Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Breast Implant Revision REVIEWS

From silicone to saline/silicone ruptured

ORIGINAL POST

From silicone to saline

Magical2163
WORTH IT
I currently have a ruptured silicone implant that was put in only 8 years ago. I have researched all the new silicone options, and the IDEAL implant and have decided to go with traditional saline implants.
I want women to know that silicone does rupture and expensive MRI’s are necessary when a rupture is suspected. Revision surgery is also expensive and has more risks for larger incisions, increased bleeding and increased complications. We all read about these risks but always assume it won’t happen to us. Unfortunately the statistics tell the real story that most of us will need repeated surgeries every 10-15 years. I’ve heard of women having good implants for 20 years. I’m not one of them.
My story: SURGERY ONE: my first implants in 1998 (?) were saline behind the muscle. They were my first boobs about a 34C; that got me back to my pre-childbirth and pre-nursing days. Sometimes I could feel the edges but I had no ripples and was very pleased.
SURGERY TWO: In 2011 my left one ruptured and I had a flat boob. I met with a PS and he showed me silicone that did feel nice so that’s what I got. Silicone felt amazing and looked very natural. I felt like I had gotten an upgrade. And my husband said they felt so soft and real.
SURGERY THREE: Only 4 years later one of the implants began to protrude thru the muscle somehow. I could feel like a hard knot on my breast. My PS placed a mesh material in my breast to hold the implant in place.
SURGERY FOUR: Another 4 years later I decide to get a routine mammogram. It showed a possible tear. I began to have weird pains that would come and go in that breast. And it looks bigger to me. I had to have an MRI. That was more painful than the mammogram. It didn’t hurt the boobs- it was like hanging on a cross where all the weight was on my breast bone and arms above my head for 30 minutes. It confirmed an intracapsular rupture. My PS said I needed an en bloc capsulectomy and then remove or replace. I was very disappointed about the enbloc capsulectomy. It would require a much larger incision, bleeding risks, and longer recovery. I met with another PS who could place the IDEAL implants. He is going to take a more conservative approach and take out the ruptured silicone implant and look at the capsule. He plans on just cleaning it out and putting in a new implants. Leaving the option of course if a total capsulectomy is needed- he will do it. I was more comfortable with this plan so I have my surgery scheduled in August. I’m not using silicone anymore because of the silent rupture. There’s no way to know if they rupture unless you have a mammogram or MRI. And then to think I would need total capsulectomy to make sure silicone doesn’t migrate to my lungs or arms is scary. I’m an ER nurse so I’m not uneducated or squeamish. The new silicone isn’t supposed to migrate so why do they have to do capsulectomys to get all traces of silicone? So I’m just not comfortable with silicone anymore. I thought the IDEAL implants were a great product. I have a video of me holding a traditional saline on left and the IDEAL implant on the right. But my Allergan implants were still under warranty and I want to wait a few years to make sure the IDEAL company will survive. So I will update after my surgery in August on how it went.

Magical2163's provider

Timothy Wilson, MD

Timothy Wilson, MD

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

Magical2163 rating for Dr. Wilson:

Overall rating

Replies (9)

June 20, 2019
You're not alone with silicone rupture - I had a microleak with one of my implants and slowly formed painful balls in my armpit and side. I chose to replace with textured silicone. Hopefully these won't leak. Leaking implants are always scary! ... just keep in mind, if you have a saline leak, you will be instantly deformed visually with a deflated breast (to me that would be a nightmare)
June 20, 2019
Was your micro leak implants from the old kind of gel that was liquid-like? The consensus is the new gel doesn’t leak and migrate like that. Yes I’ve had saline before and I noticed the rupture at work. I put some toilet paper in my bra and had on a loose top so it was ok. I used the silicone inserts in my bra you can buy at target until my surgery.
June 27, 2019
Mine was from old implants placed around 2001. Ah then you know how to deal with it
July 5, 2019
thank you for sharing! I got my boob job done 3 months ago and sooooo many doctors tried to convince me to get silicone instead of saline. But i stuck with my gut because the health benefits far outweighs the “cons” which aren’t even real cons if you ask me. Idk care I they don’t feel as real (which isn’t true at all)!! Heath always should come first. I personally think docs get “kickbacks” for silicone implants because there’s such a huge push for women to get silicone despite the high risks
July 5, 2019
Im so glad to hear you are happy with the saline! I watched a lot of you tube videos of women that had saline and were very pleased. Especially for women who are wanting especially large implants. Because the incisions can remain minimal despite a large implant. As a medical person myself, I doubt doctors get “kickbacks” for silicone. Their surgery fee is the same whether they use saline or silicone. And the companies sell both. But a lot of women seem happier initially with their results with silicone so that’s an incentive for doctors for sure. Nobody likes to deal with dissatisfied customers. But I obviously agree with the health risks of silicone( despite everyone saying they are safe). And that’s why I’m going with saline this time. It seems so hypocritical for the industry to say silicone is absolutely safe- until they leak or rupture. And then you have to remove them. Reminds of the old glass mercury thermometers they don’t make anymore. There were safe unless they broke. Then it was unsafe. Thank you for your comments.
July 7, 2019
I believe it..I stayed with saline
User Avatar
August 18, 2019
I agree with doctors being so pushy with silicone! That was my experience too and I still stuck with saline. The silent rupture and silicone balls that can form in a women’s body scared me to death. I’ll take my “water bags” over the potential of health concerns from silicone any day. Now I don’t know if they feel any different but I LOVE mine! I watched a YouTube video of a women who initially had 800cc saline and she LOVED them. But since she had so many people comment on the size and told her how better silicone was, she went in for a second surgery to downsize and get silicone. She made a video post op saying how much she regretted her decision and how the saline and silicone felt no different. That played a huge role with why I stuck with saline. Coming from someone who has had both and she’s saying they feel no different once inside you, then I’ll take her word for it unlike someone who’s only experienced one side of the spectrum. Anyways, I think all us women weigh the pros and cons and come up with the best solution for ourselves.
August 18, 2019
Thanks for sharing, I’m switching out old saline, 5 doc are pushing silicone. I’d like the Ideal implants
August 20, 2019
I really like the ideal implants as well. But since my Allergan implants were still under warranty, I just couldn't justify not taking advantage of the free replacements plus $3500 towards surgery. Check out my video of the icky silicone mess that was in me from a silent rupture. And a mammogram was the only thing that alerted me to it.
UPDATED FROM Magical2163
1 day post

Surgery yesterday! Capsulectomy ; removed silicone; placed Allergan saline

Magical2163
I had my surgery yesterday. Things I’m glad I had at home beforehand: Aleve, chicken noodle soup, yogurt, soft foods, and my bed set up with 5 pillows. I think it went very well considering. I went in at 5am and surgery was at 7. I went to recovery at 9:30 and woke up at 10:15. The PS said “it was a mess”. That’s always fun to hear. the “mesh” material placed in 2014 to fix a protruding implant was “the mess” I think. He said it almost looked like a sponge was left in from a previous surgery. I’m not exactly sure of the details but will find out and get to see my old implants at my checkup next week. He said he ended up needing to do a capsulectomy on the breast that had ruptured silicone. The first PS opinion I had gotten said I needed an enbloc capsulectomy. Guess he was right but I went with this PS because he was going to try to be conservative and hopefully just clean it out before placing the new implant since the MRI indicated intracapsular not extracapsular rupture. He said it came out in pieces and some was stuck on my ribs. ****The good news is I have no drains, minimal swelling and pain is controlled with hydrocodone (Percocet) every 4 hours. I’m also taking 2 Aleve twice a day. I hope this regimen will only be needed for the first 2 days. I was surprised at how much my throat hurt -but it is because of the intubation and 2 1/2 hour surgery. (Chicken noodle soup and yogurt hit the spot). ****Sleeping on a homemade wedge is wonderful and really decreases pain and swelling. Plus soft pillows under each arm. I asked for same size as before and last night I was thinking for all this pain I should have gone bigger and at least had something to show for it! But this morning I feel much better and I think I am going to like the results considering I initially considered explanting when I found out I had silicone rupture and pain. Will update with pics later.

Replies (0)

UPDATED FROM Magical2163
3 days post

Postop day 3

Magical2163
My left breast looks funky I know but it had a lot of issues. When I have my surgery bra on, they look fine so I’m not overly concerned- at least trying not to be. My left incision is at least an inch more higher than my right. Not sure why that is. Is that because the incision is dictated by where your natural inframammary fold is? Will ask at follow up appointment.

Replies (0)