VOTE: Which Celebrity Has the Most Dramatic Surgical Makeover?

MakenzieR on 10 Oct 2011 at 12:30pm

Celebrity masks are a big-seller for Halloween costumes, but some stars have such extreme plastic surgery you’d think THEY were the ones wearing the mask.

Whether or not you think they look good now, who has had biggest surgical makeover?  Check out the photos and vote at the bottom.

We had to leave out Michael Jackson, Jocelyn Wildenstein and Sarah Burge -- their extreme transformations create an uneven playing field! 


cher plastic surgery

Janice Dickinson

Janice Dickinson plastic surgery

Carrot Top

Carrot Top plastic surgery

Heidi Montag

Heidi Montag plastic surgery

Dolly Parton

Dolly Parton plastic surgery

Barry Manilow

Barry Manilow plastic surgery

Donatella Versace

Donatella Versace plastic surgery


Madonna plastic surgery

Photo credits: Cher - Bauer Griffin on; Janice -; Carrot Top -; Heidi Montag - and; Dolly - and; Barry - Wikimedia; Donatella - Woman’s Day and David_Shankbone on flickr; Madonna - Access Hollywood and WIkimedia.

Comments (9)

I can understand not liking a feature or two - I want new, perky, B-cup boobs that can sit up and beg. :) I haven't had surgery - no $$$ - but if I had it, I think I'd just get the boob job because mine are uncomfortable. To change a thing or two if you have the resources - sure, why not? To me, it's a matter of some things getting too extreme. Heidi Montag was a pretty young woman - I don't think the surgeries changed her face much, but her breasts are just disfiguring at this point. Carrot Top - what the HELL did he do to his eyebrows? he looks insane. Donatella looked like an unattractive man,and still does - just with weird lips. That Weildenstein woman - and Michael Jackson - that much sugery seems to indicate some sort of self loathing (complete inability to accept yourself and your looks) or mental health issue. Or a desperate need to be noticed. Spend the money on therapy instead! As for Heidi, new boobs won't get her acting jobs, because she can't act. Wasted money.
Reply coined the term "Madamism"
puppet like features caused by too many face lifts.

Thank you for sharing that! I had never heard that term and once I Googled it I found it quite entertaining. Definitely some resemblances there...

Plastic surgery is very complex and one minor change can change the total package. These celebs aka people shoudn't have tried to make a total overhaul each time they went under the knife.
Madonna looks the same just like she never aged.
Carrot-Top was ugly before and after. Who was his PS he needs to retire.
Janice ... Po' Janice need I say more.
Dolly is Dolly love her to pieces.
Cher, Cher, Cher ... really too much but I still love ya.
Donatella went from woman to drag queen. Did she have the sex change to go with it?
Heidi went from girl next door everyone wanted to marry to PORN STAR everyone wants to screw!
Barry just brought out his inner craziness to warn us all, he is crazy.

Hahaha! Thank you, BNF, for that great recap. I think you hit it pretty spot on.

With all the amazing software out there, someone should do a "what would they look like now WITHOUT surgery?" comparison!

Everyone is guided to make decisions based on what troubles them. A person who feels their nose is too big might always be troubled by what they perceive as a problem. If they have the money, they are likely to address the issue, as many celebs do. But more often than not, a celebrity is likely to have procedures done to maintain what they feel is their "image." I guess they think the public expects them to be frozen in time.

Personally, I admire celebrities who choose to age gracefully. I have no problem with them coloring their hair, doing Botox or having plastic surgery, but no need to go to extremes.

Carrot Top and Barry Manilow are a bit creepy looking......eeks!

Carrot Tops eyebrows are too arched, especially for a man.
I love all but they shouldv stayed nomal