Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty Reviews

Grossly asymmetrical nostrils & breathing worse than pre-surgery

UPDATED FROM Gmnkn
7 months post

Update

$10,001
My nose started to bleed and this happens daily, also it started to smell ready bad. I called the office and left voice messages and never heard back.
I was told that I will get an appointment but this is an emergency and I think it needs immediate attention.
In my voicemail I asked them to get back in touch as soon as they can, because I am worried that is smells Very bad and I hope it's not an infection - no response. I asked for a referral multiple times and no answer.
Has anyone had this issue? I am scheduling an appointment with another surgeon, because I am very worried it's serious. I can't be seen until Wednesday (with another surgeon) and they left me without an answer for the 4 day weekend...Very worried about my heart at this point.

Gmnkn's provider

Stuart H. Bentkover, MD (retired)

Stuart H. Bentkover, MD (retired)

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (5)

You should just go over there if you live near . Sounds like an infection
Hi it could be an infection but i had a vile smell from my nose and my surgeon Lucian Ion said this happens to a lot of patients and is part of the healing. However I must stress he did check mine and said it was not an infection and would eventually go. Yours should be checked I dont know what your surgeon is playing at. Hope you okay x
Thank you so much! Yes, your surgeon sounds amazing, these guys won't event return my calls. I stressed that I would like them to get back to me and not let me go through 4 day weekend with this. As you said, it can just be nothing or something serious, but since I am not a surgeon or not I have any medical education, all I can do is see another surgeon.
Thank you for the kind words.
Aww I hope you get it sorted it is shocking how you have been treated. Yes Lucian is an amazing surgeon. Hopefully it will just be part of your healing and apparently it is common. x
Hi I'm sorry you are experiencing this. How is everything going?
my nose looks the same. Some really bad scarring too.
Had my appointment and now I need a revision - my worst nightmare.
Thank you for checking in!
From my experience I suggest you talk to other surgeons. Have you considered Dr. Fechner in Worcester. I really hope things get better.
Don't take this the wrong way, but your surgeon isn't behaving post op in a way that I have ever experienced after any surgery! The fact that you did not have a post op appointment that could be scheduled is ridiculous in my opinion. Also, a foul odor should be checked, because it's not uncommon to get an infection in the nose which creates the odor. If it is an infection it will need to be treated. Blood coming out of the nose this far out from surgery is bothersome too.id pay a visit to my primary care physician and let them take a look at that A.S.A.P.
As far as the aesthetics go I can see in your photos why you are upset with the surgical outcome. You mentioned getting a revision in your post and I hope you will inquire with a few more surgeons in your area before proceeding. I would not place my trust in this surgeon again I your shoes. From your account he appears to be unprofessional and incapable. I can't tell you who to see, but I'm in your region and I'd suggest you steer clear of Mass Eye and Ear, because my personal experience there is not good.
I hope you keep posting about your experience and I wish you the best of luck.
How's everything? Any better?
Not yet, looks bad, smells bad, barely breathing.
Look, I hate to be intrusive, but I wholly believe you need to take yourself and your nose to another specialist and get some medical advice and a second opinion A.S.A.P..
UPDATED FROM Gmnkn
5 months post

Looks worse with every passing day and they keep cancelling my appointments

The tittle sums up everything. The swelling is as bad as on day one after the cast was taken off, nostrils are grossly asymmetrical, breathing is worse than pre-surgery.

Haven't been able to get in to see him, they keep cancelling my appointments. At very bad place mentally.
I can't believe this is happening to me, I took so much tome to research and contact other patients and I ended up looking like a freak.

Replies (5)

I had the same experience, did my Rhinoplasty 3 times and the results of each was worse than the one before were, please don't feel bad your not the only one there, you will have another successful one trust yourself
Was yours with dr Bentkover as well?
Was yours Bentkover as well?
Sorry:( I just found dr Nima Shemirani's profile. Looks promising.
No, but they all are the same. Before the surgery they need your money so they are pleasent and assuring, after the surgery and handing the money; they know you need them so they run away and make excuses like: your nose was worse and we fixed it, your nose was bla bla bla..
Yes it is. Dr.Nima Shemirani is Iranian I guess, these are most artistic in Rhynoplasty
So sorry you are going through this. What is the reason that this guy is telling you as to why you can see him? The truth is, he ought to get you into his office right away. You should be a PRIORITY. He may offer to try to fix it, maybe even for free, but I'd be reluctant to let him do the revision. I think its time to start seeking out a skilled revision specialist. Honestly, because of your result you might have a shot at getting a refund. Best of luck in your journey. You're not alone. Lots of us are suffering with you.
Go see Dr. Ion. He'll correct your nasal structure back to normal. He's the best in the world. Just read his reviews.
I agree some person!
I wouldn't go back to him. My mother had a surgery with him around the same time as you, her results left her very unhappy and she hasn't been able to get an appointment. Apparently his health has been off lately and he hasn't been able to work. It's still sketchy, you should seek out another professional.
Have you had any luck contacting Dr Bentkover? I had my primary rhinoplasty with him a little over a year ago and am also really unhappy. My new nose is disproportionately short, wide, and and overly grafted. I've been trying to get into see him as well, but was told that he had some kind of medical emergency. Very frustrating.
Yes, I was able to speak with him, once he was back in the office, after his medical emergency. They didn't set an appointment yet, I am assuming that they have a list of patience, waiting to be seen, since he was out for a while.
UPDATED FROM Gmnkn
2 months post

I took 10 years to make sure I choose the right surgeon and this was my biggest fear..

Once the swelling went down, all the issues became obvious, my nose is pointing to the right, left nostril is much smaller than the right one, columella is not even, longer on one side..
Follow up appointment is in 2 weeks, I will post an update.

Replies (3)

sending positive vibes .I had opposite reaction .I absolutely hated the way I looked at cast removal .My entire face was still swollen and I told him to tape it up immediately because I didn't want to look at it anymore. Now I like it more and more just under 30 days .I hope that he can fix it if it isn't a matter of uneven swelling .If not look at Jason Hamilton .He wasn't my doctor but I decided early on if I needed a revision I would be going to him. Hope it's just swelling
Thank you so much! I will look at your doctor, right now I think it will need a revision but have to wait at least to a year. Feeling okay now, there are options:)
Give it time. My nose isn't perfect either but a major improvement over the original. I think a lot of it is uneven swelling that comes and goes... if you decide to consider revision down the road, I recommend Dr. Denenberg in Omaha. Take care.
Thank you! After msg many kind comments I am feeling optimistic and hoping it is the swelling and I will not need another surgery:) Thank you for your kind words and the recommendation.
How did your follow-up go? Can you update us please? Or feel free to send me a pm :) Thanks!
I haven't been able to make an appointment yet. As soon as I do, I will post. It's still looking not so hot.