Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty Reviews

My tip is very asymmetric and now I struggle to breathe

ORIGINAL POST

Join the Rhinoplasty Support Group on Facebook!!!

Reserved861153
$8,000
This is in no way meant to slander Dr Katz and his office staff. They were amazing and I wish them well now that the doctor is retired. Unfortunately, I was one of the unlucky ones that undergoes a rhinoplasty thinking life could only get better, but it definitely did not. I wish I had accepted my flaws instead of trying to change them. This post is to persuade anyone that comes across this heartfelt post to research as much as you can and talk to real life primary AND revision patients before you undergo irreversible procedures. It takes an emotional and mental toll that I do not wish on anyone. The depression is real!!! I'm happy for all the people that get their dream nose on the first go around. I did not know how common it was to come out with more irregularities than the ones you go in with even in the best hands.
I did not have breathing issues and now I struggle to breathe. This has caused me to have panic and anxiety attacks that I had to seek therapy for. My tip is very asymmetric that it is embarrassing to look anyone in the eye or go out in public. I have lost sleep and spent countless hours researching information on revision. Life is NOT the same! I am terrified to go through this procedure again as no one ever talks about the recovery process! It is not a walk in the park! Even if you do end up spending another 15-20k on a revision a year later it's not guaranteed to fix issues caused by a primary or that you won't need another one down the road. It really is a downward spiral.
This not meant to discourage anyone from surgery, but rather to bring awareness of the aftermath if things do not go well. It really is a risk!
I only saw Dr Katz for my 1wk post op and 8wk post op appt and he retired before my 6th month appt making matters worse and leaving me to figure out what went wrong on my own. Please be VERY selective on your surgeons. Wishing you the best of luck on your journey.

Reserved861153's provider

Warren J. Katz, MD (retired)

Warren J. Katz, MD (retired)

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

Reserved861153 rating for Dr. Katz:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (4)

User Avatar
January 21, 2022
am so sorry to hear your story . am the same very disappointed on this doctor
February 8, 2022
Sucks to hear we were some of the unlucky ones! I have a few internal issues on top of the outside appearance, but scared of trusting anyone to do a revision! Wishing you the best going forward!
User Avatar
March 3, 2022
i wish we can sue him !! sometimes i have hard time working out trouble breathing ! i blame myself for trusting this old man
October 22, 2022
hi , how are you doing? Did you have revision yet?
January 22, 2022
I'm so sorry this happened, I hope you're doing better. Wise advice for everyone. Sending you healing energy!
October 22, 2022
thank you!
January 24, 2022
Im sorry love. It does appear he lost his touch a little towards the end of his career. I hope you find peace. Your nose looks good after but I know you will never think so. The breathing issue however is scary. My nose came out okay, though the aftercare was lousy. Also, I’m surprised he is referring his patients to a surgeon who doesn't even specializes in noses.
February 8, 2022
I’m glad you got your desired results! I definitely think he lost his touch at the end :( I’ve spoken to many unhappy patients which had rhinoplasty with him in the last year. I just wished he had told me the limitations during the consult instead of over promising, but what can you do. Thanks for the compliment! Hope you’re fully recovered !!
June 22, 2022
Hello! I had my rhinoplasty done by this doctor as well. I have had trouble contacting anyone from the office. Do you have the contact information for the doctor he is referring his patients to? Thanks I'm advance for any help!
October 22, 2022
15 mths and I have now accepted I was unlucky with Katz and found some peace.
October 22, 2022
did you still need help?
February 20, 2024
hello, What is the name of the Facebook support group?
UPDATED FROM Reserved861153
1 year post

15 mth update

Reserved861153
At this point of the healing journey I can confirm all the deformities were caused by Katz’s outdated methods and techniques.
-Breathing is compromised.
-interrupted dorsal line (what I like to call half inverted V)
-external alar collapse due to cephalic trim and lack of supporting grafts.
- imaging confirmed 2 mm septum deviation and 2mm bone spur.
-asymmetric tip defining points
- two side profiles due to the his lack of attention to my tip cartilages
-alar retraction
-slimmer bridge , bulbous tip. Very bottom heavy and not proportionate at all!

There are more than a handful of people in the revision FB group with similar issues. He indeed was a money hungry surgeon like many out there. He made me believe at my 2 mth post up the asymmetry was swelling but when I received my pre surgery consult notes after he retired it clearly stated, “asymmetry of the tip will remain after surgery.” He also preformed an alar base reduction without making me sign paperwork as he made others sign. He failed to add it to my op note and I can’t forget to mention that 5 of us have the SAME EXACT op note. Only difference is the name and dob. He referred his patients to a surgeon that doesn’t even do rhinoplasty. Most patients didn’t even get a 2 mth post op with him before his abrupt retirement. If this doesn’t prove he was a horrible doc I don’t know what else will make you see the evil and incompetence that exists in the plastic surgery community. I’m glad he retired though! I lost 8k no refund of course and wish that if I waited 6 more months I would have been saved from him and this hell but I’m glad more people didn’t have to suffer under his care!

I wish he would have told me he was incapable of delivering a complete septorhino.
At no point did he look inside my nose and suggest I may need my septum fixed. Clearly he wanted to get a quick buck by just shaving off the hump and narrowing the bridge. He didn’t even do that correctly and ended up giving me an interrupted dorsal line. All an all I’m in complete regret of trusting my face and mental health to this man! Worst decision of my life. Thankfully I have invested 12 mths to therapy and can now accept and move on from this traumatizing event in my life. I am still unsure if I can ever submit myself to do a revision though. This procedure stole so much from me the first time and I don’t know that I can do it again. I would never wish the mental anguish, depression , anxiety, and self esteem killer to anyone. I’d wish I loved myself before committing to Katz OR I wish I’d trusted a much younger more competent surgeon at the very least. I believe in karma and I pray that one day I will find the happiness I deserve.

Replies (0)