Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Ear Surgery REVIEWS

*** Failed Otoplasty - Sugar Land, TX

ORIGINAL POST

To make a very long story as short as possible I ...

kimmmy87
$3,500
To make a very long story as short as possible I had otoplasty done by Dr. Horndeski and have never been more disappointed in my life. I went in with the excitement and intention that my ears will finally look good enough to wear my hair up and not have to hide them anymore. I am 29 years old and have always been self conscious about how much my ears stuck out and absolutely HATED them. After having done the surgery I can honestly say that i would take my "old" ears back in a heartbeat after what he has done and having to deal with the uncaring, unprofessional way him and his assistant has treated me on top of that. A piece of cartilage (rook) that i used to have pierced has been cut off from both my ears and only a tiny piece left. A bigger piece was left on my right ear. There's excess skin in my conchal bowl that they are saying will go down but have recently discovered stitches that i can feel under the surface of the thin layer of skin in my conchal bowl. When I call about my concerns they seem frustrated and annoyed and repeat the same things instead of directly answeringdirectly answering my questions. First saying that my ears are normal so give it time to heal. And now admitting, after being confronted, that the "rook" WAS taken off in order to give me what i wanted. Otoplasty surgery is supposed to make the ear pinned back but still have a normal inside structure. It was not what i wanted or what i asked for and certainly was not warned. In all my research I've done I've never seen or heard this being done to anyone so i had no idea that it would be possible or that it would even happen to me. If they informed me of this I would not have done the surgery. Also they are now saying that these are not stitches in my conchal bowl but pieces of cartilage. So if i have random pieces of cartilage sticking out of my conchal bowl that means that this excess skin can not possible go down or "smooth out" like normal like they say. After having the conversation with Elisa about my concern and letting her know my issues i still haven't heard anything after that. Now I am worried because I can't get an honest answer. I hope that this information helps and encourages anyone to keep researching and find a better Dr and have the surgery that they are expecting. I still wear my hair down and keep my ears covered and am embarrassed to even show anyone. Even if the excess skin goes down after they completely heal i still have missing cartilage that makes my ears look deformed and have no idea how big of a problem it will be if in fact these are stitches.

kimmmy87's provider

Gary M. Horndeski, MD

Gary M. Horndeski, MD

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

4.6 | 319 Reviews
PROFILE

kimmmy87 rating for Dr. Horndeski:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy

Replies (22)

August 1, 2016
you make me scare I'm thinking about having mine done
August 1, 2016
Enrique, It is definitely scarey to know that this sort of things happen but it shouldn't as long as you do your research and make sure you're 100% comfortable with the Dr you choose. There are a ton of great Dr's out there. Unfortunately there are also ones like mine so just be careful who you chose. Take your time and spend the extra money if you have to. It'll be worth it. If i had a good Dr it would have been worth it!
August 1, 2016
don't bother, i had it done 10 years ago, not a day goes by where i don't regret it and it's soooooooo painful - don't listen to ANYONE saying it is a walk in the park, plus you have embarrassing scars behind your ears. And sunglasses are painful.
August 1, 2016
I don't mind the scars behind my ears at all. But you're right, it is painful and glasses do hurt still and i have regretted it every day since. I am sorry you are unhappy too. Sounds like the more i learn the more it's not worth it!
August 5, 2016
then it is not worth ?
February 17, 2018
may I ask why it hurts to wear glasses 10 years post op - I am thinking of getting this done too, but worried about these sorts of things. Thank you!
February 17, 2018
I have no idea why. The pressure i guess on the top where they rest on my ear makes them sore after a while and have to take them off.
February 17, 2018
Perhaps you can email your surgeon and ask him/her if this is normal? x
August 1, 2016
I am the same, I had it done 10 years ago and I want my old ears back. Not only was it so painful but my ears don't match now and the left one is a mess. These surgeons should not touch people's ears.
August 15, 2016
The same thing happened to me and In fact my ears look worse than ever. As well as you I am very self conscious and the otoplasty didn't help much because I still cover my ears.
July 28, 2018
Sorry to hear. Is it because your ear still sticks out or because the cartilage looks strange?
August 15, 2016
OH MY GOD!! I hope you plan to sue!
August 15, 2016
I'm looking into it! Thank you!
January 27, 2017
Start asking around and find a good trial attorney. HE DID NOT KNOW WHAT HE WAS DOING, AND TOOK YOUR MONEY. You should win the case, then have money to find someone for reconstructive surgery. Be proactive. fight for yourself.
February 1, 2017
Yes. He took messes up then took my money & then blew me off after that!
February 1, 2017
** He messed up
UPDATED FROM kimmmy87
27 days post

Pics

kimmmy87

Replies (11)

User Avatar
July 21, 2016
Oh my... So sorry you're going through this. I sure hope he fixes his mistakes and makes it right. Or refunds money.
July 21, 2016
Thank you! I definitely don't want him trying to "fix" it but I am looking for other PS to help once it's healed. I haven't asked for a refund. I'm sure he won't give it to me.
July 26, 2016
You should go at see Dr David Gault, he did my Otoplasty and I could not be happier. When speaking he mentioned he also fixes failed otoplasty
July 26, 2016
Thank you! I will definitely look him up.
User Avatar
July 26, 2016
July 26, 2016
I'm definitely not letting him "fix" the damage the did. If he couldn't do it correctly the first time I just can't imagine that hw could "fix" it. Thanks so much for your message and I'm sorry to hear about your experience as well.
July 31, 2016
ill vouch for David Gault UK he might be able to improve them he is the king of ear deformities, but the damage has been done and no surgeon will be able to make them how they was.Be carefull as things can get worse if you go to the wrong surgeon.
July 31, 2016
I've had a few people recommend him, thank you!
UPDATED FROM kimmmy87
1 month post

5 weeks update

kimmmy87
It's been just over 5 weeks now and they are still sore of course and a numb at the tops of my ears. My temples just above my ears hurt for some reason and i can't turn my head all the way to the left. The skin back there I'm assuming was stitched too tightly so when i do it pulls and is very uncomfortable. The only part of my eaf that really hurts anymore (unless bumped or touched) is the excess skin on the inside. The part that isn't even spposed to be there. They throb sometimes at the end of the day, middle of the night and in the mornings :/ i don't sleep elevated anymore but i do have ro sleep on a donut pillow every night ao i can put my head on the top of the pillow and my ear through the hole part. I still wear the headwrap at night in case i accidently lay on or fold one. I still can't exercise (it was my favorite thing to do) or go outside too long because they start to swell up still. The problem with all this is that even though i know it's not, he tells me I'm fine and sends me out the door in less than a couple minutes q+with no other information than that. So i have no idea if I'm healing normal or not. The PA, Elisa, never even responded to my last concern about my stitches and skin.

Replies (2)

User Avatar
July 30, 2016
They aren't going to respond in an acceptable manner. They will continue their practice of Elisa apologizing for his behavior and poor bedside manner and he pretending everything is ok and just fine to get you out the door. You will find no remedy whatsoever in the office. I would begin now searching for another PS to check your progress and make plans for correction. I am so very sorry this has happened to you.
July 30, 2016
That's exactly what's happening, you're right about that. I have other consultations set up with different PS already so they tell me the truth and I'm doing all the research I can still on fighting it. Thank you for your comments.