Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Genioplasty REVIEWS

ruined my face - Boston, MA

ORIGINAL POST

Do not walk but run quickly away from this doctor,...

NY76
$10,000
Do not walk but run quickly away from this doctor, he ruined my face.

A little background: I transitioned at 18 years old in the early 90s. I had a few nips and tucks over the years and passing was never an issue. I had my chin filed down in 2004 by a well known ffs doctor in Chicago. He did a good job but it was slightly uneven. Still passing was never an issue, beyond that I was always considered very stunning and people would gasp in disbelief when they heard of my past being transsexual. Any surgeries I had done were done very well as looked extremely natural as if nothing was done at all.

So in 2014 I decided to have the slight unevenness revised on my chin. I decided to go to Dr. Jeffery Spiegel. He was supposedly known for giving slight yet natural results. As I stated passing wasn't an issue, I didn't want to look like someone else, but I wanted someone experienced with chin surgery beyond a standard surgeon, so Dr. Spiegel seemed like the right choice.

I had a face to face consult with him told him I wanted to fix the slight unevenness and while he was in there to tapper my jaw to blend smoothly into my chin. I paid my deposit and booked surgery 2 months later. I paid the balance due in the interim. I was then contacted by the office asking if I could change my surgery date to a week later. I already had planned for a friend to go along with me and she took the time off work. I asked my friend if the new date worked and she changed her schedule. I emailed the office to get a reply back that something came up and could I move it ahead yet another week. In total this happened 3 times, my friend was beyond upset.

So mid February was the date. My friend and I arrived in Boston. I went to Dr. Spiegel's office the day prior to surgery. I was greeted by a female resident and asked several questions as to what I was looking to achieve ect. In talking I stated I generally use fillers in my cheeks, she said of would you like me to put some in today. I was a little taken aback as I was scheduled for surgery the following day. Soon after I was greeted by a girl who worked in the office, in talking she told me about a laser she did and asked if I wanted to do it today also. I don't know but I started to felt like I was in a used car lot not a surgeons office. I was finally greeted by Dr. Spiegel he and his female resident looked over my face and he pointed things out to her. We chatted he asked a few questions and was only in the room for 5 minutes and said I would see him tomorrow at the hospital.

The next morning we went to the hospital early. Came out of surgery and I don't remember much. I went back to my hotel and rested. Saw Dr. Spiegel the following day, and left town a few days later. I got home I followed all post op instructions I didn't leave the house much for the first month as I was very swollen.

Over the next few months the swelling went down a great deal. As the swelling went down I could start to see a lot of unevenness. At 4 months post op I went back to Boston with my concerns. I was not happy at all. I had lumps, bumps and dents. Unevenness, was numb and talking was difficult. Dr Spiegel said I was still healing and I would be fine, to wait 9 months come back and we could address any concerns.

I waited 9 months and still all the same problems were there. Lumps, bumps and dents. Uneven beyond words. Before surgery I hadn't looked like I done anything to my face, now after surgery I didn't look like I had cosmetic work done but more like I had some sort of trauma, like I was in a car accident and hit my lower face.

So I booked a second post op consult. I was greeted by Doctor Spiegel and two new residents, and the four of us gathered in a room slightly larger than a closet. I showed him all of my concerns and the two residents looks at my face oddly seeing that it didn't look well. The doctor said he could do a fat graft to help even things out and rushed out of the room, it seemed he didn't want these residents to see the work attached to his name. A few moments later a girl in the office came in and handed me a quote for 2,500 to do a fat graft. I replied I thought that a revision was covered. She said let me talk to him and I will call you, it has been 9 months since then and I am still waiting by the phone.

This showed me his character, based on his lack of interest in his patients and the greater interest in his wallet I won't go back.

I requested my surgical notes from Mass General. Once I received them I was beyond taken aback. To find that in each portion of the surgery it stated Dr. Speigel name along with his female resident surgeon I had met the day prior to surgery, then in the end it said Dr. Spiegel was present at all times. I am sorry but I didn't pay for a resident to operate on my face as some sort of practice in her training, and I guess ones result is based on the skill of the resident in training at the time their surgery.

It took me a while to come to terms with the fact my faced was damaged. So I did some research and traveled to see 3 maxillofacial surgeons experienced in revision work. I selected the one I felt was the best. I was sent for ct scans of my chin and jaw. There are several areas of asymmetry. I was also told the incision inside my gum is too high and poorly stitched. I need a series of small implants custom made to fill in the all the areas of asymmetry. The ct scan was 1k, the implants are $5500 and surgery is 15k, I am scheduled for surgery later this winter.

The nerve damage and loss of feeling will not return.

Going to this guy was the biggest mistake of my life.

NY76's provider

Jeffrey H. Spiegel, MD

Jeffrey H. Spiegel, MD

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon, Board Certified in Otolaryngology – Head and Neck Surgery

4.8 | 380 Reviews
PROFILE

NY76 rating for Dr. Spiegel:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (17)

User Avatar
July 23, 2016
You put everything very well , I feel deeply sorry for your experience . Good luck in future surgeries !
July 23, 2016
Thank you. I found it oddly funny that this doctor had 2 positive reviews on the same day, the day after my negative review. Yet he hadn't had a review in months before mine, coincidence I think not.
September 19, 2016
Nerve damage - like has your lower lip movement been affected, or was it only a loss of sensation? If movement, what was the change?
November 18, 2016
Wow, I was totally convinced he was a good surgeon. Guess your testimony serves as an example that people aren't always what you read or hear. Thanks for sharing, and have a quick + lovely recovery !
November 30, 2016
So sorry.
January 2, 2017
I am so sorry to hear about your experience -truly... so thank you for sharing this. I would offer that while fat grafts are decent at re-filling an area in my experience they have been iffy long term in terms of symmetry as one loses and gains weight... I have instead used micro droplets of Silikon 1000 which are permanent and have been really wonderful for me. I've done them in stages to see how reactive my tissue is to them.. but they can be administered very precisely and are truly permanent... There is another filler which reportedly seems to hold something like 80% of its volume even after 8 years called Bellafill which might be an option too since it is sometimes more difficult finding Silikon 1000 which is the surgical grade pure form of silicon.
Peace and my best to you in 2017 for your surgery...
UPDATED FROM NY76
3 years post

A little update

NY76
A little update, here are portions of my surgical notes I requested directly from Boston Medial Center. The resident is all over them in every portion. My interaction was mostly with the resident not the surgeon I hired. This might explain why my jaw is uneven and lopsided. It also states that JS was president during “critical portions” of the case. I have still yet to get it revised. I planning to do so soon. Going here was the biggest mistake.

Replies (5)

March 29, 2018
That’s horrifying. I’m so sorry they did that to you! I read your story and I hope you got everything revised or getting revised soon. You deserve to be happy. I can’t believe a resident performed your surgery without your verbal consent; how unethical of them!
April 24, 2018
Wow, that's really bad. Sorry this happened to you.
July 27, 2018
Could you file a lawsuit against this doctor since the price you paid was for the doctor not the resident. I've heard this happening before for women getting lipo and tummy tucks. I feel the doctor should ask or inform the patient that a resident would be working on them. That is so dishonest in my opinion what he did. I'm so sorry you had this experience.
May 3, 2019
I am one of those patients. May I ask, did you come in under insurance or cash?
January 22, 2024
I'm sorry this happened to you. Do you still have the nerve damage? Did your overall condition improve?