Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Mole Removal REVIEWS

Definitely Not Worth It! - Seattle, WA

ORIGINAL POST

I had a cosmetic mole removal done by Rebecca...

MT93
$350
I had a cosmetic mole removal done in Seattle, Washington. I went in to have the mole looked at because I was concerned with some irritation I was experiencing off and on and they enthusiastically said many times "there's nothing wrong with it medically, but we can remove it!" "let us get you the information about having that removed." Honestly, at the time I wasn't even really thinking of removing it for cosmetic reasons, but they were so enthusiastic about wanting to remove the mole. I thought about it a bit, and decided I would go for it since they said "in a month it will be just a flat, slightly pink scar and then it will fade into normal skin color or maybe a bit lighter." That didn't sound bad to me and although I didn't hate the mole or anything, it wasn't my favorite physical attribute. A couple weeks later, I went in for the actual removal. A little nervous I asked the nurse who was checking me in for the procedure for more reassurance about the scarring and overall outcome. She enthusiastically told me that EVERYONE is happy with their results. When the PA came in (guess I should've really gone with an actual cosmetic surgeon or cosmetic dermatologist), she looks at the mole and goes "oh, this mole is really red. Hmmm, yeah, I think I can shave it off anyway" (she removed the mole via the shave method btw). She went on to say that it might still be red afterwards. This was news to me as before they brightly said "oh yeah, it'll fade to skin color after a couple months." Nervously, I said "well, do you still think I'll be happy with the cosmetic outcome?" At this point I already have marker on my face around the area and a local anesthetic in my skin. She goes "oh, yeah, definitely." I really felt like I was already at the point of no return and didn't have a chance to think at all with this new information she was handing me. She did the procedure, which was painless and took less than 5 minutes. Slapped a bandaid on me, told me the nurse would give me instructions on healing and said "it'll be ugly for awhile but it'll heal." Ummmmmmm......ok? I'm not even sure what that's supposed to mean. Well, anyway, it's four months out and it is nothing like what they told me in my initial appointment. I am left with a deep purple scar that is very indented and WAAAAAAAAY more noticeable than the mole ever was. I actually think I even miss the mole, but maybe that's because I just hate the scar so much. I'm guessing if it had healed how they actually said it would that I wouldn't be saying I missed the mole. I also want to say that I had realistic expectations. I knew there would be a scar, but the scar I envisioned from what they told me would be much, much smaller and less noticeable than the scar I am left with. I am so self-conscious of the scar all the time and it's really, really sad because I was never self-conscious of the mole before. I'd had the mole for as long as I can remember and never thought much about it. Now I think about the scar all the time. Also, I'm not sure how they know that EVERYONE is happy with their mole removal because they never did any follow up with me. I am going back in this week to see if they can fix the damage they've done, but I'm not at all optimistic and I don't trust them at all. Anyway, the moral of my story is, if you have a small mole that doesn't really bug you that much, maybe this procedure isn't for you. Everyone's situation is different. But don't let a doctor or anyone else tell you that it will without a doubt heal up nicely with a scar that is barely noticeable because things like this do happen and you have to think of the risks/possible rewards. The office I went to was supposed to be this great office, the main doctor has even been on Oprah. So I really thought I was in good hands....

MT93's provider

MT93 ratings

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

I recently went back after my bad result and she was very warm and compassionate. They are going to work with me on helping me treat the scar free of cost. Hopefully the end result will be a scar that I can live with. Time will tell, but I did appreciate their response to the issue.

Replies (36)

March 22, 2016
Thank you so much for your comment. Definitely helped me form my decision.
March 23, 2016
You're welcome :) obviously some people have done removals and had great outcomes so everyone is different. This is just my experience and if I could take it back I would.
March 23, 2016
Do you have a "before" photo? Was it a brown mole or a fleshy colored mole? Was it far or raised? Did they give you proper after-care instructions? I have several fleshy moles on my face, and I saw a plastic surgeon for a consult. She said that all could be shaved except for the one near my mouth (in the same spot as yours) due to the tension the skin experiences from talking/chewing. She recommended excision on that mole for best scar results.
March 23, 2016
*I meant "Flat or raised"
March 23, 2016
Thank you for your comment. That is definitely helpful to know as I am planning on having the scar revised by a plastic surgeon and was worried how talking/chewing would effect the outcome of an excision. Did your excision heal nicely? (The mole was raised and red in color) I just don't think the PA really gave it much thought beforehand. When I came in for the actual treatment it was as if she'd never looked at it before.
March 23, 2016
Oh, also, I kept it very well covered with ointment and a bandaid. I followed their aftercare instructions to a T.
User Avatar
March 23, 2016
Check out Dr. Nathan Newman. He works with adult adipose stem cells. He could fill that hole no problem.
March 23, 2016
I had a nearly identical procedure as you on my face in December 2015. We both have divots because the wound site wasn't kept covered with Polysporin and Vasaline for the first 3 weeks.
March 23, 2016
I actually followed the after care instructions very carefully and did keep it well covered. So that isn't the source of my problem. A doctor told me they shaved too deeply. Sorry yours didn't heal nicely either :(
June 7, 2016
Thank you for your post. I too am undecided about a mole I kind of dislike (but not intensely). Some stories on this website seem to show larger scars/indentations than I would have expected. It's good to be informed, so why don't the Drs enlighten us pre-op?
June 7, 2016
Hi there, I agree it seems like all too often doctors only focus on the positive outcomes and don't prepare you enough for the risks. My doctor has actually been really good since I went back in and is providing free cosmetic treatments on the scar. But the treatments are intense, there's downtime, and there's a long road to go. Fingers crossed that the scar will eventually be something I am comfortable with. For me it hasn't been worth the emotional anguish, downtown of further treatments, etc. everyone's situation is different, good luck!
UPDATED FROM MT93
1 year post

1.5 years later

MT93
Here is an update of my scar after two subscision with filler treatments, several IPL/v beam treatments, and a CO2 laser treatment. I'm hoping to get more CO2 done in the fall.

Replies (25)

June 28, 2017
Oh wow what a huge difference! I can see the photo now :)
June 28, 2017
Thanks :) it really is a lot better. It's hard as I'm sure you know when you see it everyday and improvement is so gradual. It's helpful to see the photos side by side. Still hoping for more improvement this fall. Good luck with yours! I know how difficult this is, and in my experience most people in my life don't quite get it.
June 28, 2017
No people don't get it! Thanks for your update, makes me a little more hopeful!
June 29, 2017
Sorry one more question - so impressed by your results! Did you ever try dermastamp (?dermaplaning) or microneedling on the scar?
June 29, 2017
No problem! I'm more than happy to help - I totally understand and thank you for the compliment. My aesthetician has done dermaplaning on it (if you just mean the manual exfoliation with the scalpel). I've thought about microneedling but haven't done it yet. I've done microneedling on the rest of my skin before all this happened and I liked it. I think it could help to smooth out edges. Subscision though is kind of a more aggressive version of microneedling because they basically take a bigger needle under the scar and move it around to break up scar tissue and increase collagen production (gross sounding, I know). Once I've done a few more CO2 treatments I may do microneedling on my whole face again and see if that helps to blend things out. I just want to focus on the CO2 right now. I really think that CO2 is going to probably help your scar at this point more than microneedling. The results aren't earth-shattering (although it is considerably cheaper than CO2.) You could look into doing a combo of both....
June 29, 2017
Thanks! One out if state doctor recommended subcision and dermastamp but I didn't know what that was or anyone that could do it. The goal, as you know all too well, is to lift the depression and smooth out the edges. The edges I have cause a lot of shadowing. And I still am considering an excision but if I could get it to where you have gotten yours I would be happy!
June 30, 2017
I am not familiar with dermastamp. I think subscision would definitely help lift and then you could rotate with laser to smooth it out. I know, the edges are the worst. And there's nothing I've found you can do with makeup. It just is what it is. So frustrating.
July 4, 2017
It looks much better now girl! (I followed your post before!) I am hoping to remove a mole too but I think after reading your experience I want to avoid the shaving method and go with excision. If you check out my question you can see my mole is just in the crease of my cheeks when I smile so that would probably be a factor...
July 4, 2017
Thanks! Yeah, I wouldn't do a shave if I had to do it over again, I would go to a plastic surgeon and not a dermatologist (just my preference, I'm sure there's lots of great derms out there). Especially since yours is in the smile line like that, I think you will have a really nice result with excision. I wish that's the route I had gone to begin with. Good luck!!
July 25, 2017
Update: I was hopeful to try subcision but surgeon advised today that I should get scar revision...ughhh So scary. Maybe my scar is deeper than yours was.
July 25, 2017
Oh man! I don't know though, you might end up being happier and with quicker results. I know there are risks with revision, but I think I'm the end it might work better. You will have some down time, but I've been getting treatments for 1.5 years and it still is not where I want it. Don't get me wrong, it's a big improvement, but I still do not like the scar especially if I see my reflection in bright natural light. Let me know what you end up doing and how it works for you. Fingers crossed!
July 25, 2017
Thanks! I'm doing a ton of research trying to find someone who specializes in scar revisions. I got a quote for $1500 (ugh) so far. The key is to make sure the scar is a little raised at first where it will sink down down. If it starts out level with the other skin it could end up being depressed. If slightly raised it can always be smoothed down later. Then there is the pigment to consider, right now no redness so it blends (besides all the shadowing). I had the C02 7 weeks ago and can't see much of a difference. Not sure I will go for another treatment of that. The surgeon I just saw felt that the C02 won't do much, it only skims off the top of the skin in that area and that skin is already "thinner" - so THAT made me nervous. It's hard to know what to do. If I find someone I am comfortable with, I may go for the scar revision, he said it would be about 2mm longer than what I have but a thin, flat line (hopefully!).
July 26, 2017
That's really barely anything (2 mm) since your current scar isn't red, I bet your new one would fade nicely, but I don't know. Did the doctor have any concern about with where the scar is and movement on your face of it stretching? I read about that but don't know if that is really an issue or not. Maybe not with a good surgeon. At the end of the day although it sucks to pay $1,500, I think if it makes you a lot happier, it's totally worth it. Plus that would be hopefully just one treatment needed vs the cost of how many treatments I've had. Although the doctor is doing all of that no charge for me.
July 26, 2017
This doctor did not seem to be concerned with stretching, he said the only time that is a concern is if the scar runs over a joint. I am going to get two more options from plastic surgeons and see what they say. It's scary but I will probably end up doing it.
July 27, 2017
Let me know what you end up doing and how it goes! I'm really interested to know. And good luck!!!
July 25, 2017
Bellafill works!