Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Smart Lipo REVIEWS

BE CAREFUL - Not Worth It with Anyone but a Trained Liposuction Surgeon

ORIGINAL POST

This review is for anyone considering Smartlipo...

bowling babe
$4,300

This review is for anyone considering Smartlipo.  I'm not anti-smartlipo, but this procedure is significantly misrepresented by Cynosure, the maker of the smartlipo machine and publisher of the brochures, along with many doctors who should NOT be anywhere near this device.  I'm one of the unlucky ones who got a quack in Batavia, New York that thinks he's an expert since he took the EIGHT HOUR COURSE that Cynosure gives and sends ANY DOCTOR, NOT MATTER WHAT THEIR FIELD, out to alter someone's body. 

I'm also one of the lucky ones who lives near a doctor who's considered one of the best smartlipo surgeons in the east.  Yes, I SHOULD have gone to him first, but he's already fixed three others from the quack I went to and has assured me that I can be "fixed".  I'll have to go one more summer without feeling good about my legs, but I won't have to worry about it for next year.  I won't bore you with the details of my procedure, but below is a list of things that you might want to know before you go out to talk to a doctor about having this done.   I'm going to speak to having legs done.

1.  Smartlipo is NOT a lunchtime procedure.  It is liposuction surgery with a laser.  A good surgeon will tell you that.  It is the next wave of liposuction and is quickly taking the place of the old method.  The laser does help in tightening the skin and the tumescent (wet) procedure reduces bruising, pain and swelling WHEN IT'S DONE PROPERLY.  You should have the maximum fluid used for your body weight and should not have more than 2-3 areas done at once.  Example:  inner thighs, anterior thighs and knees in one procedure, then outer thighs and abdomen or gluteal crease in the next procedure.  These should be done about 7 days to 1 month apart.   This is a health precaution as well as a results precaution.

2.  You will be home laying around the house for about three days and draining for about 24-72 hours and have to wear a compression garment for 2-6 weeks, depending on what you have done, for the best results.   Some people don't wear the garment, but I found it sped up the healing process, which is making it easier for me to get my corrective surgery done sooner.  You're going to be sore for about three months, gradually getting better the whole time, but still sore.  you'll have lumps and bumps in your legs for that long, too, again, gradually getting better.  You'll need to massage those areas and seriously look into Lymphatic Drainage Massage.  IT WORKS WONDERS.

3.  THE DOCTOR.  This is probably the most important advice I have for you.  Do not, do not, do not, go to a doctor that does not do this as his only line of business.  Do not use a pediatrician, a general doctor, an ear, nose and throat doctor - get my point??  Do not use any doctor that has added this to his practice and sandwiches your smartlipo inbetween allergy shots and annual physicals.  The only training required by law to do this is the EIGHT HOUR course that Cynosure gives after the doctor purchases the machine.  OH, I forgot, they offer two more eight hour courses for ADVANCED training.  Think about it - 24 hours of training lets any MD start to reshape your body with absolutely no previous cosmetic experience.  Don't do it.  Run away.  Fast.

4.  Do your research and make the commitment to yourself to get the very best.  Save your money, get the best deal on a credit card, make sure you have enough time off from work.  You're worth it.  I am planning my time off, how much it will cost me for gas and hotel (My "Good" doctor is two hours away) and what I'll use for time off at work.  I should have done this the first time, but again, I'm very lucky to be able to do it right the second time.  This is something I've wanted for about 10 years and I'm not going to screw it up again. 

5.  Once you've got your resources together, only look at board certified plastic surgeons, OR, doctors who have proven skills and track records IN THE AREAS YOU WANT TREATED.  This is a wonderful website, and it probably saved me from going back to the quack and letting him try to fix me (he told me could, but I got a full refund instead) but I would direct you to liposuction.com.  It's a great place to gather all the info you'll need to be well informed about your procedure and what can and can't be done.  There's also a great page with a list of questions to ask the doctors - you will want to interview at least two, if not three - that you're considering using.

6.  The most important questions you can ask are, "How long have you been doing this procedure on the areas I want treated and how many have you done?", "How do you determine where to sculpt and contour?" and lastly, "Can I have three references that I can call that have had the same areas done?".  Don't gloss over any answers that you're not totally comfortable with, and if they cannot give you three references, thank them and never call them back.  Any doctor who is good at this will have several happy customers who would love to tell you how happy they are.

7.  Be an active particpant in the procedure.  Let the doctor know excactly what you want and don't let him say "I know what to do" before you lay on that table.  If he gives you a hard time, say thank you, get up, get dressed and get out.  It's your body. 

I hope this helps someone.  Again,  I'm not anti-smartlipo, but I've learned a very valuable lesson about cosmetic surgery and the makers of the machines that assist with it.  I'm looking forward to my next surgery and am thanking God that I'm able to come out of this OK.  I'd love to hear from others.  Also, I'd like to thank Julie7 on this site.  Her comments and review along with all those who wrote in helped me get to this point tonight.  


bowling babe's provider

Dr. Idrees, Batavia, NY

Replies (31)

June 10, 2008
Hey Thanks for your story and wow!! You covered it nicely for folks out there running to get fixed up by this lunchtime procedure. Everything you said is accurate and difinitely helpful for someone seeking out to do the treatment. Can I see what happened to you? And would you mind letting me know who is going to fix you? Or could you review my story under Unattrative Result and tell me if I look like something your doctor could help me with??? I don't want to have to pay for a mistake for the rest of my life. I really do feel deformed now. I understand having a deformity. I an accept that. But a self-inflicted One? That's the part I am having a hard time with. I trusted my doctor and I feel as though he let me down. After paying for the thing and meeting in person, I learned that it really was lipo but couldn't get a refund or I would have. I basically considered myself stuck. Thanks again for puting your information out there to help others. You are truly paying it forward. You are a good person.
June 13, 2008
Hi ND, I've read your review and was horrifed about what happened to you. I am very sorry for your experience. In fact, it was after reading your write-up a few weeks ago that I got the nerve to pursue my total refund. One thing we as women need to do more - stand up to any professional when we have questions and tell them "no" when it doesn't feel right. I'm never going to let this happen to me again. In fact, I've called my new doctor twice to get references. They told me they're calling clients right now, but it's hard to get people to agree to discuss this procedure and I can relate to that. But they need to find me at least two or I'm not going to use them. They promised to get me some info by next week. I really can't speak to what my new doctor could or could not do for you, but the wavy area on the side of your leg looks similar to one of my areas that will be corrected. I don't have pictures but I can tell you that 90% of my issues are shaping and contouring on the outer thighs. The Quack just sucked out fat without blending into untouched areas. I don't mind telling you that I was absolutely terrifed when I went to meet Dr. F. (New, Good Doctor). I was afraid he was going to take one look at me and say I was a lost cause. I almost cried tears of joy when I showed him my legs and he immediately began to say what needed to be done and how he'd do it. He looked at one area and said, "You've got to feather this in,just like a professional painter joining old and new paint so no one can tell where one area ends and the other begins. I can't believe he didn't do that". Then he realized who he was talking about and said, "well, he's a quack." That's where I got the nickname. I am reluctant to give Dr. F.'s full name on this site since I got a strange e-mail asking for the new doctor I'm going to. I have a funny feeling it's from the Quack's office or wife. When we met with him to get my refund, he demanded to know what doctor I was going to use and I wouldn't tell him. I'd also like to wait until after my first corrective surgery before I give out his name, just to make sure I'm OK. Don't want to jinx myself. Feel free to e-mail me. I know how it feels to think you're the only one with this issue. And by the way, I can certainly understand how you view yourself, but from what I see in your pictures, your legs look pretty good for the most part. I can't imagine that someone worth their salt can't make some adjustments to make your feel much better.
June 18, 2008
Hello, I am planning to have Smart Lipo done on my abdomen next month. The only affordable price I was able to find just happens to be in Batavia. Would you mind telling me if the Doctor I am using is the "Quack" you encountered? This Doctor is Dr. {edited}. I really don't know alot about him, other than the basic information I was able to gather on the internet. Thus far, I haven't come across anything negative. I am going in for my consultation this week, and plan to schedule the procedure for the end of next month. Any advice you can provide would be greatly appreciated. Thank you for sharing your experience. It is very helpful to those of us who are new to all of this, and are still in the decision making phase. Editor note: You must be contacted privately to receive the information you requested. This requires free registration for an account. When registering, you must opt-in to receive private messages (a check box).
June 20, 2008
CW, The Quack in Batavia is a pediatrician and the only Dr. in Batavia that does smart lipo. I can't speak to his stomach lipo skills but if you're looking for an opinion, I'd wait and save some more money to go to someone else. To give you an idea of what your procedure might be like with him, I felt everything and was in pain most of the time. Twice I cried out and he ignored me both times. When the procedure was done it was obvious that my legs weren't even but he tossed his gown off, got me bandaged and tossed me out the door into the mall. His staff isn't geared toward lipo, they're geared toward kids. Nice people, but not the supportive kind I learned I want behind me in a procedure like this. When my husband and I went to get my refund from him, he was more concerned about pointing out that I signed the release and telling me where I was wrong instead of admitting that he didn't blend and contour any of the areas he touched. He's never done lipo before he bought the machine. I was stupid to go to him and lucky to be in as good a shape as I am. There's a Dr. in Williamsville that I talked to. His office staff leaves something to be desired but he's a plastic surgeon, not a doctor looking to make free and clear cash on the side. The doctor I'm working with right now is opening an office in Rochester, NY this fall so there's another option. As for not finding anything negative, you won't find anything officially negative on the internet about a doctor in New York State unless a complaint has been officially filed with the NYS Office of Standards and Practices AND the doctor has been cited. Any complaints that aren't found to be "true" are never published. I'm sitting here rubbing my legs, thinking about my corrective surgery. Think real hard about using Batavia Medical Laser Center.
July 20, 2008
Hi bowlingbabe, I'm a guy who lives near Batavia and am considering Smartlipo for my breasts. Please let me know how you like your new doctor, and if you're comfortable with it, his name. Want to find a good local doctor for this! Thanks.
August 4, 2008
Hi "BBG", sorry it took me so long to get back to you. the doctor's name is {edited} in Utica, NY, at Rejuvenate Medispa. If you call, please tell them Roberta R. gave yo utheir name. Good luck! Editor note You must contact the user privately to share provider information. To contact another user click their username.
August 12, 2008

I am considering smart lipo with a DR in Utica, NY at Medspa min a few weeks. Anything good or bad about this DR.?

August 18, 2008

If you're referring to {edited} on Genesee Street in Utica, He's the doctor I've been writing about that's doing my corrections in less and a month.  You can read my comments about the references I got and the consultations I've had with him.  I'm very confident about his skills from everything I've researched.  I would be very interested in your experience with the office and Dr. F in general.  Please let me know, and thanks in advance for your info.

 

Editor note: You must contact users privately to share this information. To contact another user privately, click on their username.

 

 

October 6, 2008
Hello Bowling Babe and others who are considering using this Dr. in the mini mall in Batavia. I have to admit that I was one of his victims. I first went in Oct 97 for a abdomen lipo and waited until april 08 before I was determined that no results had occured. Mind you, I am an educated individual (PhD) and I thought I knew all the right questions to ask. He told me he had done several of the procedures before, and even some men. When I called the office to complain they told me I was his first male to have this procedure and I would have to speak with him directly. He was rude on the phone and stated I needed to come in and see him. When I arrived, he lifted up my shirt and said, "It looks much better to me!" Then I reminded him and showed him my before picture and he finally agreed to do the procedure again which he did. This time I directed him how much fat i wanted to see in the tube before I left as I had researched this in detail. The staff tried to be accomodating. However, they kept opening the door exposing me lying there in my underwear, they didn't know how to use the razer for prepping. I screamed in pain a few times and he completely ignored me (And I have a high tolerance for pain). I would not recommend him to anyone!
October 10, 2008
Chub Guy, I am pursuing legal action against "Dr. Mini Mall" Would you be willing to talk with me and possibly join me in it? Let me know.
October 17, 2008
i have just had my upper and lower abdomen done and i'm not sure if i'm gonna look deformed or not! starting to be worried. first of all, there was NO INDICTION of the actual process in the literature i was given!i was completely unprepared and horrified at the whole process. i looked thinner at the office immediately after the surgery but started to swell the next day...she said i would but she did not elude to the fact that i would look even bigger than before the procedure. it was done on a saturday and by thursday, i looked as if i would explode...literally! she assured me that this was normal...i am now three weeks post-op and now my main complaint is the hardness. even though i look less lumpy, i have strange deposits of hard "fat'? i start the morning pretty flat and during the work day, ANYwhere my clothing touches..waistband, zipper, etc. becomed a huge indention or extrusion to the point that i look very deformed by the time i am able to get my clothes off in the evening. i have faithfully worn the compression garments and purchased a couple of extra so i am never without. please let me know if you have had any of this experience and if it will fix itself...i was NEVER told that i might need a second surgery or touch-up. she just says i will be back in a bikini soon. my kids are graduating and i don't even feel the need to be perfect again at my age, just wanted to feel better about myself and look good for my husband...i am really hoping i havent made a big mistake..........please help!
October 18, 2008
Dizzy, I have had all of the same symptoms that you describe. At almost 6 weeks post op that is finally starting to go away. I only have a narrow band just below my belly button that is still hard. The swelling at the end of the day is LESS - but still there. You have another experience to go through yet - nerve pain - extrememely sensitive to the touch, tingly or sunburned feeling (it's nasty) but that too is getting less. It's easier if you know what to expect - I think - so you don't imagine something is not quite right. FYI - i went out and bought a couple of pairs of maternity pants for those couple of weeks that I just could not stand wearing a waist band. "It hurts to be beautiful"
October 30, 2008
my abdominal lumps are getting more pronounced........
October 30, 2008
Bowling babe, I would consider legal action.How do we exchange information? i only live about 20 miles from Batavia. have you spoken to anyone legal yet? -- Editor note: This user can be contacted privately by clicking on their username.
June 20, 2008
Hello, Thank you so much for shedding some light on all of this for me. As I explained, I am very new to this, and information is often limited, with regard to the specific doctors themselves. I will definitely be doing a little more "shopping around" before I make my final decision. Good luck with your corrective procedure. Thanks again. Take care.
July 2, 2008
Just an update - Spoke with all four references from Dr F's office and am very happy with the info I got. All are thrilled with their entire experience there and are happy with their results. Three of them had the same areas done that I'm getting corrected and both say what a great job the Dr. did with contouring and blending, and touchups are included and expected to make sure you're even and happy with your results. - Met with the traditional lipo doctor today just to cover all my bases. Not at all impressed with his lack of knowledge of smart lipo procedure and results. Kept telling me that I shouldn't worry and that it will take 6-12 months for my results to show. Obviously doesn't know about the much shorter results time for smart lipo. Also told me that pain would last that long. I'm not in any pain anymore, just a little sore to the touch in a couple of spots still. I'm definitely sticking with my new smart lipo doctor in Utica, NY.
July 7, 2008
Hi bowling babe, Can you tell me who dr F, the good smartlipo surgeon you went to and where he is located as I would like to get the surgery myself on my thighs. Can you tell me how you went. Regards kh
July 9, 2008
DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY! I had the procedure done @ Medical Spas of Houston..MAJOR LIARS! They will nag you before the procedure to snatch your money..then after you realize it doesnt work..the're going to advise you to wait for the "Magic" results..Uhmmm several months later-no change. Yes I excercise. Yes I eat right. Yes I brought Spinx (garment they use to make you think you are losing anything but very minimal 2-4 lbs water weight that comes right back). After procedure: you are on your own! Procedure is NOT a lunch time miracle, Procedure is messy. Yo
July 16, 2008
hi mandi-- just today i went in to see "the country's most sought after" smartlipo doctor. without giving his name, was your procedure done by him at his office on west tc jester in the galleria area of houston? i am in the medical profession and his office staff left me a bit aghast and concerned...i didn't even see the physician, just an advanced practice nurse and a pr person about the procedure. conclusion...LAME at best.
July 16, 2008
Luis, Good catch on your observations. This is a great example of who not to use. You should always speak at length with the doctor performing your procedure. This is a big decision and shouldn't be handled by the second string team.
August 28, 2008
hey mandi-- sorry for the long time to respond. than so much for your reply. before i got your reply i had already decided against the procedure. i hope that you are doing better and are recovering. take care. if you need anyone to talk to or need any medical advise, feel free to contact me at any time. luis
UPDATED FROM bowling babe

UPDATE  - AUGUST 7th - Something else that's...

bowling babe

UPDATE  - AUGUST 7th - Something else that's very important for everyone considering smartlipo to know - Even those who get happy with the procedure are not completely happy with their first results, no matter how good the doctor is.  This is not bad, just honest.  It appears that a few bumps and lumps will show up during recovery and they'll need to be fixed.  Almost every post here gives credit to that. 

A good doctor will tell you that you will probably need a touch-up, or even two, due to the fact that while he/she will do their best, you will have a lot of fluid in your legs/stomach/whereever and it is almost impossible to get a 100% smooth result the first time. 

NOW - this is different from having major issues, such as mine for example.  I consider 12-inch ridges down the front of both my thighs and sharp indentations at the top of both NOT to be touch-ups, but screw-ups.  If I did not have those, the small lumps in the other areas might have been acceptable, but I believe all touch-ups should be minor.  Contouring and blending are not negotiable. 

Replies (47)

August 7, 2008
Bowling Babe has some very good advice for choosing your SmartLipo physician. However, the technique that your physician uses, eg. tumescent (as described above) or non-tumescent, is not important. Whether they have prior liposuction experience or not is not important. This is an inherently different modality and applying traditional liposuction techniques will lead to unreliable results. Board certification in plastic surgery is not important. As with any type of therapy the most important physician traits are experience with the device and knowledge of its (and their own) limitation. Beware the physician that has only one tool because that is all you are going to get.
August 9, 2008
Please "Dr. John." I hope people are keen enough to tell that your post is total BS.
August 11, 2008
At first, I advised everyone to disregard "Dr. John's" comments. I think I was a bit hasty. Please read them and pay attention to the tone. I get a strong sense of a doctor who has added smart lipo to his general practice, who does the procedure and is a bit nervous about his business being affected by bad press and word of mouth. He seems very concerned with defending practioners that don't have any background in cosmetic surgery and speaks contrary to what I have read on the official liposuction site used and supported by cosmetic surgeons. This is very perplexing to me. I think it's a really good example of what to listen for and watch out for when interviewing your smart lipo doctor. And ladies, that's what we are doing. Keep in mind that we are the "employer" and the doctor has to convince us that he/she would be the best "employee" for the job. And that means that references and credentials are non-negotiable. For me, experience in body contouring and a fine hand coupled with a passion for perfection is the only standard a woman should accept for anyone touching her body to make changes on it. References are non-negotiable and you should get at least three if not more. I'm trained on a calculator, but you certainly don't want me to do your taxes. We are putting our lives in someone else's hands and we should be very assertive when it comes to expectations. And, ladies, we need to realize that we may decide that a certain procedure just isn't what it's cracked up to be and that it's not going to work for us. Do not to let some doctor talk you into it because his son's or daughter's college tuition is due and he needs the cash.
August 12, 2008

I just wanted to comment on all of ur valuable info, Im not from NY nor am I even looking to have Smart Lipo done, I started reading ur post and found it so informative for people I just had to comment and thank you for taking the time to help others.  Thanks!

(unregistered guest)
August 27, 2008
Is there anyone out there that can recommend a GOOD dr. in Houston? I'm going for a consult tomorrow and I'm not sure I'm going to the right guy after reading something from someone else's email (TC Jester/Galleria area.) Comments?
September 2, 2008
Hi CE, not sure if you have had this done or not but I had SmartLipo done this past Thursday by {edited} and I HIGHLY recommend him. He and his staff were awesome and my procedure was painfree. The shots in the beginning were the only slight pain I had. I had my upper and lower abs and flanks done. They have offices all over town but the procedure is done at their Bellaire office. Feel free to contact me with any questions you might have. Good Luck, ~Sarthur Editor note Provider information is located in this users original review.
User Avatar
September 12, 2008
so did you like your results?
June 2, 2010
hi, i was woundering if there have being any changes in yr result. and i would like to know where u had urs done
June 4, 2010
I had my Smart Lipo done in Duluth, GA, It has been 11 weeks and I have seen a lot of improvement. I still have some hardness and just had my 3rd Dermassage which was part of my lipo package. The doctor keeps telling me it takes 3-6 months before you see final results. I just came back from the beach and wore a bikini top for the first time in many years and I felt I looked pretty good and my husband agreed. He keeps saying that I feel so much smaller. It has definately been worth all the pain and cost even though , the results have been slow coming, and I'm planning on doing my outer thighs in the fall.
May 9, 2016
I'm having surgery by Dr louis cole in june can you please tell me how your results are now. Nervous
May 9, 2016
I'm having surgery by Dr louis cole in june can you please tell me how your results are now. Nervous
August 29, 2008
Thanks for posting about your bad & good experiences with SmartLipo! I live in central NY and am strongly considering the procedure on my abdomen and possibly buttock. Could someone recommend a good doctor for this procedure? Thanks, Shan Ps. What is the cost for this procedure on those areas?
August 29, 2008
I am not sure about this procedure, but it looks a lot less invasive then traditional lipo and the claims of tightening the skin interest me a whole lot! How much does it really tighten the skin? Can someone recommend a really good doctor in the central/upstate new york area? Specifically for the abdomen! Thanks
September 2, 2008
Shan, My doctor is in Utica, NY. The others are in Buffalo
September 2, 2008
Has anyone in Maryland had Smart Lipo done by {edited} in Hunt Valley Maryland? Editor note: To make or request doctor recommendations, please visit our Doctor Recommendation Forums.