Does my BBL look too big?

That depends on what you want for results a little. If you want completely natural looking I would say it's right on the edge. But that's just my opinion lol As for me your butt looks like the butt I hope to have!

I don't see the slop or shelf

You truly look amazing. If I ever get my wife in for a BBL I will be bringing your pictures to show the Dr.
Only problem is you did yours with a fat transfer if I remember correctly. My wife doesn't have any fat to transfer.. so it would be implant.

Your butt looks great. Please appreciate it because sometimes it changes in a few years. Speaking from experience

It does look more firm since the initial post surgery pics. If someone want's to examine you at length in a bikini they might guess that you have had some work but they could not be sure as it's pretty natural looking. Many women of color tend to have a larger butt - yours is well within the normal range and seems to match up very well with your frame. I don't see how your result could be much better. You are your own worst critic - just enjoy your slightly enhanced shape and the compliments that will come with it.

Do you have a before? Looks great

I don't think so! However, from the side unless you had that bubble before for us plastic surgery Babes you can tell it's a bbl but regardless it looks good girl!

You look great

Your butt looks good and not fake, but I think BBLs have gotten so popular, that people can spot them now. I feel the same about my butt. I really want a reduction. Are you going to Santos for a reduction? I would love to stay connected as I’m searching for a surgeon to reduce mine.

If your partner is into big butts then girl they'll be happy lol! It looks great. Mine felt huge at first too but 7 years later it's definitely decreased. Still good but less volume. The sucky thing is I have less volume on left side than right, but i don't want a redo..

It looks great, enjoy it and your new clothes for that new booty.

It looks good just work out for that natural look:)

I think you should wait a year and let e everything settle. Research and consult a board certified plastic surgeon or discuss your concerns with your original surgeon

You look great sis! I think it suits, Enjoy it!