Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Phenol Peel REVIEWS

Three Years Later After a Deep Phenol Peel (65 at the Time) - Portland OR

ORIGINAL POST

I had a rough time because I didn't expect to be...

lillyclb
$5,000
I had a rough time because I didn't expect to be struggling with my face for so long. It took 4 months to look decent. I am just guessing at this, but I think I was one of his first patients at his new location.

At the time of the procedure they hadn't yet gotten their after-peel products, and I wish they would have suggested getting it beforehand. I was still a mess and outside running around trying to find the stuff, when I should have been out of the sun. He literally told me walking was OK and I believed him, until friends that had had certain procedures told me to definitely stop taking those walks. Maybe that's why it took so long to heal.

In retrospect, I felt like I was a "bad patient". Part of this was that I did not get along with his assistant. Also I was truly scared because I had been told it wouldn't take so long; I requested we talk one-on-one and he was quite supportive even though by then, I was expressing anger. Dr Bensimon seemed to care when he saw how disappointed I was about the whole thing.

After about 5 months I looked great. I never felt better in my life. Smooth, beautiful skin where wrinkles used to be.

Now, three years later, my skin is reacting to the sun. This is what happened this summer:

First of all I admit I was outside more than usual on sunny days, I was gardening. But I was always wearing a hat and using strong sunscreen. My face is starting to look spotty. There are two swaths of "frosting" - totally white areas - above my lip on either side. This is the area where I had the most wrinkles and the area where he went the deepest.

Along the side of my face is there is a patch of slightly darker skin which will be troublesome if it keeps developing. It is barely discernable but it's there. I can cover it with makeup.

On my cheeks, my skin is very red, I had blood vessels like varicose veins appearing everywhere on my cheeks, plus red bumps. I got that to tone down by staying indoors for several days and applying a lot of Cetaphil lotion, something my primary care physician suggested.

My physician also referred me to a dermatologist and I'm looking forward to the appointment but it's a few weeks out. Meanwhile, it's summer and unless it's really cloudy out, I'm inside.

So here's the question I'm asking myself in the wee hours: If I can't be outside in the sun in a hat with sunscreen on, was it worth it? Am I going to have to "miss" the summer for the rest of my life?

Maybe I was being idealistic thinking I could just get this done and then business as usual. No, it changes you. You have to deal with your skin much differently. You might miss the summers you used to have.

I'll provide an update after I see my dermatologist. Take care, People.

lillyclb's provider

Richard H. Bensimon, MD (retired)

Richard H. Bensimon, MD (retired)

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

lillyclb rating for Dr. Bensimon:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (16)

August 10, 2016
Thank you for your feedback here, of course we would love to see you in person. We haven't seen you for quite a while and invite you back to assess. Our patients are receiving very remarkable results with the deep chemical peel, and we want you to be fully satisfied. We stand by all our patients and if something isn't quite right, we have ways to address concerns. Please call us at 503-222-0939.
January 25, 2017
well at least this doctor wants to see you unlike others I'd jump at the chance if he's willing to help you... good on you Richard benSimon :) only wish other doctors would help after bad reactions and things that didn't go exactly to plan .. it would certainly boost there reputation if they was all like you
February 6, 2017
Thank you, Dr Bensimon, for your gracious reply. I will be calling you to make arrangements to see you at your earliest convenience.
February 6, 2017
Thank you, you're right. If anyone can figure this out it will be him. The dermatologist I saw was beside herself.
February 6, 2017
Thank you, Dr Bensimon, for your gracious reply. I will be calling you to make arrangements to see you at your earliest convenience.
User Avatar
November 5, 2016
Humm well good information to share and to think about Wil you post pictures?
December 23, 2016
I wonder what kind of hat you are wearing and what level of sun protection it is offering. If it is a baseball cap, I doubt it is helping you. You really need to be wearing something which shields your entire face from the sun, such as a hat from Outdoor Research or Akubra. Would be nice to see photos also!
February 6, 2017
I purchased large rimmed hats from a company specializing in UV-protection sunhats and wore the hat with the widest allover brim when I was in my backyard.
March 9, 2017
I realized when I visited Amber at Dr Bensimon's office, that the moisturizer I had been using was EltaMD but it was for dry skin. Now I have switched to the EltaMD with moisturizer. This alone may have instigated the problem last summer.
March 10, 2017
Thank you so much for posting this. It was very helpful.
March 10, 2017
Wow! I love Dr. Bensimon's response! Wish he were near where I live! I've been interested in a deep peel for awhile now, but am pretty scared to get one. It's nice to see a Dr. who is so caring though!
August 17, 2017
Yeah he has a very caring personality. Good luck with the deep peel though. You have been forewarned.
UPDATED FROM lillyclb
4 years post

Update from "Lilly"

lillyclb
I finally went to Dr Bensimon to talk about the undesirable aspects of his peel.
Our first course of action was to use Bensimon's special facial cleanser, DHA lotion, Hydrate lotion and, in the evening, a cream that contains a combination of hydroquinone and Retin A, at a strength formulated specifically for me. In the morning I add a moisturizing sunscreen. I reapply the sunscreen during the day; every hour when I'm outside. If it feels dry I apply more Hydrate cream.

After two weeks of this, I could almost detect a change but today the redness is back! I know skin doesn't rejuvenate overnight so I am being patient.

I took the pictures today under stark light without makeup and did not image-edit them. You can see the demarcation line separating the philtrum (upper lip area) from the rest of my face. I have two distinct almost pure white areas on either side of the philtrum. Dr Bensimon told me that wasn't called "frosting", but those were the areas of my face that needed a deeper peel due to wrinkles.

Replies (9)

March 9, 2017
Please note that with makeup, my face looks pretty good. I definitely look ten+ years younger. Before the peel I had really sun damaged skin and deep wrinkles on my upper lip.
August 17, 2017
It's my only consolation. Less wrinkles here and there - although I wasn't wrinkle-prone for my age, anyway. Looking 10-20 yrs younger runs in my family. I got this because of my upper lip wrinkles. I should have taken care of that with filler, there are other ways... but what's done is done. I'm just here to let everyone know what happened to me. Good luck to you.
August 14, 2017
Hi Lilly,
Thank you, thank you for sharing your story! You helped me decide NOT to do this, I would get the dark, rather than the white stain, Karpun had shared about the derma pen and then I saw a gal Beautybyanne show how to do the derma rolling yourself with certain products, she looks amazing so going to be safe and control it in my hands, not someone else's, my luck is not so good in elective surgery! To cover your troubled areas, try MakeUp For Ever, their tattoo cover up is the best I have found to conceal whatever you need! Allyson
August 17, 2017
I will check out MakeUp For Ever, thanks. Please don't do it. I wouldn't send anyone to see Dr Bensimon. It's very risky. There is a HUGE payoff for looking younger from a Bensipeel. The sun becomes your worst enemy. I would gladly take back my sun damaged skin. Yes, in a heartbeat.
August 18, 2017
Hi Moonflower,
You will love the Make Up For Ever tattoo concealer, except the price$30 at Sephora) but it lasts a loooong time, do a very thin layer on your coverup parts. I make scar tissue for 20 people so plastic surgery is not my friend! Doing the hyraulonic acid am and pm and that helps...if you buy any product, make sure it is listed in the first 3 ingredients, otherwise, it will do zip for you, FYI. Allyson
August 14, 2017
Did you get your problem fixed?
August 17, 2017
Nope I did not. It was disconcerting to have Dr Bensimon totally deny there was anything wrong when there is something clearly wrong. His attendants just go along with it of course. They don't want any kind of legal action to ensue so they all toe the line. That's business.
April 8, 2018
Hi I´m considering these treatment. But doing my homework. Can you tell me did you experience any long term side effects? Like bumpy skin, scars, redness that does not go away, bad texture ?
March 12, 2021
I really wish people would post photos so those of us considering this very expensive procedure could see what you are talking about. It would be so helpful. Also, I don’t quite understand from the little bits of information, what went wrong?
Did you have to pre-treat for 6 weeks prior to the peel? Did you wear the Shrek mask afterwards? When you say you can’t go in the sun at all...or maybe that was moonflower...do you mean forever? Not even with sunscreen and/or a hat?
I hope you will answer because I cannot find any other bad reviews anywhere online and I want to know the truth because I’ve had some bad experiences in my own life I should post about! I’m a breast cancer survivor and have been botched as well as all of the cancer treatments age us. Just wanting to get my glow or my pretty back.