Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

So Far, Not Worth It in Many Ways: Surgery and Revision for Birth Deformity Type Nose

ORIGINAL POST

I had a rhinoplasty at 17 to correct a birth...

CSmitty
$15,000

I had a rhinoplasty at 17 to correct a birth deformity type nose which left me with very, very flared nostrils, a low bridge, and a super wide tip. I'm a white male, and this nose was not natural for my face, and since the strong profiles are whats attractive, I wanted my nose to look stronger and more shaped up, although I was realistic about what changes could be made for such a rarer nose.

I went with a local surgeon who promised to be conservative in some aspects, while also giving the changes I needed.

Cast off: He absolutely butchered my nose in a micheal jackson way. It didn't help that my nose was all around worked on; bringing the nasal bones in, the tip, the brige, and he botched all of it. The result was that I had a super, super thin nasal bridge roof and tip point appearance, while having thick skin which made it all look so unnatural.

I traveled to a cali specialist a year and a half later to correct the issues, and he also botched me. he inserted grafts that no where near replaced or gave strong, attractive tip points or a symmetrical bridge. All the grafts were put (or shifted) to unwanted areas and it makes some aspects of my nose look so huge, but the middle structure is still so thin and deviated looking on both sides. It's a very, very unnatural nose, definatly the essence of 'shrek' or 'boxer-nose'. I definatly look like I've been in 5 fights because my nose looks so bulldogish and unnatural.

Some pros though: even beyond all the nasal deformities I had, my primar doctor performed my nostril flare reduction fairly good and I was definatly happy for that small aspect. He also in some way made my tip less round in the collumella-ish area and now my nostril holes show in a good way and it doesn't look so much like shrek as my original nose, and that good aspect at least helped me live through all the other bad deformities.

All i can say is i wish 200% that I would have went to a different primary doctor, because I do know that a rhinoplasty change was needed for me, but I just wish my primary doc didn't perform it, and I wish I didn't choose my 2nd doctor for my revision. I definatly could not have lived my life the way I wanted to with my original nose, but I still have a long way to go it seems. So yeah, I still need a 2nd revision, hopefully I'll be able to find a great doctor who truly will care about me and indentify all my problems and fix them as well!

CSmitty's provider

Alexander G. Nein, MD, MS, FACS

Alexander G. Nein, MD, MS, FACS

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

CSmitty rating for Dr. Nein:

Overall rating

Replies (5)

September 29, 2009
Hi There sounds like you have a bad time and I'm sorry about that. What are you going to do now? Are you going to save up to correct it again? It would be really helpful to know the name of the other doctor to save other people from going to them. Thank you
User Avatar
October 9, 2009
now i ask, you waste that much of money without DOING YOUR RESEARCH¿¿??guess it wasnt your fault but next time do it for god love. for another side, just take a lot of care of you, hoping the best for ya.
October 16, 2009
Hey, Steban, although I was younger at the time and didn't do proper research with my primary surgery (in the real world, very few people considering primary rhinoplasty look many things up online. I had no clue the true ratio of botched rhinoplasty surgeries, and my surgeon at the time made it sound like it was nearly impossible to have a bad outcome.), I DID do TONS of research with my revision, I spent a year and a half choosing many doctors, and I went with the one that out of them all, seemed so PERFECT for me, but when surgery came, I had the luck of him absolutely botching my nose and refusing to correct my problems dispite how extensive and planning I was to him in consultation before surgery. He used me for money, just like the first surgeon. This is what makes doing research hard, I have no clue who I can trust now, you can't just trust good credidentials and a populated city any more.
User Avatar
November 28, 2009
i see, you have your points, but what was you problem, can you post at least one pic, cus in all about it and my problem is my bulbous nose, want it a lil bit norrowed but i havent yet found a doctor that convice me for, but well how are you know, how is it going¿? take care,.
February 16, 2017
Did you have another revision?