Rhinoplasty: Stories

Write a Review

Happy but with Caveats (with video) - Seattle, WA

  • posted 2 years ago
  • updated 11 days ago

Several years ago, in my late twenties, I decided...

Several years ago, in my late twenties, I decided to get rhinoplasty. I had a huge nose that didn't fit my face at all. As I was having my consultation, I found out that I also had a very deviated septum. A large bone spur was pushing my nose to the left.

The surgery went fine. Recovery sucked. I was very nauseated the first night, but did not throw up, thank God. I had packing, which was removed after a few days (I compare this to how it might feel if someone pulled worms from your brain). I wasn't able to work for a full week. When all was said and done, I was pretty happy with my results. Loved the hump-free, new nose, though I did have a bump near my tip that hadn't been removed.

Fast forward five years. My nostrils had collapsed inward to the point that I had to wear nose strips to breathe at night. I went to see Dr. Murakami in Seattle, who said that too much cartilage had been removed. He suggested moving cartilage from one ear to the worst nostril, so that's what he did. He also removed the bump on the tip of my nose. That recovery was much better and I'm not sure why. He didn't pack my nose, but overall I felt much less tired and sick. That was a few years ago now.

I'm quite happy with my nose, though it's nowhere near perfect. It still lists to one side and probably always will. It has a great line, though. My right nostril has since collapsed inward a fair amount. Side that was fixed is still good. I'm not planning on seeking out another revision, so this is it. I hated my original nose so much that, even with all I've been through, my rhinoplasty was still very much worth it to me.

Great review?

My Doctor: Craig S. Murakami, MD

My rating:

Doctor's Bedside Manner
Answered My Questions
After Care Follow-Up
Time Spent With Me
Phone or Email Responsiveness
Staff Professionalism & Courtesy
Payment Process
Wait Times

He was professional, friendly, smart, and clearly knew what he was doing. He did not at all try to sell me, but at first ordered me a sinus CAT scan to make sure that wasn't the issue with my breathing. It wasn't and we proceeded with the surgery. I felt like I was in great hands.

Comments (33)

Sort by
mullinsd2 8 May 2013
The breathing part sucks, but you do look very nice! It looks natural as well. I have been kind of worried about my nose being to wide post surgery with spreader grafts, but I guess it is for the better if it will prevent a future collapse.
Kitten44 16 Oct 2012
Firstly, you are beautiful. There is no way that you'd ever need to do anything more to your nose from an aesthetic standpoint. I wish I had seen this website back in 2004 when I had a nose job in the UK where I was living at the time. I had no idea that this was such a difficult surgery as all the girls who I grew up with got nose jobs routinely as teenagers like buying new jeans. (ie it was veeeeery common). I wanted to refine my tip which was quite bulbous and rasp a small bump. (Structurally I don't think there was anything wrong with my old nose.) My nose was broken and narrowed at the top (not sure why as I preferred it with some width) and is now collapsing on one side. Breath rites don't even work for me. I hope I can find someone through this awesome site nearby to revise this mess in future. In the meantime, I hope that sites like this one will help people understand what a big deal a rhinoplasty really is and to choose a surgeon very wisely. Don't go to someone whose claim to fame is doing lovely breast augs, go to someone who primarily does noses and faces.
LarsFox 16 May 2012
WoW I never thought about having future nostril problems!!! Yikes! I am glad you can at least breathe and it looks amazing! I don't think people really notice people's nostrils anyways. By the way I love your hair!!!
Hanno 5 Dec 2011
I had an unsuccessful rhino pasty in my country from a famous doct and board certified!!. 
And after watching your video I am thinking of going to your doctor in Seattle.
but I am  worried of grafted cartilage from reabsorbing or collapsing؛(
Mila1986 2 Dec 2011
you are very brave! and an inspiring person! eke your positivity up! and you are gorgeous inside and out! :)
Mila1986 2 Dec 2011
*keep
Mellymelly 15 Nov 2011
Angie!! You're so flipping gorgeous as well!

You're such a sweet, sweet person!
Don't ever let anyone tell you different. :)
youngwithanewtummy 13 Nov 2011
Love it! A friend of mine had a nose job! I'm going in for a tummy tuck on the 2nd have you had a tuck?
Angiemcc (Community Manager) 14 Nov 2011

No I haven't, though I'm often tempted. :0)

youngwithanewtummy 14 Nov 2011
Oh! Lol well I know I'm excited for mine! But if you get a tummy tuck done post a review!lol
youngwithanewtummy 7 Nov 2011
Amazing sory!!! I know people who have had a rhinoplasty done but iwill pass lol! You haven't had a tummy tuck by chance?
Angiemcc (Community Manager) 19 Oct 2011

Hi Bree,

You're about to go for it! Very exciting!

As far as your questions go, though I've had rhinoplasty and revision rhinoplasty and am a community manager here, I'm afraid I don't have good answers for your questions. I do believe years of experience is important, but everyone is different. Maybe you've discovered a real talent who has honed his or her craft already.

And yes, I would go with someone certified by the ASPS. In fact, go to a rhinoplasty specialist, not just someone who does a few nose jobs. You'll want to see the doctor's before and after pictures, which should give you a good idea of their work.

An ENT with a real flair for cosmetic aesthetics might be fine. I ended up with an ENT/Plastic surgeon and thought he did a nice job.

Hope this helps!

bree2010 17 Oct 2011
Hi Angiemcc,
Thanks so much for sharing. I'm just starting to research and look into a rhinoplasty and also have a deviated septum and nose that is just too large for my face. I've gone to two consultations so far. I did like that one of the doctors told me they try to take less of the cartilage away so that your nose keeps structure and function. I assume that is the best.
I have a couple of questions:
Do you think that years of experience is really important? I am looking into some that have been practicing for 6 years.
Also, if they specialize in facial plastic surgery do they still need to be certified by the ABPS? I see that some I like so far are certified by many other boards and also ENT docs.
Any other suggestions? Thank you so much for your input!
Cabin_escape 5 Oct 2011
thank you angiemcc.. for the email But I cant reply to it or get private email from the "real" site it posts unable to display internet page

thank you
Itty Bitty Committee 12 Sep 2011
Angie! Thanks for sharing your story. I agree with previous comments, your nose looks amazing!
Berowra 10 Aug 2011
I had a closed rhinoplatsty 2 months ago abroad I feel that my nose is just a little bit smaller I had a big,long and boulbus nose and there was an ugly split in the middle of it my split is gone but over all size is not much smaller. Do you think I still have a lot of swelling at this stage I heard that the majority of swelling is gone at this stage. I have noticed a month ago my nose was smaller I don't know why it is getting bigger.
And my top lip is too stiff and long, did you have the same problem??!!

Thanks for reading my comment I don't know who to talk to my doctor is 20 hour flight from home and my husband think I am a bit looney cause I talk about my nose all day. I am depressed and frustrated I don't know what to do. Please be honest with me and tell me would my nose get a lot smaller.
Angiemcc (Community Manager) 11 Aug 2011

HI there,

I do think most of the swelling is supposed to be gone by then, but doctors say to wait 6 months to a year to see your final results, so maybe it's not gone at all.

I didn't have the issue with a stiff lip, but I definitely did have a hard nose tip, congestion and a nasally voice for a while.

Can you place a call or email to your doctor and ask about your fears?

Taniadalia 6 Aug 2011
hey. how are you?
i was wondering when does the nose not look big and swollen in pictures. does it take a full 6 months for the nose to look decent in pictures??. mine looks really big and im 6 weeks post op now :)
Angiemcc (Community Manager) 6 Aug 2011

Most doctors say to give it six months to a year before the swelling fully subsides. A long time, I know.

sushisushi 16 May 2011
I love how your nose looks! You look great!! My only concern with getting this operation done is sacrificing function over looks. I'd rather keep my big nose than not be able to breathe. It's a difficult decision.
Angiemcc (Community Manager) 16 May 2011

It is hard. I do feel like I sacrificed some function for form. I also wonder if I could've kept my function if I'd chosen a better surgeon the first time around (didn't do much research at all) or if my nose is just a difficult case. Good luck. Let us know what you decide.

Angiemcc (Community Manager) 8 Apr 2011

Hi Martino,

Thank you for your kind words.

I would suggest staying as close to home as possible. This is to ensure good aftercare. If you travel somewhere far from where you live and then have issues, it is much, much harder to get those issues taken care of.

Please let us know what you decide to do!

anon9886 28 Mar 2011
Angie! what are you talking about, oh my goodness,,,your noses is FLAWLESS, so straight, natural, omg,,,you are very good looking woman!!! no single thing to point out! teeth like a white pearls, symmetrical features, nice thin nose, u can go to hollywood!!!
look at me! I look like a shrek,,,,:-)))

anyway, i can see u r a moderator, and I need help! I need to fix my nose asap, as that is why I am not dating and I am getting old....I am willing travel worldwide, but dont wanna pay fortune, unless the result is assured.
What do you think about Europe? Any specific destination or specific surgeon?
What about Thailand? Iran? Brasil? I have heard they are better and cheaper than anywhere else.

Please, let me know ur opinon.

Thanks

Martino
ricanmami 12 Mar 2011
your nose looks great!!
CittyCat 24 Feb 2011
Thank you for sharing your video. Your nose looks good, sorry to hear about the collapse on the other side. Thank you your comment on my mommy makeover page.

Welcome Back

Sign in with Facebook

Your information remains private and will not be posted without your permission.

Forgot your password?

Don't have an account? Create one now.

Join RealSelf

Join with Facebook

Your information remains private and will not be posted without your permission.

Please enter a valid email address
 Did you mean ?

By creating an account, you are indicating that you have read and accept the RealSelf Terms of Use.

Already a member? Sign In.

Retrieve your password

Enter your username or email address and we will send you a link to login.

Check your email

Check your email. We've sent you a link to reset your password.

Ok