Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Body Lift REVIEWS

Bad breast lift, brachioplasty (arm lift) & bra line back lift

ORIGINAL POST

I had an upper body lift with Dr. Sholar in...

NewMeWK
$10,000

I had an upper body lift with Dr. Sholar in Evansville Indiana. This included a breast lift, brachioplasty (arm lift), and bra line back lift. Not one of my procedures turned out well. My breasts were droopy and my nipples pointed down. My arms became infected and I was left with awful scars. My bra line back lift had necrosis and left a large crater in my back. She never scheduled a follow up appointment after having laser treatments that were supposed to help the scaring, but made the scars even wider.

My recovery was awful. I was almost 8 months out before all my incisions were closed. When I called to let them know I was unhappy, she would not see me or return my calls, and she was not willing to give me any of my money back. After I threatened to hire an attorney, Dr. Sholar had an office worker call and offer to redo the surgery. I had no faith in her ability to do any better than the first go around so I did not even consider that as an option. I had revisions done by another surgeon and my experience was totally different.

Recovery was a breeze and I had no issues with healing or scarring. I am not the only one who has had issues with Dr. Sholar and I would suggest visiting the Indiana Department of Insurance website to check for malpractice claims before seeing Dr. Sholar. It was an awful experience and I am still physically and emotionally hurt by her actions.

During my revision surgery with another doctor he was able to give me a beautiful breast lift and repair my back scar, but he was not able to remove all of the scarring on my arms and I will live with them forever. I have not proceeded with a lawsuit at this time, but because I was not able to recoup any of my fee from her and I am still dealing with physical and emotional issues that I cannot afford to continue to manage, I am looking at moving forward with some sort of legal action.

We all make mistakes and I understand that Dr. Sholar is human. In my opinion, the right thing to do would be to admit the mistake and do what you can to make it right with the patient. She had the opportunity to make this right with me by refunding a small portion of what I paid her and she was unwilling to do so. I ended up paying another $10,000, out of my pocket, to have all the surgeries over again with a competent doctor.

NewMeWK's provider

Alina Sholar, MD

Alina Sholar, MD

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

NewMeWK rating for Dr. Sholar:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (23)

October 13, 2013
Im so sorry to here that and wish u al the best. Thank u for sharing your story with us.
October 14, 2013

Hi there, welcome and thanks for sharing your journey with us.

I'm sorry you had such a bad experience, but hopefully the revision surgery has given you some peace of mind.

October 14, 2013
Are you going to post new pictures. Did u review anothet
October 14, 2013
You want pictures of the revision? I have not reviewed the doctor who did the revisions yet. I will as soon as I get a chance to.
October 14, 2013
Yes. Somehow my comment was cut off. Laser should make it better! I'm glad your better now. Maybe she was embarrassed
October 14, 2013
The laser made it worse. It helped with the pain in the scars because it helped them to lay flatter but made them much wider. It helped with the redness, but not long term. The revision on my arms helped to move the scars in toward my sides more because they were down the back of my arms. It helped with the with of the scars in most areas, but I didn't have enough skin to remove all of the scars. Some spots where the scaring was the worst the scars are still ticker/wider. My new breasts look awesome and my lower body lift results are great too! I used Dr.Huneke in Nashville for my revision and lower body lift. He was wonderful!
User Avatar
October 16, 2013
I am so sorry you had such a disappointing experience with your first surgeon. You go into surgery with the expectation of having a wonderful improvement, it must be heartbreaking to have a poor result. I am thrilled to hear you were able to have successful revision surgery...Wishing you all the best on your journey!
User Avatar
October 27, 2013
I am so sorry...hang in there!!!