Member since 3/11/2013


  • 46 total posts
  • 2 reviews
  • 2 discussions
  • 1 question

Reviews & Stories

Seeking Feedback - Tobias for Revision Rhinoplasty - New York, NY

I need a rhino revision (severe assymetric nostrils). My primary was done about 20 yrs ago and it was bad back then and only got worse over the years. i had a consult with dr tobias and next week with dr guida. Any personal feedback (negative or positive) is much appreciated. Thank you. Thx thx thx Why are all the rhino drs on this site with 5 stars? Only happy/satisfied patients post? Is... READ MORE

Terrible Rhino Outcome!!! - New York, NY

Dr Joe McCarthy did my primary 25 years ago (I'm 46 yrs old now.) Was supposed to be a simple procedure of shaving down my bone b/c my only problem was a Greek hump, not severe, but it bothered me. He did shave it down (not scooped, did an ok job) BUT left me with severely uneven/asymmetric nostrils. He apologized, said that there's nothing he could do & sent me to Dr Nicholas Tabbal in... READ MORE

Questions from Desperatetobreathe

Why Do So Many Tips Develop Pointy, Small-ish, Hardened Balls After Rhinoplasty?

Is this due to poor technique and an over abundance of mediocre plastic surgeons? Is it the normal outcome of grafting? Thank you. READ MORE

Discussions started by Desperatetobreathe

Seeking feedback - dr tobias NY/NJ

Hi, seeking personal feedback on your experience with dr tobias I need a revision desperately, and am strongly considering dr tobias. I have asymmetric nostrils and bid tip... READ MORE

Recent comments from Desperatetobreathe

Oh, and what did Frankel tell you? We liked him and his morph. READ COMMENT

Would love to hear your feedback on Kim & Rosenberg. Thanks! READ COMMENT

Yes I met w/Davis but discounted him bc he wants to use rib and I'm not in favor of that. Otherwise, he's really top notch READ COMMENT

Don't know why they removed my comment, but I replied below READ COMMENT

We met w/Frankel & Davis READ COMMENT