Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

Dr. Oakley Smith rhinoplasty Journey!

ORIGINAL POST

Dr. Oakley Smith rhinoplasty Journey!

idk1997
$12,500
Hello all,
I’m a 20 year old female from Toronto who has already booked a rhinoplasty with Dr. Oakley Smith in Toronto. My surgery is scheduled for the winter, so I still have a few months until I am ready for my surgery. I’ve been to the consultation and asked some questions so I will begin to document my journey here for anyone interested.

idk1997's provider

Oakley Smith, MD, FRCSC

Oakley Smith, MD, FRCSC

Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

4.8 | 179 Reviews
PROFILE

idk1997 rating for Dr. Smith:

Overall rating

Replies (18)

July 4, 2018
That’s exciting. What changes are you making?
July 5, 2018
Very exciting haha! I’m asking for an improved side profile with a small hump reduction, a narrower nose tip and (possibly, this part isn’t confirmed) for the length of my nose to be shortened. My nose has a very round shape with a bulbous tip and projects too far from my face in my opinion, so if it is possible for him to reduce the projection that would be fantastic. I’ll post pics soon :)
July 5, 2018
Look forward to following your journey!
July 5, 2018
Hey, you should just know that Dr. Oakley does have some negative reviews. Have you read them all here?
July 6, 2018
I haven’t read many negative reviews :( I tried to look everywhere he does not seem to have much available
July 9, 2018
Have you had any experience with him? I am looking to get a surgery with him the winter as well! I couldn't find any negative reviews either.
July 14, 2018
I actually had a revision with him, I took my review down for now and I'll have it posted up again once I'm closer to 1 year (7 months post-op right now, but can't say I'm happy with how things have progressed however, nose is crooked). I think Dr. Smith is skilled and experienced...but I know it's something I definitely want fixed (and not through filler), so I'm in the process of getting some second opinions (already have one so far). I would recommend not touching your nose unless you hate your nose to such a degree you don't feel you'll be happy. I had my first septorhino with David Hacker and my nose was destroyed and now I'm looking at another surgery to fix my crooked/deviated nose. But regardless, feel free to send me a message or reply to this if you have any questions!
July 16, 2018
I have thick skin so I’m hoping the results won’t show as much if it’s too bad :/ he wants to thin the skin around my nose (it can go black from this which is what worries me), get rid of my slight hump and reduce the bulbous tip... his results online seem fine but my parents are telling me not too and these comments have me worried now lol... do you think I’ll be fine? I know dr jugenberg couches for dr. Smith and he’s a fantastic and reputable body surgeon
July 16, 2018
You'll find that people that have had poor results (from any surgeon) are more likely to respond as those that have good results don’t tend to linger on realself. They move on and go about their lives and will generally not be commenting on posts. So you're more likely to be getting one side only. I don't doubt Dr. Smith's skill, if you were to choose a surgeon in the GTA/Canada for rhinoplasty he would be your best bet. Rhinoplasty is just a difficult surgery and you may not be happy with the results as things beyond your ability or Dr Smith's could happen during the healing process. If I hadn't went to Hacker I would be a very different (happier and non-anxious) person. You just need to be 100% sure you are confident/comfortable with the surgery and Dr. Smith. I was not comfortable with Hacker and still went through with the surgery and put myself in this situation. So just make sure that you are certain this is what you want, Dr. Smith has had plenty of successful rhinoplasties, even the best of surgeons have less than stellar results. It's a risk you take when you decide to go through with rhinoplasty. I have sent you a pm as well!
July 9, 2018
Do you mind posting pictures of your nose and the mockup? Would love to talk to you about it, I also have a hump and want a smaller nose overall, and am thinking of getting the surgery done with him soon but I'm not just completely sure yet if he is the right doctor.
July 9, 2018
July 9, 2018
Do you have any pictures or links about the negative reviews?
July 9, 2018
For sure just waiting for my classes to finish on the tenth and I’ll be posting my whole experience thus far :) and updating as I go
July 9, 2018
Thank you very much!
August 9, 2018

Not sure if anyone is looking at this review atm, but I'll have my review up for Smith again at the end of the month. I can say one thing, I regret having my revision with him. My nose is deviated/slanted, the area above my nostril (alars) are collapsed on one side (Was not corrected during the revision despite having been told I need a graft for that), I have grafts poking through the skin on the top of my nose bridge and my breathing is still bad. He is not someone I would go to. Especially for the amount you're paying. I paid almost 18k and he messed my nose up, it looks like this " / " or " c-shaped" . He has been dishonest with me and gives me a different excuse/reason as to why my breathing isn't good or why my nose is slanted/crooked. He always has a different excuse. I have seen several other surgeons (I have another consult coming up this month) and have been told I need alar grafts at the minimum, with septoplasty most likely being needed. He put filler in my nose twice, which has done nothing much left my skin discolored and the area (on the left side of the boney portion of my nose) lumpy. It seems that many of the reviews (on many sites) are fake, on ratemd you'll find that after a negative review there will suddenly be many positive reviews that appear within a day or week. He is not the best in Toronto and if you end up with poor results you're out of luck as he will not fix it (not that I would trust him to after how he's been dishonest with me). This was one girl that had surgery with him and her nose was destroyed (idk if this is the girl the other user was talking about): https://www.realself.com/review/18-year-girl-successful-revision-rhinoplasty-move-life-2017 . I wouldn't recommend him to anyone. I need revision to fix the issues that he made worse from my botched surgery with David Hacker and the issues that he (Smith) has left me with.

September 10, 2018
wow, sorry to hear! Have you found another surgeon to fix this issue?? if so, who? I am also seeking someone for revision
September 12, 2018

Not sure if it was me you were asking, but I have a surgeon that is my first choice currently. But I have a few more consultations left before I choose. You need to wait 1 year minimum before touching your nose again. I'm being very cautious in choosing my surgeon this time after my experience with Hacker and Smith. I'm not looking to do anything to the boney portion, etc. It'll mostly be grafting to fix alar weakness/collapse and respositioning the tip cartilages to fix my crooked nose+some bossae. I'm not trying to do anything major, I just want the crookedness+alars fixed. I'll post my review up once I have my revision, I will not be going to Smith for it for sure (not that he'll do anything as he seems fine to give a different excuse/reason for my crooked nose,etc) as I don't trust him to be honest with me and I lost faith in him + his ability to fix this issued and not make it worse.

UPDATED FROM idk1997
27 days pre

Surgery is in one month!

idk1997
My surgery is less than one month away and I’m VERY nervous. I get sweaty palms thinking about it and my anxiety doesn’t help. I sat down with Dr. Smith to discuss everything I wanted all over again and he was very sweet and did not charge for the second consultation, it was meant to be a quick meeting (5 mins) that ended up lasting approx 20 mins. He was very busy so I really appreciated the time he took out of his busy day to make sure I felt comfortable with my decision and reviewed everything I wanted. He seems like a sweet man and it’s the main reason I chose him. I’m a very insecure girl as I have many problems with my face... lol. I have very thick nose skin, so my results are limited but the smallest bit counts. I’m very scared of my skin dying as he will be thinning the skin, but he assured me he does at least one thinning a month and never had any problems thus far (knock on wood). I asked for my nose to be de-projected and was told I would most likely only get 1-2 mm due to my the skin thickness. I asked for a feminine profile with a slight curve. I have a bump higher up on my nose and one lower on my nose as well, that hooks when I smile. I also have a very bulbous tip and asked for him to fix that. My parents are very worried for me, and make my stress worse. I just want to be happy, you get me? I worked at a McDonald’s 20 hours a week for 2 years at 18 and 19 while going to school for engineering and flunking a few courses to be able to afford this, I hope all goes well :/ anyways, the photo below is my original consultation pictures where I asked for a straight nose instead of the one I really meant, but it is similar enough to the shape I want.

Replies (0)

UPDATED FROM idk1997
Day of treatment

I had my surgery!

idk1997
Hello everyone, I finished my surgery this morning. It’s been roughly 9 hours post op. I’ll post an update with regards to how my first consultation went before my pics &post op. I took pics in my cast immediately out of surgery and will continue to do so until I reach my third month, then follow up with a picture a year after surgery.
Pain: I threw up twice shortly after I woke up and on the car ride home (it was approx1 hour to get home). I do feel a little dizzy and nauseous watching tv but with every passing hour I feel better. I haven’t taken a Percocet yet. I felt slight pressure on my nose when I woke up from surgery but I have no pain so far thank god! (Knock on wood).
From what I can see, the sides and the front of my nose look super cute and I was super happy to see the nose I always wanted for myself. I’ll have to see more properly when the cast comes off but so far I LOVE it :)
My parents were very nervous for me and angry I opted for PS and they have middle eastern accents so my dad came off a bit rude to the doctor but I’m sure he didn’t mean to, and it annoyed me to no end. Dr. Smith was very kind and professional although he seemed a bit annoyed ????
He has a wonderful staff and in all honesty I felt like I was being cared for by my own mother, very VERY sweet bunch of girls. I can’t emphasize how lovely they are and how skilled Dr. Smith is so far

Replies (2)

December 19, 2018
I can’t wait to see your results! Excited for you!
December 19, 2018
Thank you! I’ll post my results once the swelling goes down a bit more since my face has swelled a lot