Difference between Alloderm and Strattice?
Doctor Answers 5
Cosmetic Applications: Strattice vs. Alloderm
The main difference between these two products as you have already noted is in the origin: porcine vs. human cadaveric. They are both produced by the same manufacturers and work in a similar fashion. The primary reason Strattic has become the go-to product for revisionary cosmetic procedures is that of cost. Strattice is less costly than Alloderm. In the comsetic setting, where insurance is not involved and the patient bears the brunt of cost, Strattice is the more economical choice.
Ultimately, both are safe and effective options for the treatment of "bottoming out." If the idea of using a product of porcine origin is of concern there are a number of other ADM options available from other manufacturers which may offer some cost savings over Alloderm. Alternatively, you could choose to pay for the additional cost of Alloderm.
As always, discuss your concerns with a board certified plastic surgeon.
The issue is cost ADM
As you may know, LifeCell manufacturers both Strattice, which you correctly identify is a porcine (pig) product, and AlloDerm is human cadaver skin. In general, the Strattice is more uniformly made than the AlloDerm and it usually is a bit thicker. In cosmetic cases the costs are completely born by you. Your surgeon is trying to save you money because the lLifeCell company will give you 2 pieces of the Strattice, one for each breast, for the cost of 1. Therefore, you save half to cost. They do not make this offer with AlloDerm. Therefore, you save a substantial amount of money to use the Strattice. Your surgeon could however use AlloDerm if this is what you choose and he can tell you the difference in cost but I would estimate that will be double the cost of the material. Hope this is helpful to you.
Alloderm and Strattice are both types of Acellular Dermal Matrices (ADM's) which are commonly used in breast augmentation or reconstructive surgery. They essentially do the same job by trying to prevent bottoming out, and use can be based on patient preference, cost and availability. They are not the only versions out there though and there are other ADM's to choose from. DermACELL is an alternative to Alloderm as it is a decellularized regenerative human tissue matrix which is becoming more popular in use within the plastic surgery world. Others include FlexHD or DemaMatrix. If your heart is set on not having "pig tissue", you should look into the other types of cadaveric ADM's that are available.
You might also like...
Strattice and Alloderm are both great products
Alloderm vs. Strattice
There are a variety of different products that we call ADMs (acellular dermal matrix). Alloderm and Strattice are made by the same manufacturer. They are both quality products that can effectively be used to treat capsular contracture or bottoming out. The cellular components are removed from the tissue and both of them provide a fibrous structure that can be used for reconstruction. Alloderm stretches more easily than Strattice, but either one can be effective with your problem. The other issue that comes up is cost. Alloderm is significantly more expensive to use in cosmetic surgery. I think that both products are safe and effective. I would not be afraid to use Strattice, but in my practice I use Alloderm much more frequently.
These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.