Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Mentor Breast Implants REVIEWS

32yo, 1 Child, Crossfitter, Mentor Memory Shape Anatomic Overs - Oceanside, CA

ORIGINAL POST

I am a mother to a wonderful 6-year old and have...

User Avatar
rlifts
$7,000
I am a mother to a wonderful 6-year old and have been contemplating BA since I was a teenager. After nursing for a year, I went from a 34A to a 34AA. I think because I started out small, and only grew to about a 34B while nursing, my boobs remain fairly perky. I have a strong build, and a prominent butt, so it'd be nice to be more proportional. I do appreciate and love my small boobs (makes certain things, like running, easier!) but bigger boobs would make me feel super confident naked and in anything with a plunging neckline.

The aesthetic I'm aiming for is one that has a natural slope, not a lot of fullness at the upper pole, but with lots of fullness at the lower pole. I described to my PS that I just want to have moderately large boobs that look like they belong to a healthy 32yo. I'm pretty set on getting anatomic implants over the muscle. I know it's not conventional here in the US, but after discussing it with my PS, I feel it's the right decision. I do crossfit 5-6 times a week, and explosive upper body movements are the norm. We don't just do strict pull-ups (i.e., from a dead hang), but we also do kipping/swinging pull-ups that are very dynamic and require flexibility as well as strength. We also do a lot of olympic lifting movements (cleans, snatches). I think if I were still a gym rat doing strict pull-ups, pushups, bench presses, I'd go with under the muscle. But with crossfit, I think over is better.

Right now I'm trying to decide between 270cc tall, moderate plus mentor memory shape implants or 305cc. I feel the 305cc might be too large, especially because I'm going over the muscle. Curious to know what you ladies/gentlemen think! Initially I was debating between the 250cc and 275cc sizers, and my PS told me to go for the larger size. Now I'm wondering if I should go up to the 305cc implants (I initially thought the 300cc sizers were too big). I don't want to go any bigger because my breast width is 12.5cm. The 270cc implants are 11cm wide, and the 305cc implants are 11.5cm wide. My PS said that implants that are at least 1cm narrower than the breast will look most natural, hence 305cc being the upper limit for me personally.

Still deciding on a surgery date, and only 90% sure I'll end up doing this before the end of the year. I think I'm just feeling guilty about it. Also, my bf prefers that I not have surgery: "I prefer natural" and "You should be happy with the way you are now" and "You don't need it." Honestly, I think he probably has Pamela Anderson in mind when he thinks implants, and doesn't realize that implants can look quite natural. In fact, he's probably ogled lots of women who have implants! :-) He's definitely a boob guy, so I can't see how he'd be unhappy after the surgery. Regardless, he acknowledges that it's ultimately my decision. Perhaps I should bring him to my pre-op appointment?

If I end up doing the surgery, it'll likely be in 3-4 months.

rlifts's provider

Gregory Park, MD - Account Suspended

Gregory Park, MD - Account Suspended

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

Replies (10)

April 28, 2015
I have athletic/lean friends who has theirs over muscle. Unless you have plenty of breast tissue, you will see the implant. My surgeon is amazing and does not put them over the muscle anymore. I understand that you want to be active sooner. However, I think under the muscle is a better result in the long run. I know it takes longer to heal but you will be able to do cross fit once the time comes.
User Avatar
April 28, 2015
Thanks for the feedback! It's not that I'm worried about healing time though. I'm worried about being as strong as I am now, and being able to do gymnastics movements like kipping pullups, muscle-ups, olympic movements like cleans and snatches. All require explosiveness and I'm not sure that, even in the long term, I'll be able to do these things after surgery. But, I'd love to hear your thoughts and the experience your friends have had!
April 29, 2015
If they are placed under the muscle, your chest muscle will not be as strong? I don't about that part. Maybe ask the doctors? I just know there's a reason doctors only go below the muscle now. I have a friend who has tear drops under muscle. They are so pretty. She lifts weights but is not competitive.
April 28, 2015
How tall are you? Dr park did my anatomics memshape tall, but unders, 445 left 495cc right. But I'm 5'7". Also, i wanted big....
User Avatar
April 28, 2015
Nice! I'm 5'1" so he's hesitant to go too large. I'm hesitant too -- I'd be happy with a C cup. I chatted with him yesterday and his recommendation was to stick with the 270cc implants.
April 29, 2015
Oh Gotcha, he's a good pick!
User Avatar
April 30, 2015
That's great to hear! I think the reasoning is that you are traumatizing te chest m
User Avatar
April 30, 2015
Oops. Commented too soon. I think the reasoning is that you're traumatizing the chest muscles. That all said, I just met a woman at my gym/box who has implants under the muscle and is still doing crossfit at a very high level. It was reassuring. Still thinking overs... Ugh. Dr. Park did say I could go up (to 305cc) but if we did, he'd put it under the muscle.
User Avatar
April 30, 2015
I'm also interested in what you do regarding over versus under because I do similar workouts and do not want to lose any strength. My pectoral muscles are also huge and I'm afraid of the trauma. That said, I have a lot of breast tissue (C cup, prior reduction) and my PS still will only go under the muscle.
User Avatar
April 30, 2015
Thanks for you comment! Has your PS ever done overs? A woman at my gym has very large unders and said her PS only does unders. That kind of concerned me bc I think a surgeon should be open to both unless there is solid evidence against one approach vs another. I'm not convinced that's the case for placement. I'm an epidemiologist and looked at the implant info online that describe the clinical trials and their outcomes. I do think things like base width diameter will also dictate what size implants will look best and where they are placed. I have a broad chest despite being 5'1" and am also muscular. I can flex and see my pecs separate from my fatty tissue. I'm worried that unders will just end up distorting quite badly during workouts. Ugh. I can't really decide. I want to be a reasonable size, but don't want to compromise being able to stay over the muscle. My PS said I could get 305cc overs and they'd look great, but that over time I'll be at greater risk of rippling as my skin thins. I'll keep you posted! I think I'm going to stop by the office again...
UPDATED FROM rlifts

Over or Under

User Avatar
rlifts
Now I'm not sure whether to go over or under. :-/ Overs are not common here in the US but apparently they are more common in EU. Anyone have thoughts on this? I don't plan on going big... but after looking at reviews, in worried I'll regret not going very big. I will say that I don't want to be any more than a full C because of how active I am. But if I end up with a full B I might be very unhappy. Argh.

Replies (1)

October 2, 2016
Curious to know what you ended up with?!