Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Lap Band REVIEWS

Down from 275 lbs to 165lbs, diet/exercise and lap band

ORIGINAL POST

I began my weight loss journey in 2009 when I...

User Avatar
RSMember1401

I began my weight loss journey in 2009 when I decided to peruse Lap Band surgery through my insurance company. Getting approved by insure was no easy task, I spent a lot of money visiting countless doctors and jumping through hoops doing more tests than I have ever experienced in my life, like 6 months of nutritional counseling ($100/ session), a psych evaluation ($250), a written letter stressing medical necessity by my general practitioner, getting cleared for surgery by a cardiologist and pulmonary doctor, passing a sleep study, doing a stress test (even though I was only 20), and finally an echocardiogram to top it all off. Luckily, I got approved the very first time I sent in my packet for evaluation, so my surgery was covered and all I had to pay was a hospital fee.

I got the lap band in June of 2009 at Centra State Medical Center in Freehold, NJ. I weighed 275 lbs at the time. It was a pretty painful recovery, difficult to sleep and move after, but luckily it didn't last very long. The worst part was the pain in my back and shoulders that I couldn't even stretch or crack to relieve, which I can only guess was from laying on the operating table for so long. The first year, I was very unsuccessful in my attempt to lose weight because I didn't change my diet after I healed and I didn't start exercising. I found that if you drink fluid with anything I ate, it essentially washes the food right through the part of your stomach the lap band is constricting and I was able to eat more. By the time 2010 had rolled around and I was 1 year post-op, I had only lost about 25 lbs. In August of 2010, I decided that enough was enough and started going to the gym 5 days a week and eating healthier. I currently weight about 180lbs and have lost just shy of 100 lbs to date. I think the lap band is a good idea in theory, but I know that I could have achieved this goal by myself if I had just started eating healthy and dieting like I do now. The lap band isn't going to be effective if you're still eating pizza, macaroni & cheese, and chinese food, like I was. I wish I hadn't gotten the surgery and could have made that connection sooner.

It also didn't help that my doctor didn't see me for over a year after my surgery. I was only seen for fills by nurses and physician's assistants in the office, which I found a little impersonal. I was given no help with diet or exercise plans, as I was told was part of the "program". It was as if everything they said they offered as part of the Lap Band System was out the window after my surgery was done and I was on my own after that. I had complications with adjustments and haven't been back in at least 9 months to get a fill because I'm pretty sure they just want my money. Every time I leave the office, they either put too much fluid in the band, or not enough. Its not a pleasant experience, either, so I have decided not to go back for a while.

I don't know how helpful this is to anyone reading, but feel free to message me if you have any questions or thoughts!

RSMember1401's provider

Dr. Morris Washington

RSMember1401

RSMember1401 ratings

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (23)

November 30, 2011

Hi Kelita,

Thanks for your review. You've done really well and are looking great.

It's a difficult journey and I'm glad you took control of your diet and made the changes. It is definitely a tool and you have to wor alongside it every single day to make it work.

Keep up the good work and if you need anything just let me know!

Kirsty

November 30, 2011

Wow. Your transformation is incredible! Good for you for figuring out what you needed to do to get healthy.

I wonder if the Lap Band is different than WLS like gastric bypass. I've never had either, but from what I've researched patients of gastric bypass actually can't eat too much without feeling really full and icky. Do you think the water thing would work for them too, or is there something different about the lap band?

Anyway, I am just blown away by your photos. Congrats on your new health and confidence!

User Avatar
November 30, 2011
Hey Makenzie,

Thanks for the kind words :)

My aunt and cousin had gastric a few years before I got the lap band. With gastric, they actually cut and staple your stomach and make a new pouch that restricts your food intake, but with lap band, the band goes around the top of your stomach kind of like a zip-tie and restricts the food, which makes you feel full, but your whole stomach is still intact. Theres no way to wash the food through with gastric, which is a plus. However, I know you can stretch your stomach back to its original size or larger over time from slowly over eating. Also, a lot of people that have gastric find that they can lose the weight no matter what they are eating because they are still eating significantly less than they were before, so they tend to not change their eating habits and diet as strictly as they should. Between the stretching and not changing eating habits, it is very likely someone would gain the weight back over time.

With Lap Band, you lose the weight slower than with gastric, but if you look at long term results, after about 3 years the weight loss is the same. Also, some recent research supports the theory that lap band is proving to be more effective in keeping weight off in the long run than gastric.

They explain all the differences, pros and cons on this website, if you're interested! http://www.lapband.com/en/learn_about_lapband/compare_lapband/

I hope that answers your question :)
-Kelly
November 30, 2011

Thanks for such a thorough response! This may turn into a good material for a RealSelf blog post :) 

November 12, 2012
Kelita. I have a question regarding excess skin. Did you have any alterations done or did the skin tigghtend on its own by attending the gym and all
User Avatar
November 30, 2011
Wouldn't that be cool! Its such a good topic and theres so much information about it to consider, with all of the pros and cons of each. It would definitely make for an interesting blog, thats for sure.
December 18, 2011
Thanks for the info, I am interested in getting the lapband, I weigh 280lbs and I'm concerned about sagging skin.
December 19, 2011

Hi Cass,

Usually, if you're wanting to lose over 100lbs there will be sagging skin that will not return to normal. Most WLS patients choose to deal with the sagging skin in favor of losing so much weight, and getting healthy. There are always surgery options after you've lost the weight, such as: body lift, arm lift, thigh lift, etc

Have you spoken to any doctors yet?

Best,

Kirsty

User Avatar
December 19, 2011
Everything snapped back pretty good for me except for my belly, but thats where I carried most of my weight. My aunt had trouble with her arms and likes to call her skin "bat wings" now lol. But honestly, after losing so much weight its easy to have a sense of humor about a little sagging skin. It does snap back a good amount over time, especially with exercise, but you'll most likely have some sagging. Totally worth it :)
December 22, 2011
Hi Kirsty, thanks for the info. I have not spoken with any doctors yet. But I agree that losing the weight trumps sagging skin!

Thanks for your help.
December 22, 2011
Thanks Kelita,

It helps to hear someone who has experience say that it is worth it. I want to attend an info session, I mentioned it to my husband and he immediately said no, and was against it. "I like you as you are . .." but I think that liking me is more important. I will give him a few days to cool down :-))

Thanks!
User Avatar
December 22, 2011
It's about so much more than just a physical aspect. I feel so good now and I'm a happier person because I'm healthy and active. He may like you as you are, but maybe if you take the position that you want to live a long, healthy life he'll be more open to the idea. It really is just a tool for healthy living ;)
User Avatar
June 29, 2012
Thanks for ur post. I've been contemplating, I've actually started w/ the nutritionist & so forth but I keep thinking its the wrong option for mr & that I can definitely lose the weight but then I think about how may times I've yoyo'd back up & how I've dieted myself up to getting this big. But It seems like if I don't have the discipline now to do it I can't expect the lapband to do it for me? What do u think?
User Avatar
July 3, 2012
I didn't have the discipline to stick to a diet before I got the lap band, or the whole first year after surgery for that matter. There just came a point that I really had had enough and started to diet. Its certainly easier to diet with the lap band because you can fill up much faster and stay full longer. Its easier to plan meals and make better choices when you don't feel like you're starving (I always felt like I was so hungry I was "starving", even though I wasn't really lol). Exercise is just as much a part of it as the diet though, and most people arent into making that commitment, but its honestly so much easier and enjoyable than I ever imagined.
User Avatar
March 19, 2012
You loll great! Congrats on the healthy lifestyle. :)
UPDATED FROM RSMember1401
2 years post

I weighed 174 lbs today. Officially at 101 lbs...

User Avatar
RSMember1401
I weighed 174 lbs today. Officially at 101 lbs total weight loss. I can't believe it…

=)

Replies (13)

June 9, 2012
Thanks for the info. You look fantastic so bravo to you for succeeding.
User Avatar
July 3, 2012
thank you! :)
June 14, 2012
I just want someone I can talk too about this, I don't want to go through this by my self, any out that is willing to talk with me.
June 16, 2012

Hi. I am currently researching the adjustable gastric band. I am going to an information session in a few days. I would love someone to talk to.

July 4, 2012

Hi KayKay,

Are you having a Lap Band yourself?

May 10, 2013

Kay, I had lap band surgery 12/20/12. I had a great surgeon (recommended by my Dermotogist and Primary Care doctors). She and the office staff are wonderful and very accessible. If you do some homework (check w/ primary care dr for recommendations), you should find someone you will want to do the surgery. I was 253 @ my heaviest and close to doing insulin as well as diabetic meds. I am down from 2,000 miligrams to 500 a day). I am only 4 11 1/2 so I was obese. I am currently @ 204.8. I love to cook and eat and have had some trials and tribulations as habits are hard to break. Food is an addiction!!! I plan to join a support group which should help plus your friends will encourage you to continue. It is worth it. Please PM me I am going in for my 3rd adjustmt next week and will ask the office for a good dr reference where you live. PS-Even joined a gym - hate exercise, but it helps!!! Good luck! I am still glad I did the surgery ~ Carole.

June 16, 2012
You look fantastic!!! Way to go!!
August 20, 2012
Hello, I weigh 191 lbs and I'm searching for a provider who will do the surgery on me. This is the heaviest I've been and can't seem to lose the weight on my own. Do you have any advice on you eat healthy?
User Avatar
August 20, 2012
I went to a nutritionist for 6 months and she was a big help because I was able to come back every month and tell her what worked for me and what didn't. I am still pretty much about to eat whatever I want, but for the most part I eat much healthier on a whole by mostly cutting out foods like fast food, soda, sugary drinks, velveta shells & cheese, Chinese food, and Ben & Jerry's. I've learned to ALWAYS go for the healthier option, low fat/ no fat/ reduced fat everything, fresh vegetables rather than starches, baked or grilled chicken and fish. Low calorie protein shakes are awesome too. You should go find a nutritionist to sit down with and go over your diet so you know what kind of foods you eat too much of and what you could substitute them with.
February 28, 2013
You look great! I am wondering , due to your experience, that if you had to do it all over again, would you get the band? Do you think you could have reached this place on your own?
UPDATED FROM RSMember1401
3 years post

Down to 166 lbs. now, and I was down to 162 lbs at...

User Avatar
RSMember1401
Down to 166 lbs. now, and I was down to 162 lbs at my lowest. I am shooting for 147 lbs as my final goal weight though. Im happy I have been able to maintain my weight for so long and that Im still in this healthy frame of mind. Once this semester is finally over and I have more time, I am going to head back to the gym 5 days a week and start up weight loss mode again. Can't wait :)

Replies (13)

June 27, 2013
Very inspiring story...I have surgery July 11 would love to hear more from you. I am too from nj....I want to loose about 80 pounds..did you find that you had a lot of extra skin?
User Avatar
July 29, 2013
Hey, how are you feeling after surgery? Yes I did have a lot of extra skin. See my other post about my tummy tuck. http://www.realself.com/review/nj-tummy-tuck-weight-loss
July 30, 2013
So glad I heard from you... Down 17 pounds so far. Day 1 was awful and I was put on Tylenol with codine. Gas pain too was rough for a good week. Finally was able to sleep on my sides two days ago. Overall I feel great. Still have a little puffiness in my belly but I feel less bloated and puffy. How long after did you do tummy tuck? You truly look amazing and are an inspiration. I'm so excited to see what I will look like in a few months!
July 30, 2013
Ouch... Looks like it really hurt. That had to be worse than lap band. Looks like its worth it though in the end but that's a huge cut!! Yikes. Glad you're doing well and you truly look amazing. I'm not far from you... Lbi area
User Avatar
July 30, 2013
How funny, I'll be in LBI the week of the 10th! I'm glad you're doing well and down 17 lbs, good for you ^_^ Lap band wasn't nearly as painful as a tummy tuck, but the tummy tuck was definitely worth it. Most excruciating pain of my life, but the pain is only temporary and I love having a flat belly more than I could ever possibly put into words. I got lap band in May 2009, and the tummy tuck in December 2011. I just booked my surgery date for a breast lift and augmentation for December 30th 2013!
July 30, 2013
How long was recovery I for tummy tuck? I need to lose 50 pounds right now and right now I have just a little jiggle and hardly any stretch marks do you think ill have a lot of extra saggy skin? Do you know the average range of weight that causes a lot of extra saggy skin?
User Avatar
July 30, 2013
I don't think there really is an average range of weight that causes sagging skin. Everyone carries their weight differently, people's skin elasticity is different with age and genetics… theres really no great way to tell. I carried most of my weight in my belly and my boobs though, my arms and legs were never really that big. I knew I was going to need a tummy tuck if I lost a lot of weight because of how strange my belly looked when I was heavy, it was already hanging a little then. It took me a pretty long time to recover. Probably like 2 months before I could even stand up perfectly straight, and even still it feels strange to lay on my belly and stretch out my torso. The swelling took about 6 months to go down, and the scar is still in the process of getting lighter. I was out of the gym for 3 months and returned doing only very light activity.
July 30, 2013
If you don't mind me asking but what do you do? Did you have to take off work and stuff? We're you open about everything with friends and family?
January 18, 2014
I've been thinking about getting surgery... but I've been wondering if just eating healthy and working out would do it... I'm glad I found your article. I'm definitely going to try it without surgery. I'm 290 and want to get down to 155 at least. I was curious if you had any issues with baggy skin after losing all that weight? I'm kinda nervous about that. Thanks for sharing your story!
User Avatar
June 23, 2014
You've done amazingly well, and proven what everyone should know, no surgery will just hand you success. It's a pity your follow up care was so poor, you really have done it all by yourself.
August 27, 2014
I've had my lap band since 2006, I've lost 151 lbs. Because of this of course I had to have a mommy makeover, where 15 lbs of skin was removed and had to have abdominal muscle repair along with a breast lift, I'm two weeks out of surgery and I am happy with the results. Good luck to all you banded, please check out bandedwendy on YouTube , she helped me through many ups and downs.
October 11, 2014
It would have been nice to know at the consultation that if you have Hypothyroidism and Insulin Resistance it would be harder to lose the weight. I didn't find this out until earlier this week, after having the surgery done Dec 2013, and still at the same weight as when I went in. Not a happy girl!