Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty Reviews

I Hate My Nose Job Results

ORIGINAL POST

I Hate My Nose Job Results

$7,500
Simply put, I hate the results of my nose job (rhinoplasty). Dr. Hilinsky seems like an intelligent, experienced professional, and the Harvard credentials help to sell his ability, but when it came to delivering results, he just couldn't do it. $7,500 and 9 months of having a fat swollen nose just to have less confidence than I had before. I regret to say it was the worst decision I have ever made in my life. I tried waiting and giving him the benefit of the doubt, but at this point (2 years later) it is clear my nose is done healing and no changes are going to happen. It's time to stop being polite and tell the truth about how I feel. That's what this website is for right? The truth.
A refund would be appreciated but I guess this is one of those industries that doesn't believe in accountability. To be honest, I feel like if they paid me $50K for my investment plus suffering, I would still be in the red. What makes it so frustrating is that my case was a very simple, small change and my nose looks the same as before from the side and a little bit fatter in the front. Not only was it not improved, it was made worse. It truly boggles my mind how this operation went wrong.
Choose a doctor who is a perfectionist with plenty of experience. Credentials do not matter. I believe the cause of failure in my case was simply a lack of perfectionism and attention to detail. He has a lot of great results on his website, unfortunately, I don't get to be one of them. Of course he will never advertise the bad results and only he will ever know the real success rate that he has. In the end, he is just a businessman obsessed with increasing his wealth like almost every other man on the planet. I just can't understand why such wealthy "professionals" would not want to provide refunds for work that they failed to complete as promised. This is one very backwards industry. I know that when I fail to deliver for my clients, I either redo the work until they are satisfied or provide a full refund and I don't get paid a fraction of what this guy gets paid for an hour of his time.
Side note: my nose was noticeably fat and swollen for 6-9 months after surgery and wasn't completely healed until over a year. Most doctors, including Dr Hilinsky, will tell you that your nose will be swollen for 2 weeks and you can go back to work and nobody will notice. That could not be farther from the truth. I could have been unlucky having to wait 6-9 months, but my research shows that my case is the rule and not the exception.

sdjack's provider

John M. Hilinski, MD

John M. Hilinski, MD

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

4.6 | 86 Reviews
PROFILE
Overall rating

Replies (5)

I got a revision done by Dr. yoo in San Diego about 6 months ago and he did a horrible job .
Really? Wow! I have heard amazing things about Yoo. After years of researching and a revision with Davis in Miami, I can say that every surgeon has unhappy patients and bad results. It's sad when it's us.
Hi Candysway, are you referring to Dr. Donald Yoo from the Botched series?!! I'm supposed to meet with him soon and I'm quite nervous.
What is the Botched series???!!! Where can I see it?? Thanks! Mk
Really? I wanted to schedule a consult. I feel like there aren't many good rhinoplasty surgeons in San Diego. I might have to find one out of state or county.
And, Yes! Don't be fooled by credentials esp Harvard!!! I've already consulted with several Harvard affiliated rhinoplasty surgeons and I'm not impressed. At least one of them had the decency to say that he'd recommend I see someone else.
It was Dr. Sirius Yoo in San Diego
I know it's going to cost and there will be another yr till you get the results you want to find a surgeon who specializes in rhinoplasty revisions, how many they've done, the results, and in particular to your ethnicity. Have at least 5 consultations and let them tell you what they think went wrong and how they will fix it without you uttering a word and that will be your revision surgeon. Don't let cost be the determinant factor or how many board certifications they have or how big and nice they're office is. Only expertise should be the determining factor. Good luck!
It is distressing to hear about disappointing procedure results. Patients put a lot of time, effort, and money into this process, all for end results that will make them smile. We know that not every patient will be 100 percent satisfied with their results, but that doesn’t stop us from reaching for that goal. In keeping with that, Dr. Hilinski absolutely is a perfectionist with countless satisfied patients. Moreover, years of experience and hefty credentials back up his skills. On that note, we ask readers not ignore a physician’s credentials no matter what procedure or treatment you are pursuing. Those are important qualifications for any patient to be aware of.

When it comes to patient satisfaction, Dr. Hilinski and his staff are proud of their many success stories. However, mutual communication from patients both before and after a procedure is vital to achieving desired results. There’s only so much that can be done if a patient does not reach out. Whenever a patient is not yet satisfied, we are committed to helping them reach their goals. If a revision is appropriate, we tend to waive most surgeon fees for revisions. Anesthesia and facility costs would still apply, but this policy is extremely competitive and fair among the industry. We'd be happy to consult more directly with any patient who has concerns about their results and can be contacted at our office.

what kind of a nose job is this???

I say this based on the post op photo OP has posted, i dont know how his nose looked like before but post results are just not acceptable.
I totally agree. I’m sorry he is going through this.
Can I thumb your comment you up?
In fairness to Dr. H, I had a very positive experience with him when he did my lip lift. Lovely results and I enjoyed him as a person as well. Maybe he had an off day? There are no Before photosso it’s hard to say, but from the one After photo posted, this patient’s upset is warranted. Why not consult with other nose specialists? Second and third opinions can offer hope.