Rhinoplasty: Stories
Write a ReviewSome Improvement but Still Looks BIG to Me - Chicago, IL
- LR2Girl
- posted 1 year ago
- updated 1 year ago
- Not Worth It
- Cost: $23,000
- Chicago
I had one rhinoplasty to fix a collapsed nostril...
- 22 Jan 2012
I had one rhinoplasty to fix a collapsed nostril and reduce a hump on my bridge which was covered by insurance. Ear cartilage was used and things didn't turn out well. I sought a second one--a complete reconstruction (no insurance) where rib was used.
It looks better in some respects but I still think it looks huge and extra stuff was done that I didn't want done. My doc will do some additional surgery, but I have a much higher bridge, huge tip and the reconstructed side still looks strange.
I could use some advice and input. I'm including photos of my nose before surgery with the collapse, one after the first surgery and two after the second surgery--one is a candid and one is a retouched one from the surgeon.
Great review?
Comments (21)
Sort by





I hear you about the bridge graft - I had one too and I also think it makes my eyes look too close together. Apparently it's supposed to blend in the brow ridge and look "feminine" but giving someone a higher radix makes it looks masculine. And I can't get used to it!
I think you've been really overcharged for the surgery and there must be some fine rhinoplasty surgeons out there who don't charge so much.
What he may have been trying to do was "blend" in your pinched nostril/bridge with the rest of the nose with cartilage, and just used way too much cartilage. I have had this cartilage grafting myself for a pinched nose and unfortunately it made my nose look too wide - I and I will now need other ops to refine it. I don't blame my surgeon (I know that revisions/reconstructions are difficult) - it's just one of those things. However, if I was to go in for a 2nd revision with him, I would expect a significant improvement that time round. Maybe the first time might not get there... but after 2, I would expect something better for sure! It is actually harder to add than to subtract successfully.
Prodigiousflames is right... makemeheal and look your best are great sites for rhinoplasty, I am so sure you'll be able to chat there and there'll be others in similar positions.
Lr2girl I hope you found your way to the rhino forum! I am 100% sure you'll put this behind you within the next year.
Hi there! Did your nostril collapse on its own initially? Or was that the result of an accident or surgery?
You're a lovely, lovely lady, but your nose does look off still. Were both surgeries done by the same surgeon and was he or she board certified by ASPS or ASAPS? I'm not sure when you had this done, but it could still be somewhat swollen.
I'm going to suggest that you post your photos and a question to doctors in RealSelf's Q&A community. I think you'll be able to get some good feedback there.
Thank you so much for sharing your story and photos with us.
You might also want to check out the Revision Rhinoplasty community.
I'm really sorry you're going through this. Everyone deserves to have a nose that fits her face.