Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

Paul E. Kelly, MD

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon
400 Old Country Rd, Suite 16, Riverhead, New York
4 | 5 Reviews
28 Questions Answered
This provider is not currently accepting consultations through RealSelf

MAKE SURE YOUR DOCTOR IS REALSELF VERIFIED

RealSelf Verified doctors complete our multistep verification process to ensure they are in good medical standing, display their experience and most performed procedures, have high patient satisfaction ratings, and respond to consultation requests quickly. Just look for the RealSelf Verified badge.

FIND A VERIFIED DOCTOR

ARE YOU DR. KELLY?

Claim your profile now— it costs nothing! Build trust by highlighting education, board certifications, and hospital privileges. List treatments, and include all procedures you perform. Get involved by uploading before & after procedure photos and answering questions from prospective patients.

CLAIM YOUR PROFILE
FEATURED DOCTOR
SEE ALL

Paul E. Kelly, MD reviews

Paul E. Kelly, MD

RATING DETAILS

4.0
5 reviews

All reviews are evaluated by the RealSelf team to ensure they're written by patients like you and meet our guidelines. Your results may vary. Doctors can never pay to have reviews removed or hidden.

START YOUR REVIEW FOR
Paul E. Kelly, MD
Select your rating:
5 Results
Rhinoplasty

Stellar_Stila

Dr. Kelly is a hidden gem - he used every maneuver in his repertoire to get me breathing well again

I had my rhinoplasty-septoplasty with Dr. Kelly in October of 2020. My sinuses were messed up enough to get my insurance to pay for the functional aspect but at the age of 42 my nose was getting larger and droopier. I decided to correct the aesthetics as well, which included getting a medium chin implant. Dr. Kelly corrected my multitude of internal sinus issues and also gave me an aesthetically pleasing nose. It’s rather hard to find a double board certified ENT and plastic surgeon without trekking into Manhattan. He did what other surgeons charge double and triple for. His office staff is terrific. His nurse Nikki will answer any and all questions and will put you on the right track for healing optimally. Nose jobs are intimidating for the patient but I felt I was in the best hands with Dr. Kelly and his staff. I now realize I was kind of a difficult case with the three internal functional issues and a S shaped septum. I’m so thankful I went with Dr. Kelly. I think he used every maneuver in his repertoire to get me breathing well again and looking better too.

Chin Liposuction

Gemmstar

Results exceeded my expectations. Great Dr. Great Practice!!!!

I chose Dr. Kelly to perform chin liposuction. It was one of the best decisions I have ever made. I was extremely pleased with the results, in fact they were even better than I expected. The office staff was pleasant and professional. Dr. Kelly was attentive and took his time with me to ensure that all my questions were answered both before and after the procedure. I have and will continue to recommend Dr. Kelly and would definitely return to him for any future procedures I may choose to have in the future!

$1,000Juvederm

Veryhopless

Juviderm is Ruining Lives 2 Years Later - Southampton, NY

26 months ago, I had Juviderm injections under my eyes, & in my lips, to try & even out some bumps & symmetry which had been lost over time as a result of fat injections, ( another "myth; I had my lips done via fat in 1990, & it NEVER dissolved, just got bumpy.) All was ok for a while, but over 2 years later, both results suddenly began to change & move around for the worse. The "volume" which WAS, in my lips, has now moved WELL over the lipline, on both the top & bottom lip, giving me platypus effect, esp the upper. My eyes suddenly developed HUGE kidney shaped FESTOONS, underneath, which appeared to move around if pushed. One knows, when a substance in one's face is foreign. ONE injection round of Vitrase fixed the eye bags within 24 hours, a problem with which I'd been living with for weeks, wanting to die every morning. Now, my lips have followed, one month later, looking like someone punched me in the upper lip, & I will have to find another doctor, because the original DR refuses to believe this is from his injections. Something's happening to many of us, 24+ months after injections of Juviderm, which these doctors are in complete denial about. Women are being admitted for depression, for ruining their faces, because this problem is not being dealt with. My doctor refused to even LOOK at this site, and all the misery people are sharing, two years after injections, There is not enough known about the long term affects of this filler, and what they THINK they know, is very flawed. Updated on 24 May 2014: I have still not found a doctor to try and fix my lips. Updated on 25 May 2014: Now, about 7 weeks AFTER one very minute amount of dissolver was injected under eyes, may not look it, but great improvement. Transformation was immediate. I have a lipodystrophic very thin face, so every "bump" shows up. WE, are the ones who WANT filler in the first place, because of this very fact. My eyes "hollowed" again, bags beneath shrank a bit immediately, though they are still VERY much there, but but more residually, more from the skin that was stretched. I no longer can actually "feel" a substance moving around under my eyes. As you can see, the lips remain a disaster, lumping unevenly on top, & a deflated lower, hanging like a ducklip. Updated on 28 May 2014: My original DR Kelly has come through after all for me, & I had the first Vitrase injections in my lips today. I don't see too much difference yet, but the pressure & tightness from the edema, esp over the upper lip, feels a tiny bit less. The bottom lip seems to be "flattening" somewhat. Updated on 2 Jun 2014: It is huge, the difference. DR Kelly treated the lips themselves, but these next injections need to be above & below the lips, where it is obvious the Juvenile swell is still going on But the difference is absolute Updated on 12 Jun 2014: As if someone pricked a balloon, I'm showing my lips before and after 2 rounds of Vitrase dissolver. Updated on 25 Jun 2014: I've had 2 rounds of Vitrase in the lips. Now, the top is excessively bigger than the bottom, chronically giving me an upsidown smile-frown. I hope to god some more Vitrase in the top will do SOMETHING to improve this...The lumps, I am forever stuck with, for they are from an old fat injection. However, the swelling of the breaking down Juviderm, "pushed" these lumps lower on my top lip, covering my teeth, looking awful, and from some angles, hideous.

$7,500Facelift
East Hampton

East Hampton

Great - Aquebogue, NY

had some down time and didnt like the way I looked - old

Rhinoplasty

RCareleton355

Bad Nose Job - Long Island, NY

I did not achieve the results I had hoped for. My advice would be to choose your surgeon extremely carefully and be on the same page as them before the procedure. I do think with the right doctor it is possible to be happy with the results. The recovery is manageable and if you are totally committed to the process then go for it.