I have the option of a good doctor (25,000 patients) using Wavelight Allegretto or another doctor with much more overall experience (45,000 patients) using the Nidek. Is it possible that the doctor using the Nidek can achieve an equal or better result than the one using the Wavelight Allegretto?
Wavelight Allegretto Vs. Nidek for Lasik?
Doctor Answers (2)
Which laser to use
i've used and been certified on both these platforms. neither one of them offers a true Custom WaveFront treatment. the Nidek can do custom in Japan, but their more advanced laser never got FDA approval in the US, because they're selling so few lasers here it wasn't worth doing the FDA trial in the US, as that costs over $1 million. the market share of Nidek for LASIK in the US, by the way, is about 1%. meaning 99% of the procedures in the US are done on a different platform. the only reason to use a Nidek laser in the US now is that it is cheaper to use it than most other lasers, because it doesn't require a royalty or "click" fee. so doctors or centers wanting to cut prices below the competition often use the Nidek, as that's one way to reduce their costs. i used to use a Nidek EC 5000 laser myself, but that was way back in 2000, when that was a state-of-the-art laser.
in terms of the Allegretto, that, too, is not a true Custom WaveFront platform. it is so not true wavefront, that FDA prohibited that company from marketing it's laser as "WaveFront" and required them to tack on a modifier: "WaveFront-OPTIMIZED" this is like USDA requiring the makers of Velvetta to call their product "cheese-FOOD" or makers of soy "milk" to label their product "contains no dairy product"
the Allegretto platform takes a true WaveFront scan, but then does this weird thing where it then matches your scan against it's internal database of a few hundred profiles, and then chooses the "best fit" sphere. so your treatment is optimized, but not truly custom. in other words, for every laser treatment done on the Allegretto, there is someone out there, somewhere in the world, getting an IDENTICAL treatment. the market share of the Allegretto laser in the US, btw, is about 5%
my preferred laser platform is the VISX, because unlike the above laser brands, it DOES perform a true custom WaveFront correction. it takes a unique wavescan of your eyes, each of which is like a fingerprint of your prescription, so that no other person ON THE PLANET has the same scan. then that scan is saved in the computer, and transferred with a flashdrive into the VISX laser. it is a true custom system
VISX is by far the dominant laser in the US, with about 75% market share. this means there have been more eyes lasered on the VISX platform than all other laser brands--COMBINED
you can get excellent results on either a Nidek or Allegretto laser. just be clear that neither are true custom wavefront platforms. if i were getting my own eyes lasered (i was the 1st LASIK surgeon in NYC to get LASIK himself, and i did it on a VISX), then i would choose the Allegretto over the Nidek, if i were being lasered in the US. outside of the US, i might choose the Nidek, especially if i were in Japan where they have the newest version w the upgraded hardware and software
don't worry, you can and probably will have excellent results, no matter what platform you choose, they are all good, just some are true custom, some are non-custom, and some are pseudo-custom
Wavelight Allegretto vs Nidek for LASIK
The overall number of patients that a surgeon has treated is not always a good measure of a doctor's skill level. There are surgeons who have treated more than 30,000 eyes who have a reputation in the LASIK industry as poor surgeons. LASIK eye surgery is a very successful surgery with high rates of success so even the worst surgeons generally have good results and have many happy patients (although they have more unhappy patients than the best surgeons). Finding a surgeon with experience is important but you should also find a surgeon with a reputation as an excellent surgeon. The VISX and the Wavelight Allegretto are currently the more popular excimer laser systems in the USA among LASIK surgeons. The Nidek has become less popular at this point. There are still LASIK surgeons who believe the Nidek laser to be a good LASIK system but the majority of LASIK surgeons have chosen to go with other lasers at this point in time for many reasons. Many LASIK surgeons feel that they can use several different systems well and prefer different systems depending on the needs of their individual patients. Picking a surgeon is not easy. Good luck.
These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.