Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty Reviews

Worst experience with a doctor, shocked & devastated

ORIGINAL POST

Worst experience with a doctor ever

Melchicago
Let me start by saying I had a revision surgery (not with Griffin) that didn’t go well in 2003, so I was entirely careful and concerned about making the right choice with my teenage daughter who has wanted rhinoplasty/septoplasty. I have been on this board almost since it’s inception and have seen and followed so many of your stories. We searched from coast to coast. There were many major names we consulted with, and then we found Dr. Griffin. We loved his photos, followed his pics and posts and met some of his patients online who were absolutely wonderful. We had to meet with him twice virtually during the pandemic. We asked for an imaging (which we got from several other doctors virtually), he said at first it wasn’t legally possible, but then conceded and sent one.
We were not entirely in love with the image as it was not clear and asked him to please do another. The second was very projected, upturned and the radix way too low for our liking. My daughter was concerned about the ‘Whoville’ look of it. I emailed him and sent an imaging that my daughter did that she liked, he said it was possible. We never expected images to be perfect, but deciding on an overall idea with your surgeon is imperative. There was still something about his online photos we kept going back to, so we decided to book surgery June 4th, 2021 expecting to agree on final plan during pre-op. I specifically asked if we were going to go over imaging with the scheduler as my daughter was still concerned about a final plan and wanted to confirm she could see imaging in person with doctor. She said, “Yes”.
We waited several months for surgery, planned, rented a VRBO, took off from work, traveled 6 hours, pre-op visit with pediatrician, pre-op tests, etc. Energy, emotion, so much agony waiting years and finally deciding to do this. You can imagine our joy and overall relief we had finally found someone.
We came to Minneapolis for the surgery 2 days in advance for pre-op meeting (which they then rescheduled for ONE day before because they decided to squeeze in another surgery).
We expected at this pre-op that like most other surgeons we would not only meet him for the first time in person, but get to go over the images so we can understand the surgical plan for the morning. Again, we had been told we WOULD. He begins to seem agitated and says that he has already emailed us two images and that we can see his results from his before and after photos online. We explained that we were hoping to go over images so we can agree on one as we never did. There are a million ways to change a nose, your surgeon should let you know what they are planning. He then proceeds to say, “I have already spent more time on you than any other patient, ever”. I almost died. We just met the man 20 minutes ago (waited an hour and a half for HIM that morning alone, his office also sent us an hour out of the way to the wrong clinic). He already mentioned this once before in an email when I asked about whether insurance covers any of the procedures, but this time floored me (should have been my first red flag. Apparently you are high maintenance if you ask about insurance).
We inquired about deprojection, grafts, nostrils, dorsal hump, etc. and really wanted an image or at least an idea of what the outcome would be. He was vague, changed his answers multiple times, awkward, mentioned we would be picky about every detail, and overall perturbed by our asking. He didn’t even have the two images he actually already DID available for us to see. Which one was he going with? It was a pre-operative meeting, what were we supposed to be doing? He seemed to insinuate that most of his clients just jump in and don’t ask many questions. We were the exception, and obviously unruly type A individuals.
We left the pre-op with no idea of what to expect the next morning, we reached out to the office about our concerns to speak to him that night- they said he would be “unavailable” but could talk for a few minutes before surgery in the morning. We both decided we had no choice but to cancel the surgery (losing $1000 in surgery center fees alone). My daughter was in absolute shock by what transpired. We were devastated after searching for years, planning, meeting, getting there, changing our schedules, paying thousands, the emotional toll of about to go through surgery and someone dismisses you. He couldn’t take 5 minutes to show a child who waited for years and was conscientious enough to see SO many doctors what her nose might look like and go over a plan the day before surgery? She felt both violated and devastated. So did I. The way he responded to me in that office was something my daughter will never forget. We sat in the car in total disbelief.
If you are looking for a surgeon who will take time with you, go over your imaging the day before you go under the knife without making you feel like you are a burden, want an image you can agree upon with your surgeon, who cares about you, treats you like you are not a hassle, thinks an hour over a year of talking to you is not too much, will not say you have “baggage” if you had previous failed rhinoplasty, and is not a part of a high volume factory- Dr. Garrett Griffin is not for you. I highly suggest a professional who invests in your happiness and takes the time to make you comfortable, no matter what.
I wrote him an incredibly lengthy email to which he responded that my daughter can come back when she’s 18 (but WITHOUT my involvement). I’m sure it’s safe to say that at any age a child is going to want her mom’s care and guidance through a permanent change to her face. She was horrified by his response. He could have called or emailed at any time and helped to easily resolve this. Any caring and compassionate professional would have realized that 5 extra minutes to make a patient comfortable before surgery, is worth it.
Your face is too important to leave it up to other people’s before and afters...and most importantly so are your morals. I’m still in shock and devastated that a doctor could actually do this to a 17 year old girl. I’m still personally trying to figure out as a mom what I did over two zoom calls that could lead him to say “I’ve already spent more time with you than any other patient ever”. What health care professional says that? I spent more time getting my hair colored than speaking to a doctor about a change to my daughters face. The last year of heartache over his inability to take 5 minutes to give someone he’s never seen in person a quick image or idea we all agree on (that most humans on earth can do in 4 minutes on Facetune) is beyond words. She has waited almost her whole life to fix this insecurity and instead has spent months now trying to understand how another human being could actually do this to someone else.
I’m happy to answer any and all questions regarding this truthful and honest experience with Dr. Griffin.

Melchicago's provider

Garrett Griffin, MD

Garrett Griffin, MD

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

4.6 | 53 Reviews
PROFILE

Melchicago rating for Dr. Griffin:

Overall rating

Replies (5)

May 9, 2022
I am sorry this experience didn't go as you had hoped, and it did not go as I had hoped either. The day of your in-person consult was probably the least optimal clinic day that I have ever had, as I had fewer nurses to assist and more patients that usual (50 patients that day, usually I see 35 a day). Patients are interviewing doctors, and doctors are interviewing patients. I stand by my statements to you about the fact that you had unrealistic expectations of how much time I would be able to devote to just you and your daughter. As you know, I did offer to come in early the morning of surgery to spend an extra 30 minutes with you, but you declined. In the end, I do not think that I would have been able to make you happy, though I think I could have made your daughter happy. I love what I do, love caring for patients, and am a good rhinoplasty surgeon. I am also human. Your in-person consultation was really an aberration of the typical in-person consultation experience, and had you come on almost any other day, it probably would have been the experience you hoped for. In the end, things probably worked out for the best but I am quite sorry that your daughter did not get the surgery she was hoping to receive.
May 10, 2022
Dr Griffin, Why would you not have been able to make me happy? You and I had a few email exchanges and two zoom calls. You don't even know me. Is it because I am being carful with my child after a failed revision? Seriously that is the craziest excuse for your behavior I have ever heard. You are a wonderful surgeon- your treatment of us that day and continued blame on me (even a year later) are exactly why I finally felt compelled to write this. You astound me. Patients coming to you (especially after having experience with rhinoplasty) are looking for reassurance and real answers. I was happy to forgive you, but you should know it was my daughter who could not. Even a year later you can't find it in your heart to realize being compassionate is truly what most of us on this board are looking for in a surgeon should things unintentionally go wrong. You amaze me.
May 10, 2022
Also this was not an in person consultation. This was our pre-operative meeting. She was having surgery the next morning. You had 50 patients that day??? So you left her 12 minutes (in a 10 hour workday) to meet in person before you changed her face forever? I'm the one with "unrealistic expectations"? Patients should know this.
June 3, 2022
I have had multiple consultations with Dr. Griffin and I flew from NY each time . I have not yet had surgery with him which is scheduled soon but let me tell you ; he really takes time to explain . This would be my 3rd surgery on nose so naturally I am very anxious too but a surgeon is not a salesman . A surgeon work speaks louder than words and Dr. Griffin makes lovely noses . My advise would be to go to a revisionist only when 100% sure you and your daughter are ready for it .
June 3, 2022
Im not sure what you mean as this was not for a revision. My daughter was having a primary surgery scheduled for the very next day. We have met with multiple surgeons all of whom treated us with dignity and respect. Good luck with your surgery and hopefully you are granted a few minutes to review your images and a plan the day before surgery before losing thousands of dollars. Words and treatment of people do matter.
June 3, 2022
I do understand you are hurt like I am . I have been devastated with my outcomes too. It's tough and I understand that you needed to be very careful but please be advised that only book a revision when you are 100% sure . It will save the agony next time . Your hurt is also evident for loss of advance fee and trip saving loss but regret may have been worse . Good luck to your daughter too and blessings & peace to you!
July 1, 2022
Gentle311 I would love to see your results! I have a revison scheduled in august with him. It’s been a long, hard 2 years for me!!
April 14, 2023
Dr. Griffin severely botched my surgery. So, I strongly disagree that Dr. Griffin makes lovely noses. He failed me on so many levels, and I have evidence to back it up. The work he did on my nose is quite horrific, I have to live with his failure every single day of my life. Justice will be achieved!! He ignored how I wanted my nose, and arrogantly shaped my nose to his liking, without consulting me whatsoever about these drastic changes. And, significantly damaging by breathing as well. He admitted to botching my surgery, and backtracked, to cover his butt. I'm in agreement with Melchicago! I would never recommend anyone seek out this Surgeon. I should've walked, when you was extremely disrespectful, during the initial consultation.
April 17, 2023
Agreed!! I should have walked from the moment he emailed me back angry that I asked if insurance covered any part of it. Ugh
June 22, 2022
Finally had surgery with a different doctor. Amazing, kind, patient, attentive, intelligent. Surgery was Monday. So far nose looks beautiful. Treated us with such respect, compassion, took time to explain a plan. It was a valuable lesson about how you should be treated- especially by a medical professional. Will post review soon!
July 1, 2022
Sorry you had this experience- this is the complete opposite from my experience with dr Griffin. I had a virtual meeting and then flew To see him in person. I had a horrible rhinoplasty that has ruined my life so i have to be sure about who I choose to help me. I have surgery with him in august and have had several conversations with him since December and he has been very kind and never made me feel like he was in a rush. Maybe it was really just a bad day for him?? But sounds like your daughter has a good result so that it great! God bless.
July 1, 2022
I hope you have a wonderful outcome and wish you great results. Yes, we found an incredibly kind and caring doctor who actually spent time the day before surgery showing us imaging and discussing results. Incredibly professional and compassionate. Complete opposite of Dr. Griffin. I also had a poor revision and understand how important it is to be treated kindly. I will be seeking surgery with this new doctor as well. Hope everything goes great and wishing you a speedy recovery!!
July 5, 2022
Thankyou!! Same to you!
January 27, 2023
As of now I am not happy with my revision but am trying to be patient. I look like a piggy. Not sure this nightmare will ever be over for me.
Is your daughter still doing good?
January 27, 2023
Yes! She’s doing amazing. I can send some pics. We went with Dr. Kim Patrick Murray in Miami but also felt Dr. Zoumalan was great, Dr. Josh Zimm was incredibly kind and we had a great consultation with him as well. The way we were treated by Dr. Griffin was such a vast comparison to the many, many doctors we consulted with and visited. Probably over 15 of them when all was said and done.
July 18, 2025
2years since I posted that last comment and it has been a nightmare!!! Griffin is a horrible surgeon and not the nice person I thought he was. He agreed my outcome was disappointing and said he’s fix it when I got to the year mark. I waited patiently and went back to see him (I’m states away) at the year and he denied saying he’d help me. He told me he couldn’t believe I was unhappy and that I was ‘pretty enough’ and needed to look for the good… it’s very very hard to feel good when you have a deformed pig snout. There is no way to hide from it. I have had another revision to try and fix the long long list of issues and deformities griffin caused me. The surgeon was shocked that most of my structure was completely removed and didn’t know how these things could happen… griffin should be ashamed of himself- and he needs to STOP doing surgery… and he needs to STOP pretending to me nice and kind… he turns into a completely different person. I was so shocked I just sat there not knowing what to do.. I am in a better place emotionally so I will not be quiet anymore!
There was also dishonest things going on with the fees I paid. Tried and tried to get to the bottom of it but after a year of being lied to I gave up.
Stay away from griffin and that office!!
July 18, 2025
I’m so incredibly sorry to hear this again. Ughh. Wishing you so much love. If you are able, consider consulting with Dr. Kim Patrick Murray in Miami. It’s now been several years since our horrific experience with Dr. Griffin and BOTH my daughters have had surgery with Murray. He is not only intelligent, and a perfectionist but an incredibly kind and decent human being. Responsive, amazingly caring and has been the best thing I ever did. We live in Chicago- I consulted with at least 30 doctors and he was the one. Hoping Dr. Griffin one day wakes up and realizes he truly has some personality and professionalism issues.