Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Facelift Reviews REVIEWS

Horrible Results - Smithtown, NY

ORIGINAL POST

I went to Dr. Marotta in March 2013 for a...

Dannapolis
$20,000
I went to Dr. Marotta in March 2013 for a facelift, chin implant and upper eyelift. I was 54 years old and already looked 45 before the procedure. Dr. Marotta suggested a fat transfer to my lower eyelid to fill in a hollow. I agreed. My final results were this: No perceivable difference for facelift. The goal was to get back my jawline. This didn't happen. As far as the eyelift, again, no perceivable difference. I still have fatty deposits near the corners of my eyes and hooding in my eyelids. The only difference I see are scars. As far as the chin implant, I now have a horizontal line across my chin where the muscle is pulling and you can see where the implant was inserted. The lower portion of my mouth looks like a ventriloquist's doll. The worst part, however, were the fat injections. Not only did Dr. Marotta put them in the hollow of my eye, but he filled up my cheeks. It was horrible and I was told that it would take a year to see the actual results. I waited the full year for things to "settle" and still look like a chipmunk. Worse is that the fat injections under my eyes have turned into lumps, as scar tissue has encapsulated them. In addition, my face is not asymmetrical. I have been to Dr. Marotta for follow-up visits over the last year and a half with my complaints and he says there is nothing he can do for me. He insists that my face was already lopsided and says he's sorry that I'm not happy. I have just gone to another doctor to try to balance out my face. He is giving me a "cocktail" of injections to my bloated cheeks to try to melt some of the fat. In addition he is injecting Juverderm in the other side of my face to give me balance. I've had to get Botox injections by my chin to reduce the horizontal line of the chin implant. However I still have jowls and hooding. I spent $20,000 with Dr. Marotta and am now spending thousands more to look normal with another doctor. It's been a year and a half and acquaintances still don't recognize me because of the bloated cheeks I was given. The look is very much like "ET". NEVER GET FAT PUT INTO YOUR FACE!!! It is a complete guessing game for a doctor as to how much will be reabsorbed by your body and where it will ultimately settle. Also be sure you find a doctor that will make things right when they go wrong.

Dannapolis's provider

James C. Marotta, MD

James C. Marotta, MD

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

4.9 | 610 Reviews
PROFILE

Dannapolis rating for Dr. Marotta:

Overall rating
Answered my questions
After care follow-up

Replies (56)

November 21, 2014
Are you sure it is a crap shoot as to how much will be absorbed and where it will ultimately take and where it will ultimately be absorbed? Because you know women by the droves are having fat transfer at the same time they have their face lift. So the doc puts the fat in ( the fat you just said is a crap shoot as to whether it lasts and where) and then they pull and tighten the face around the fat that is the crap shoot. BUT .....when it all needs fixing later~ they can offer another round of crap-shoot fat or fillers for life to even out where the fat didn't take. As to whether the face lift will be tight enough....well, hey, they can do a revision maybe for 1/2 price! What could be better, right?????
November 21, 2014
After I complained to Dr. Marotta, he said that he had expected my body to absorb and discard 50% of the fat, so he had overfilled. My body absorbed and discarded nothing. However one side of my face seems to have held more. He told me that my underlying muscle and tissue was different on that side and that's why my face is now asymmetrical. That is a bunch of BS, because another doctor is working on getting me balanced. However I am still not recognized in my community after 1 1/2 years. However Dr. Marotta believes he did a fine job and has not offered me any resolutions.
November 22, 2014
Just wondering if you have gained any significant weight since the fat transfer. Whatever fat cells remained after transfer are subject to retaining fat with weight gain. If the fat cells of the stomach balloon in size with weight gain then when they are placed in the face the same phenomenon is going to happen.
November 22, 2014
Good question. My weight fluctuates up and down 5 pounds, but nothing significant.
User Avatar
November 21, 2014
Sorry to hear that! You are right You look different. I hope everything works out for you.
November 21, 2014
Thank you. It has been a very upsetting and depressing experience for me.
User Avatar
November 21, 2014

Thank you very much for sharing your experience!

November 22, 2014
Thank you for posting my story.
November 22, 2014
So sorry you aren't happy. I'm hearing more and more to never put fat in the face. Did the doctor explain why you still have jowls? Did he offer a revision? Or any other solution?
November 22, 2014
I asked Dr. Marotta why I still have jowls. I told him I didn't think he "lifted" enough. Of course he told me he did as much as he could. However, I can see that he did barely anything. This has been confirmed to me by two other surgeons I have recently seen. He did not offer a revision or any other solution.
User Avatar
November 22, 2014
The main correction from a facelift is the neck and jawline. If you didn't see that then your dr didn't do a correct facelift procedure. Can you file a complaint with his licensing entity? I am so sorry you have gone through this, it's very scary. XO
November 22, 2014
I will look into a complaint with his licensing entity as well as small claims court for each component of my surgery so I don't spend a fortune in legal fees. It is scary. This doctor gets great reviews from most of his patients, which is why I chose him. I guess he had a bad day with me. I also have worse marionette lines than before the surgery, probably from the fat cheeks weighing on them. After returning to this doctor every couple of months to re-address my issues and getting no support or help from him, I have decided to move on and am considering my next options.
UPDATED FROM Dannapolis
1 year post

Additional photos to horrible results

Dannapolis

Replies (24)

User Avatar
November 22, 2014
Can't see your chin and neck in this after pic, but what I can see looks very good imo. Not so different as the first pic except more youthful and no eye shadow or lipstick. And eyes look bigger after, which is considered a youthful trait.
November 24, 2014
I am sorry you are disappointed with your results but I must say that I think you look terrific. I like the results of your surgery.
November 25, 2014
IMO your post op pics look great. You look much younger with smooth firm skin. The hooding over your eyes is gone as well and I don't see any jowls anymore.
User Avatar
November 26, 2014
I don't see a lot of difference in the 2 pictures but all that should matter is that you are satisfied because this is no a cheap surgery by any means .
UPDATED FROM Dannapolis
1 year post

Post Op

Dannapolis

Replies (0)