Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Tummy Tuck REVIEWS

Terrible Experience. Reconsider Using Dr Alderman

ORIGINAL POST

Terrible Experience

Atlanta8408
$6,399
I had 2 separate surgeries by Dr. Alderman. If I’d left a review after the first one, I’d have left 4-5 stars like everyone else. Unfortunately, I decided to use her again for my second procedure, which is why I’m leaving only 2 stars. (In hindsight, there were some pretty big red flags, for example: convincing me to increase the size of my implants right before my surgery began, but AFTER the iv sedation had started, despite my emphatic insistence on at all of my consultation visits that I wanted SMALL boobs.... but I unfortunately chose to ignore the warning signs.)
I don’t think Dr Alderman is a terrible surgeon but be forewarned- her bedside manner can quickly shift from “soft spoken and empathetic” to “dismissive and condescending” if you raise any concerns about your results.
During my consultation, I expressed my displeasure with my upper abdominal laxity and I asked which procedure would be best for the upper abdomen area and she recommended a traditional tummy tuck.
Immediately after my surgery I had issues with a small scar that she refused to correct for months. She literally wouldn’t even acknowledge my questions about it at first!
Finally she acknowledged that she heard me but then insisted I wait 6 months before she’d do anything because she felt that I “wouldn’t want the longer scar” and that “I’d get used to it by then”. I tried to be explain to her that I was not remotely concerned about the scars but she wouldn’t hear it.
During that same visit I told her I was disappointed that my upper abdominal laxity wasn’t better... that’s when things really got heated.
She decided to tell me then, after I already had done a regular tummy tuck, that a fleur de lis tummy tuck was the only way my upper abdominal area could be addressed.
I asked her, “why am I just now being told about that option?” She said that she didn’t tell me about it bc “I wouldn’t have wanted the vertical scar”. (Starting to see a theme yet?)
Okay, WTF. Seriously?!!! That choice should’ve been for ME to make!! I never would’ve gotten a traditional tummy tuck if she hadn’t steered me towards it! And I never once said anything negative about having scars!
We argued for a few more minutes, during which time she pointed out other areas I *should’ve* been concerned about, called me “too anxious” and muttered “if you’re gonna have a nervous breakdown...”(I had a witness who heard it too).
Despite all of that, I still came back exactly 6 months later to ask for a revision of the smaller scar, which she begrudgingly agreed to do. Unfortunately for me, she still didn’t listen to me and I now I have to go somewhere else to get it revised, again.
TLDR; Dr Alderman is a capable surgeon and probably not a bad option as long as you don’t mind her making executive decisions about what she thinks looks best for you, regardless of your input. And definitely don’t have anything remotely critical to say to her or you’ll regret it!

Atlanta8408's provider

Amy K. Alderman, MD, FACS, MPH

Amy K. Alderman, MD, FACS, MPH

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

Atlanta8408 rating for Dr. Alderman:

Overall rating

Replies (2)

April 24, 2021
If it's any consolation, I had a very similar experience with the Jeckyl & Hyde persona. Read my review from July of 2019. I would NEVER recommend Dr Alderman. Again, technical skills aside, she makes unilateral decisions about Brest size etc when you are on the table and can't speak for yourself. I expressed innumerable times my issue wa fullness at the breast pole NOT cup size. She takes offense if you assert your point of view or question her about your results. Too many other Drs out there who listen to their patients and take responsibility for outcomes. Stay Away.
July 29, 2024
The EXACT same thing happened to me! She left half my nipple after a lift with implants. It was clear as day areola. Her and her team gaslit me saying it was a scar... I went back for "scar revision surgery" as she called it and actually asked me where I wanted her to cut. Smh