that you need liposuction.  Liposuction, though aggressively marketed, is best for people who are otherwise fit.  What I would suggest is to amplify your workout routine.  If you've reached a point where you plateau, then consider other options.  If may be a good idea to talk with a personal trainer to focus on exercises that will shape your external olbliques (these help to shape your waist and hips).  Hope this helps.

Jason R. Hess, MD
San Diego Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 7 reviews

Compression garments will not move fat around

+1

While the use of compression garments after liposuction is standard postperative care, such an approach without liposuction will not be successful at reshaping or moving fat around. Fat must first be 'loosened' or partially removed to have a compression garment help in reshaping any excess fat area. A compression garment does not have magical properties, it is a passive device that does more to control swelling after liposuction than it does in reshaping fat contours.

Barry L. Eppley, MD, DMD
Indianapolis Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 26 reviews

You might also like...

Alternatives to liposuction = not compression garment but Zeltiq Coolsculpture

+1

No, compression garments won't help and no Zeltiq Coolsculpture won't give you the same volume reduction as liposuction, but without liposuction or surgery, Zeltiq coolsculpture which is an FDA cleared device for fat chilling, can lessen fat for some people as much as 20% with one treatment that takes one hour, and the results can be seen in the first several months. Love handles, lower abdomen and flanks, no surgery. We're still getting experience with it but there is a high satisfaction rate. Speak to a physician to learn of the risks and advantages, but remember, it's not the same as liposuction!

Ronald Shelton, MD
Manhattan Dermatologist
5.0 out of 5 stars 31 reviews

Compression garments do not permanently change body contour

+1
Compression garments are not a replacement for liposuction.  They can help mask contour abnormalities but will not leave behind a lasting effect once taken off.  Liposuction is very effective in changing body contours, unlike many non-surgical treatments that are on the market today.  None of those can produce the effect of a real liposuction.
 
Sincerely,
Martin Jugenburg, MD

Martin Jugenburg, MD
Toronto Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 135 reviews

Compression garment versus liposuction

+1

A compression garment is used post-liposuction. It is not used for changing the shape of areas that have not been treated.

Steven Wallach, MD
Manhattan Plastic Surgeon
4.5 out of 5 stars 17 reviews

Can compression garments to alter shape.

+1

I don't know of any credible product on the market which will thin areas of the body or redistribute the fat using compression.  At best, firm compression will temporarily flatten areas but these areas will quickly return to the original shape once the compression is gone.  Although you would like to avoid it, liposuction is a relatively quick procedure with a quick recovery and predictable permanent results.  Other modalities, though heavily marketed, are not proven to be as effective as liposuction.

Jeffrey M. Darrow, MD
Boston Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 32 reviews

Compression garments to change shape

+1

The "Squeem" product claims to be able to do what you want but I have no personal experience with the results.  I do know of two people who are trying it to change their shape.  Sounds sort of Victorian England to me though.

Richard P. Rand, MD, FACS
Seattle Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 48 reviews

Can compression garments cause permanent changes in your body shape?

+1

There are many examples of how intermittent pressure on a body area can cause permanent changes in your body, with bra strap grooves being an obvious example.  But can regular postsurgical compression garments cause a permanent change in your body shape?  The answer is not obvious, because details really matter.  We definitely know that compression can cause permanent changes in body shape during the growth phase of life- the ancient art of Chinese foot binding is an example.  Practically speaking, though, this is not a realistic way to change a problem with your hips, for example.  The amount of pressure and the length of time that would be required to achieve any meaningful change in your body shape would make it very difficult, if not impossible to get the changes you want.

 The tried and true ways of getting the shape you want include both surgical and non-surgical, with the fastest, most reliable way being liposuction. Lipo can easily change your body shape permanently, and the best candidates are those who have a normal body weight but have a genetic predisposition to an area of fat that is both diet and exercise resistant.  

If you have a 'problem area' that never goes away, despite your best efforts, remember that it is NOT your fault!  The fat cell receptors in these areas are actually different from fat in the other areas of your body.  The receptors on the cell wall control when the contained fat is used, thereby preventing the breakdown of its contents excepting in the rarest circumstances.  Removing a portion of this fat pad can alter the physiology permanently.  Liposuction is the best way to achieve long lasting results in this type of problem.  It has withstood the test of time and is a safe and effective method of achieving the desired result.  See a qualified plastic surgeon for a consultation.

Claudio DeLorenzi MD FRCS

Claudio DeLorenzi, MD
Toronto Plastic Surgeon
4.0 out of 5 stars 5 reviews

Compression garments mold the body, but will never make permanent changes!

+1

You describe yourself as "skinny" but with a violin deformity of the hips. Other call this a "muffin top" but we all know that this localized extra fat looks bad coming out over your lowrider jeans or snug-fitting slacks. (I have 4 daughters in their 20's!)

If this is indeed localized fatty tissue, you are an excellent candidate for liposuction (or liposculpture) of this area. At 20, you (probably) have excellent skin tone and muscle tone, and removal of this fat by an experienced, board-certified (American Board of Plastic Surgery) plastic surgeon can give you a wonderful, long-lasting improvement in your appearance.

No garment will create any movement of tissue; your cells are not fluid! Spot exercising does not work either.

Lipo-dissolve or mesotherapy is NOT recommended, These techniques use injections of caustic chemicals designed to KILL the fat cells. Unfortunately, instead of "harmlessly absorbing the dead fat" as the advertisements and marketing state or imply, sometimes you are left with hard, calcified lumps of scar tissue beneath the skin that can not be removed without more scarring and severe deformity. I have seen patients with this, so even if it is "rare," I would NEVER recommend this form of fat removal. Of course, liposuction is an operation that has risk as well, so careful research about your surgeon is critical to minimize any likelihood of any risk or complication. Best wishes!

Richard H. Tholen, MD, FACS
Minneapolis Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 118 reviews

These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.