Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

Rhinoplasy, Finally… - Chicago, IL

ORIGINAL POST

I have finally picked my doctor and set a date for...

Themissguy
WORTH IT$5,000
I have finally picked my doctor and set a date for my rhinoplasty. I know how hard it is to find good intel on surgeons, so I am starting this review.

I had read a lot about picking a doctor over the pat few years, and a lot of articles I read said to bring pictures of the nose you want. That really didn't ever make sense to me. It is not reasonable to expect something entirely different then what you've already got. Cosmetic procedures can enhance or slightly alter your features quite well, but attempting huge changes that are really contrary to your existing features/structures is not realistic. I also didn't want to be the one telling my doctor what to do.I don't know the first thing about noses! I wanted to find a doctor that told me what he would do, and see if his idea matched mine. I spoke with Dr. Epstein in Miami, Dr. Slupchynskyj in NYC, and Dr. Shah in Chicago. I am sure they are all great surgeons, but I am confident Dr. Shah is the right surgeon for me.

Dr Slup seemed confused, and even irritated that I didn't have a nose to tell him I wanted. As if it were a bother for him to decide what to do with my nose…um…don't you look at nose everyday? And you can't tell what is unappealing about my nose? His morphs horrified me, and made me reconsider having surgery all together. He, apparently, does not believe in fixing a hanging columella.

Dr. Epstein apparently cannot be bothered with too much patient interaction, and expects a $2,500 deposit before he will even meet with you. Go [RS bleep] yourself, Dr. Epstein. There are a ton of great surgeons out there.

Dr. Shah met with me, and told me he was first going to tell me what he would do to my nose before hearing what I would like. Perfect. He mentioned EVERYTHING I would have said. This is definitely the surgeon for me. It still took me a few months before I balanced out the risk/reward enough to scheduled my surgery. I am scheduled for April 24.

Themissguy's provider

Anil R. Shah, MD

Anil R. Shah, MD

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

4.6 | 374 Reviews
PROFILE

Replies (9)

March 13, 2015
Oh my $&@! Dr s's morphs are horrifying!! Scary scary scary! I met with Dr. Epstein and he didn't ask me for a 2,500 deposit. I heard Anil Shah is good, but dont know too much about him. I hope your surgery is successful! I like the morphs! Best of luck
March 13, 2015
Dr Epstein assistant, Ed spoke with me and let me know he needed the deposit to schedule a consult. Did you like Epstein, and have you had surgery and/or picked a doctor?
March 19, 2015
I liked him and had a consult with no down payment , I just went in so I don't understand. It was free. I can't stand his assistants and he has a quite a few I believe. They are annoying, but obviously they are trained to be, I guess. Too pushy for my taste. It's not epstein who personally turned me off when I seen him. It's his assistants. He's very busy so I understand that he needs them, but he needs to train them better at answering and persuading people to go with him. They made me feel uncomfortable. I have not made any decisions on who to choose though as of yet. I wanted to consult with a couple of other surgeons. I want to go and see Andrés bustillo, and Steiger . Dr Richard Davis I heard is good too, but I recently have been hearing bad stories plus his wait is forever
March 19, 2015
Good luck! Looking forward to seeing your results.
March 25, 2015
Please update us after your procedure. Hope you surgery goes well. I am also considering doctor shah for my rhino. I still haven't made up my mind. I live in Chicago and there's a lot of doctors to choose from so still doing research. How much was a consultation with shah?
April 3, 2015
$100. I think it goes towards your sx though
April 3, 2015
I am scheduled with him as well. Very nervous, but confident in his skill set/aesthetic
April 4, 2015
Your morphs look fantastic, I'm interviewing Drs presently for a revision and Dr. Shah is on my list. Prayers for a speedy recovery. Looking forward to your updates.
UPDATED FROM Themissguy
Day of treatment

Day of Surgery!

Themissguy
I was extremely nervous. Last night was AWFUL for me. I hadn't really slept in days, and I had a tension headache, which resulted in me tossing and turning with weird dreams until 4:30am when I had to shower. My surgery was moved up to 6:30. I was so anxious I thought I was going to vomit before I left my apartment. I live a pretty unstressfull life, and the anxiety really got to me. I even broke out in a nervous rash (NEVER happened before). My head was spinning as I filled out the consent forms--what the hell am I doing?!?!

They took me back to the room, took a urine sample, and put am IV in me. The IV felt uncomfortable (all in my head), and made me even more anxious. After a 30 minute wait, the Anesthetist came in and spoke with me. I found him to be warm and confidence inspiring…probably because he prompt had them start my IV sedation. Shah came in to go over the morphs. I have complete trust in him, and I love his aesthetic. Even if I don't get the morph nose, I have no doubt I will like my nose better than my old one, so that conversation was short. I was wheeled in the OR and put to sleep before I even knew what was happening.

When I woke up in recovery, I was berthing though my nose! Something I thought was not going to happen. That alone was a big relief. I asked for come ice to chew on, and took about an hour getting myself mentally prepared to go home. During the walk down to the car my nose saturated bleeding, and it bleed the whole way home, until I laid back down. I promptly stopped once I reclined. My day has been easy. I ate homemade apple sauce, popsicles, and yogurt. I am breathing mostly through my mouth, but I occasional exhale through my nose, and I think that is adding a lot to my comfort. I expect to be too swollen for that tomorrow. I am already pretty swollen and bruising, but so far, so good. I actually feel really good. I took 1 pain killer because I had an awful headache.

Replies (4)

User Avatar
April 25, 2015
I hope you heal well. Take it easy and get a lot of rest! Don't forget to ice constantly!
April 25, 2015
Thank you for updating. I'm so happy your surgery went well for you. Rest rest rest, frozen peas are your best friend right now. Take care of you.
April 25, 2015
Congrats!! Please keep us updated! I know how u feel about the anxiety .. I haven't even booked with anyone yet and the thought of it is so overwhelming I can't even deal sometimes, but I know I have to get it done too or else I'll be miserable.. So good for u! All over with! Keep us posted!
User Avatar
April 26, 2015
Hoping everything is going well! Can't wait to see your results. The tough part is over, enjoy the time to rest. And enjoy those popsicles.
UPDATED FROM Themissguy
8 days post

Day after cast removal...

Themissguy
I am the worst picture taker, but I wanted to update. I had my cast off yesterday. It was uncomfortable, but not painful. I was in a bit of a daze afterward, and terribly exhausted, for some reason that isnt apparent to me. Oh yea, I had surgery 8 days ago.

Obviously, I'm very swollen in my nose and cheeks. My black eye persists, but is slowly resolving. So far, I'm extremely happy with the result, but I also know I haven't even seen the result.

Replies (4)

User Avatar
May 3, 2015
The pictures are not the best to tell to be honest, but I can clearly see that your bridge is straight now and your tip is up a little, which looks nice to me. Also, of course, there is lots and lots of swelling to go down. I am looking forward to more of your update in the next weeks and months :D
User Avatar
May 4, 2015
Looking good!
May 5, 2015
Looking good girlfriend;-) can't wait to see more
September 3, 2016
Are you still happy with your result?