POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty Reviews REVIEWS
Primary With Dr. Minoli Was NOT Worth it Revision With Dr. Celebi Was
ORIGINAL POST
Primary Rhinoplasty, So Far, Not the Best Results
As of today I am about 7 weeks post op primary rhinoplasty. I had a dent in my right side fixed (and the dent was everted, or popped out, no graft was necessary) and a deviated septum. 9 days post op I noticed a significant difference in my nostrils which are now VERY assymetric. As always, Drs. on here, as did my own, advise that time is the key factor. Im starting to think that's just a go to answer. Although I know time does play a part, I highly doubt that time is going to make my nostrils the same. There is a bump that has formed which was also there at 9 days post op due to sutures popping out twice, but it's no longer due to any sort of swelling, it's just there. It actually goes from the acute inside of my columella to the roof of my left nostril making it appear smaller. As of now, no, I'm not happy with the outcome of my rhinoplasty. My Dr. said he can go back in under local anesthesia, in 6 months. I saw Drs. on here mention that if nostrils started out assymetrical then that may explain it, thing is, mine were only slightly assymetrical, and now they are VERY assymetrical. My left is almost half the size of my right. I also find it odd they would mention that, seeing as how this is a surgery that's supposed to FIX those issues, not contribute to them. I'm super depressed, as a surgery that's supposed to boost my confidence, has only made me feel more insecure.
UPDATED FROM WishThink
2 months post
So far I am told that the bump is very much…
So far I am told that the bump is very much due to bad scarring. Only time will tell at this point. Although it is not ideal, I do like everything else about my nose, other than that. It feels like my columella is straight, it's just the bump on the inside making it look crooked. My profile and tip have both greatly improved which were my main goals. I guess one thing to keep in mind, is that no elective surgery is a guarantee. Always hope for the best but be prepared for possibly the worst. I'm certainly hoping that I won't need a revision of any kind, but we'll see. I'm going to heed advice I've been given and be patient. I still have more post op appointments so I will update on an as needed basis pending the outcome of my appointments.
Replies (0)
UPDATED FROM WishThink
2 months post
I Dont Have Much to Say. It is What it is.
The dent on right side was corrected, but now has resulted in pulling the right nostril high. It's not so noticeable in person, but as you can see, very noticeable in photos. The scar tissue will be removed in May, a date that got moved significantly forward (from September) because I started experiencing an odor in my left nostril. My surgeon insisted that it's not infection. Apparently accompanied with scar tissue, the high right side, has also pushed my columella towards the left. Although some things were improved during this primary surgery, other things were made worse... the downfall of an elective surgery, I guess. I'm trying to be optimistic, but I'm thinking my hopes to not need a revision, are far fetched. I'm going to ask my surgeon in May, if the excision under local anesthesia can also encompass making my nostrils look at least somewhat symmetrical.
Replies (8)

April 21, 2017
Sorry to hear about your situation. I just had a revision with a so-called Realself 'Core Doctor' and he really jacked up my nose. Left me with extremely uneven nostrils. Just like you said, they did start out slightly asymmetrical, but after the surgery they were WAY off. I think you look nice but I see the issues you're talking about. I'm not sure who your surgeon was but I just want to say: be careful on letting him go back in unless you really feel comfortable with his work/ability. Have you seen other reviews, met other patients of his? Getting a revision is serious and you have to make sure to get it right. Not trying to scare you, just looking out for you! Don't want you to end up in the situation I'm in! All the best in your journey!

April 21, 2017
Thank you for your kind words. Yes, in May, I do a scar revision, but not a full on revision. Reading horror stories on here absolutely terrify me, and if I was to do a full on revision in a year or two, no, I probably wouldn't have this same surgeon do it. Honestly, I don't want to have to do another OR surgery at all. Not only was the primary kind of my one chance financially, but due to my job, I get very limited time off. Anyhow, although I do appreciate that he initially takes a conservative approach to his surgeries and therefore tries not to do too much, unfortunately in his effort to not have an over done result, some issues were left undone (ie, the uneven nostrils resulting from the dent being pushed out). I really like my surgeon, however, I did know going in, that if things didn't come out ideally the first time, my chances of them getting better a second, were slim. That's just how I feel right now.

April 21, 2017
:( Hard times. Well, I hope he gets the scar straightened out. Once that's done you might feel pretty happy with the result. At least I hope so. Hope it all works out. :)


March 16, 2018
Hello, I have not had a revision yet, but I would be happy to share the information regarding my primary doctor, privately.
April 21, 2017
I hope your doctor is a good person and does right by you.

Replies (7)