POSTED UNDER Chin Implant REVIEWS
Chin Fail - Bellevue, WA
ORIGINAL POST
I had a chin implant surgery performed by Dr....
EM22August 18, 2015
$5,000
I had a chin implant surgery performed by Dr. Young in 2013. It was a revision of an implant surgery that I got 5 years previously from another doctor that shifted horribly. My objective was to have the old implant taken out and a new one inserted and screwed in so it would not shift. I wanted the size to remain the same and that was communicated to the doctor. I had the surgery and that's when all hell broke loose. I was really swollen in the days after and there was some redness and fluid build up. Dr. Young identified this as an infection despite not doing a culture and there being an absence of pus or pain in the area. Instead of taking the implant out, he opened up the incision and I began a regiment of packing with gauze until it healed by itself. I packed 3x a day for 3months. Finally the incision closed and I healed....so I thought...I always thought the implant was big but I was so burnt out on the whole process that I just let it go. Right after surgery, Dr Y said he made the decision to put a larger implant in because he thought it looked better and that he'd "shave" it down if I didn't like it. Fast forward two years. Since the surgery, my chin area had always been tight and there was still a little redness but in May of 2015, the redness increased....then turned to purple...Basically the implant was pushing through my skin and the nightmare started all over again because he put such a big implant in. I went back to Dr. Y and he cut out the purple, thin piece of skin that was covering the implant and tried stretching skin around it the implant and sewing. That failed and after packing with gauze again for a few weeks, I was seen by another Dr. who told me to have the implant taken out which I did by Dr. Y. I was only put under local sedation for the implant removal and could hear and feel the screws being taken out of my bone. It was awful. So after all that, I'm left with major scarring and emotional issues. I went into to have my teeth cleaned the other day and about had a panic attack lying in the chair with someone working on me in that area. I was flashing back to having the implant taken out...Anyway, I feel bad posting this review because I think Dr. Young tried and cared but there were multiple missteps and instances where I think he was less then truthful. He definitely lets his ego get in the way as well. Nobody cares that you got the best score in the nation on the written exam if you don't use common sense and slow down. Plastic surgery is a big deal and when it goes wrong, it can change your life.
Replies (21)
August 19, 2015
August 19, 2015
I'm definitely considering taking action. Especially after reading the DOH report. It showed me how dishonest he was with me at times. When he decided I had an infection and recommended I start the regiment of packing and wound care, he straight up told me he hadn't "lost one yet" referring to taking implants out due to infection. The report specifically cites patients of his that had to have their implants removed way before me. So that comment was a lie. I asked him once as well if the jaw bone can be broken from the screws (because I knew that had happened to his former patient) and he instantly said no. I noticed in the DOH report that he repeatedly wanted to do fat transfers on these patients as a quick fix when it wasn't appropriate. He did the exact same thing to me. He got weird on me a few times with text messaging too....Wanted me to drive down to his office so he could remove a drainage tube at 10:30pm which would have been a 150 mile round trip for me...I just went to the ER down the street from me and it took them 5 minutes...Just a bizarre experience.
August 21, 2015
It sounds like you had a real rough time with this and that really sucks. I guess you never had another one put in after the 2 fails. I was recently thinking of getting a chin implant but, sometimes I feel like I don't know anymore. It seems like some people have great experiences and others horrible beyond what they should have to go thru. Even the people that are originally happy with their implant, I just wonder how long they stay happy with it before it shifts or for whatever reason becomes uncomfortable. I have to ask, do you regret ever having this done? Hope it gets better for you.
August 21, 2015

September 19, 2015
I am so sorry to hear about your story. You should not feel bad about posting what happened to you at all. It was not your fault. It is also a lesson to others about how the surgeon handles issues so it is incredibly important. Thank you.

October 19, 2015
I think the same as Naomi, you've had a terrible time and it sounds like you have been very fair with your judgments. x

December 1, 2015
OMGoodness hon, I am so sorry to see and hear you went through all of this!!! I went through my own nightmare experience as well! It certainly gave me trust issues with the medical community as well as surgical procedures. What is next for you? Is there an alternative product for you to use, or are you just done with any attempt to augment your chin? I hope all heals up for you physically as well as what you have lived through with this!!!
December 3, 2015
Ahh. Thanks for the kind words;) I'm doing better and getting over it. I'm not going to do any more procedures and just want to move on. I'm pretty fortunate to have a good support system who helped me through it all. Definitely a life lesson!
Replies (18)
August 18, 2015
Jesus, that hole under your chin. I'm getting an implant next Monday and I hope everything goes ok with me. Hopefully you will recover emotionally.
August 18, 2015
I'm sure you'll be fine. The odds of this happening is really low. My issue was that it dragged on for so long trying to "fix" it with small procedures when I should have just had the implant taken out.

August 20, 2015
This Dr has multiple lawsuits against him in relation to infections etc. There is another lady on rs and he completely ruined her nose by not treating infections right. She is getting compensation and so are others. I think you should too x
December 1, 2015
Kristy, do you know of any other doctors to avoidd or docs with lawsuit against them?
August 21, 2015
You should file a complaint with the Washington department of health' health
November 18, 2016
He contacted me the other day and tried to convince me to change or remove my post. Ridiculous!
December 7, 2015
Thank you for your post! How are you doing now (is your chin doing better)?
December 7, 2015
I'm doing good now. Just trying to move on. My chin is fine but I'll probably always have facial hair because the scarring is so bad. Overall I'm fairly lucky because there's no real permenent damage aside from the scarring...I'm just glad it's over!
December 7, 2015
Wow, that's a relief your chin is doing alright now. Have you tried any treatments for your scar, like lasers or ointments?
December 8, 2015
Maybe someday I'll look into a treatment for the scars but I'm just not worrying about it these days. Trying to enjoy life;)

June 4, 2016
Wow so sorry you had to go thru this. I too went thru chin implant hell. Had my implant inserted and taken out due to shifting 3 times. The last implant which looked great wound up getting infected. My dr immediately said it had to be removed and much as I was heartbroken I knew it had to be done. After that I received a fat transfer to the chin and I'M DONE!! :-)
You really never know with implants, is tricky.
You really never know with implants, is tricky.
June 6, 2016
Sounds like your doctor was responsible and made the correct decision right away. I went months nursing mine only to have it come out anyway. How'd the fat transfer look?

June 7, 2016
Yes, I'm glad to have had it out and over with. I actually had some projection from the scar tissue which helped my profile. The fat was helpful, however not the end all to the problem. I still had to get fillers. My goal originally was to get the chin looking good and no maintenance. Will be putting money every year now there. Although I'm still happy as this could have been so much worse. How are you doin?
June 8, 2016
Doing good. It's been a year so I'm recovered. I actually ended up with more projection because of the scar tissue too! That was a nice surprise. No more PS for me though ;)

June 9, 2016
Completely understand. I consider myself lucky to have come thru this with nothing terrible lingering. Surgery is risky and I've had enough too!

Thank you very much for sharing your experience on RealSelf.