Dark Around the Nipples After Tattooing

if the areola does not lighten on its own over several months to one year after being done, then you could try laser to lighten the coloration which may be more effective than trying to retattoo with a lighter pigment on top of the untreated darker pigment.  If the laser tattoo removal helps lighten the color but creates a less than ideal homogenous result, you can then retattoo.

A natural, non altered areola is lighter than the nipple, so I understand your concern.  I am not sure when you received the areolar tattooing, but most of the time the pigment does fade.  The medical grade tattooing is not performed as deeply in the skin as a normal art tattoo which makes it more susceptible to lightening.  Give it about six months and if you are still not happy then return to your surgeon. I hope this helps you.

Kindest regards,

Neil J. Zemmel