Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

31 Yr. Old Lactating Mom, Removing 11 Yr. Old 315cc Saline Sub-muscular Implants

UPDATED FROM surfergirl2016
4 years post

4 year update

surfergirl2016
WORTH IT$2,701
Another year later and I feel the same as I did a year ago. I am not happy with my current appearance and deformed. I have extreme asymmetry and saggy empty breasts. My nipples sink inward and my flex deformity is the same.
I constantly try hide my breasts and I hate for them to be touched. It’s embarrassing.
I am at the point I am having a little regrets about removing my implants now, because I didn’t have any issues like BII or contractures…they looked fine and were much better than what I have now.
Now, if I want to fix them I have to have another surgery and pay thousands of dollars… I’m so sad about that. I’m a mother and don’t want to do the risks or recovery of another procedure and I feel selfish to spend that money on myself.
I definitely think i will do something though…
I’ve recieved many comments about fat transfer and I am researching that
I am not getting a lift. I have zero tissue and do not want to be flat with large scars.
So I will either do a fat transfer or implants again.
I’m going to continue to research these options before I decide.
I’d love to hear experiences of women who’ve had an explant and then got implants again or had a fat transfer after explant.
Best wishes to everyone. Hope this honest review helps someone and I’ll answer questions when i can. Good luck to anyone with making a decision. It’s hard. Such is life!

surfergirl2016's provider

Jeffrey S. Church, MD, DDS

Jeffrey S. Church, MD, DDS

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

surfergirl2016 rating for Dr. Church:

Overall rating

Replies (5)

July 7, 2021
Hi surfergirl. I am in exactly the same situation as you. I had my implants removed 4 years ago and I really don’t like how my breasts look. I have basically no tissue and my nipples also sink in. I never want my husband to see them. I definitely regret having gotten my implants removed at times because the symptoms that I thought might have been BII were actually related to my thyroid instead. I do like being natural but I’m just so unhappy with how I look. I thought that I would eventually be at peace with my decision and with how my breasts look but I haven’t gotten there yet. There are times when I think I want to get implants again but I don’t want to spend the money on them or go through surgery. Sometimes I feel so shallow being so worried with how my breasts look but I just can’t seem to get to the point of being happy with them. Good luck with trying to figure out what you want to do. It’s definitely not easy but at least you know you’re not alone.
July 7, 2021
Wow, that is exactly how I feel too. I’m 35 and i just don’t think I can go on without doing something. It’s tough….I also don’t want to spend money or do surgery but I just can’t stay like this. I feel deformed. Thank you for sharing your story. It’s nice to know I’m not the only one feeling like this or going through this.
July 7, 2021
I had an explant, it’s been 4 weeks now and the asymmetry is slowly starting to even out? My nipples sink inwards and so saggy , I know exactly how you feel.My surgeon will look at me at the 3 month post opp to discuss fat transfer, no lift I feel the same as you! I cannot go for implants again as I has extreme inflammation in my body. I’m hoping I have enough fat too?
July 7, 2021
I’m sorry you’re not happy with your results. I understand about not getting implants again. I have seen reviews for fat transfers with women with little body fat, so you may still be a good candidate. I wish you the best of luck! If you do get a BFT let me know your results.
User Avatar
September 3, 2021
Hi hope you don't mind me asking. Could you explain your inflammation where it was & how it felt. I myself have been back any times to my PS & he dismisses it. I even paid for a consultation with another PS about it & he dismissed it to. I'm so confused
September 3, 2021
Hi regarding inflammation,my ANA was around 1280, my symptoms was stiffness in my hands and sore nuckles also sore hips in the joints and very tired, Doctors dismissed all relation to implants but my surgeon who put them in agreed with me, best thing I did was remove also puffy eyes was a symptom too? All disappeared now and my asymmetry is even,just small now but I like feeling not so heavy and so soft :) good luck
User Avatar
September 5, 2021
rachellegurr thank you for you reply What does ANA stand for?
September 5, 2021
Antinuclear Antibodies found in a blood test, if this is high it means you have inflammation in your body,when my implants were taken out the tissue around the implant was sent to pathology, full of immune cells rejecting, surgeon said it was the right choice, my body just didn’t like the implants?
July 11, 2021
I will be getting mine out again soon I am just over the implants I have a lot of back pain. Did you ask you doc about scar revision? Anything is better then getting implants again and the scars for a lift are not that bad and can heal nicely. My doc is against fat transfer because of inaccurate mammograms .
Fat noduls and lumps..I am going to wait a year and if I am not happy then I will go ahead and get a lift. Do you mind sharing pics? And where was your incision?
July 11, 2021
Good luck with you on your explant! I hope you have great results. :)
I am never getting a lift. I don’t want to pay thousands to be flat as a board. Like I said, I have no tissue to lift.
I’ve read the same thing about fat lumps and issues reading mammograms with fat transfer, and that makes me hesitant on that procedure.
As far as pics, I don’t have any right now but I haven’t shared pics for a few reasons. Mostly because since my ex plant I’ve have two pregnancies and have been breastfeeding much of that time. I am still BF my last baby and hanging on to some weight. So, I don’t want to post pics because my breasts are fuller than normal. I’d hate someone to see the pics bad think that’s the results I’ve had from explant.
I’m also not sure how comfortable I am posting pics.
July 11, 2021
Oh and my incision is under my breast because I had saline under muscle implants. My scars are about an inch long.
July 13, 2021
Hi, I’m sorry to read that . I explanted back on 2019 because of everything I was seeing and reading about BII, I never had any issue with my implants (had them for 10 years)my explants results were exactly the same (my boobs looked as raisins), however I did a fat transfer on 2020 and unfortunately was a waste of money because the little fat I got just disappeared:( and I didn’t choose to have a lift because I would ended completely flat. I was so unhappy cause I couldn’t wear anything I like, so I decided to have implants again and I can tell you that so far I’m happy with the results I’m almost 2 months post op.
July 14, 2021
Hi, thank you for sharing your experience! I’m sorry your BF transfer wasn’t worth it. I have heard about the fat not staying, which is a waste of money! It’s good to hear you’re happy so har with your new implants. Did you get the same kind or size? I also was concerned with BII when I explanted, but I have to look at risks vs reward and it seems the odds are low for BII. I’ve read some even scarier reviews on BF transfer and I think implants are looking more and more like they way I’m going to go in the future. You should write a review! :)
July 14, 2021
I got the same kind (silicone) different brand (sientra) which is really good (did a very thorough research) I used to have Mentor which are good as well never had an issue with them. The size is less than before 305cc (before explant 375cc)because the damage I had on my tissue for the explant surgery and the fat transfer the dr couldn’t go any bigger.
July 15, 2021
Gosh sorry to hear you have damage! I think my explant went well, so hopefully if I get implants again it would be easy. I am not sure if I I should get same (mentor, saline, under muscle) or silicone, over, etc…honestly, with my augmentation I didn’t even get a choice. My doctor just said he would do saline unders…so I have no idea. I’ve read on this site that silicone you have to MRIs every two years! I can’t afford that…but I know they feel better than saline and have less rippling. My tissue is so thin so rippling is a concern of mine. Thanks for sharing your info with me! It has been helpful.
August 30, 2021
I’ve had silicone unders for 5 years and I’ve never had an MRI. Mammograms hurt like heck though with these implants because they have to do extra pulling to move them out of the way and try to get the best pictures of your natural tissue. It’s rough and a big reason I’m getting these removed in 4 weeks. I’m 37 and have had 2 mammograms so far in my life because of my mom’s past history with breast cancer. Knowing how painful they are with implants, I don’t want to do this every year. I just wish I had never got them in the first place! Also I had a huge ripple or concave area over my right implant and 3 years ago the surgeon suggested we put a fat graft on it to fill it in. Well…. I ended up with fat necrosis and hard nodules in that same area that I just had to get biopsied since it was a palpable lump. I couldn’t take a chance and because of my kids, I had the core needle biopsy even though I was almost certain it was from the fat transfer. Sure enough it was, but now I have the peace of mind that it’s benign. Ugh. It’s been a crazy journey and again- I wish I had never augmented my breasts. Live and learn. I hope they bounce back but I’m expecting them to be very small again with some sagging. The unknown is scary. But I wouldn’t do a fat transfer ever again because of the fat necrosis and lump I had. Not worth it! I am very thin to begin with so taking fat from my abdomen wasn’t fun and left permanent dimples where they harvested fat. Good luck to you. It’s such a journey we are on!
August 30, 2021
Wow! What a journey you have been on. I really can relate to the feeling of wishing you’d never augmented yourself. I truly wish I would have never gotten implants when I was 20. I have lived with my results of the explant for over four years now. It is hard. I feel deformed and that’s hard to except at age 35.
I hope you feel better after your removal. There’s just no way to know what to expect and it is scary, but lots of women have good results!
The things you mentioned about fat transfer are the reasons I am now pretty sure I do not want to do it. I’ve seen terrible reviews about fat necrosis! And the lumps! And I would be so paranoid if I wasn’t sure if the lumps were fat or tumors.
I am so sorry you’ve had issues with both your implants and FT.
My implants never gave me issues, I just wanted to be soft and natural again. I do have muscle flex deformity which is more obvious now than ever. Sunken nipples. Scars and just a deflated balloon look to my breasts. Also asymmetry (from breastfeeding, but one breast had nerve damage from augmentation and doesn’t let down milk).
I’ve tried so hard to be content with my body and not do any more procedures. It’s just so depressing to look like this and feel these things.
I hope you write a review or come back and let me know how your removal goes and how you’re doing! Good luck!!
August 30, 2021
Aw thank you so much. You are very sweet and we have similar views… as all of this in an unknown to me, I may be miserable too without the implants. It’s scary for sure. I don’t want to feel deformed, but I have no way of knowing how my results will end up. Ugh. I started with an A and now I’m a D… they are so soft and look good, clothes fit so nicely over them. My doctor even said at my consultation for explant how natural they look…. So yeah I’ve had moments of pause and hoping I’m doing the right thing. It’s tough. The mammogram thing really messed me up and made me feel remorseful for ever getting these implants. I just want to be my self again and work out again since it’s near impossible with these implants pulling on my muscles. And I hate wearing a bra 24/7. I used to go braless when I was an A and it was wonderful to be free! Now it’s way too uncomfortable to go without a bra for 5 years now. I did 4 years of breastfeeding before my implants so there was a lot of wear and tear on them as you know. We go thru so much as moms… I am trying to be kinder to myself and practice self love. It’s not always easy. I wish society was easier on women and the media wasn’t so cruel to us in regards to our bodies. I wish I just stayed natural and never messed with my breasts. We have to forgive ourselves though because we just did the best we could at the time. Sending hugs to you. <3
UPDATED FROM surfergirl2016
3 years post

3 year update

surfergirl2016
It’s been a long time! Since my ex plant three years ago I have had another pregnancy and breastfed that baby. It was wonderful to go through that without implants. I didn’t have that engorged feeling or discomfort. Unfortunately, I had same issue with right breast not letting down milk even tho it makes milk, which results in baby preferring left side and my right going smaller as milk supply decreases.
Through research I think I have some nerve damage from my original breast augmentation which affects let down of my milk. My breasts are currently still very uneven in size.
Here’s how I’m feeling:
I don’t regret removing my implants
I DO regret getting them in the first place.
I’ve had a hard time accepting that I chose to ruin my muscles, have scars, muscle flex deformity and stretched saggy boobs by getting implants when I was 20. I wish I’d have stayed all natural!
Removing my implants has felt great. I love soft natural boobs. However, I am unhappy with the look of my breasts. I’m fine with small and saggy but I hate my scars...I hate my flex deformity....I hate my Areolas and nipples sink inward (because they’re so stretched out and have zero tissue beneath to support them). They don’t look or feel like breasts should look and feel. They feel empty/hollow skin. My husbands has more firm/dense feeling breast lol.
Seriously I have zero tissue and I don’t gain weight in my boobs at all. I cannot get a lift or anything because of lack of tissue.
So my only options are:
1) accept this body and live with it, try to love it and move on (I’ve been trying to do this option)
2) get implants again

I do not want to get implants again. But I have thought about it a few times. It just feels like the solution to my problems cannot but the same as what caused my problems (getting implants). So I don’t think I can go through with ever getting implants again.

I still encourage anyone looking to explant to go ahead and do it. More than likely you will look and feel great! Especially if your natural breasts are at least a full A cup. I only have issues because I really am so flat naturally. I’d be over the moon if I had even a little tissue to fluff out my nipple and look “normal”. Anyway, I will try to check in and answer any questions or comments as honestly as possible.

Best of luck to anyone on this journey! It isn’t easy!

Replies (5)

July 14, 2020
Thank you for updating! Have you considered a fat transfer? I had this empty feeling after my explant too... But please, don’t consider implants they only cause new problems. Maybe not immediately but they definitely will...
July 15, 2020
My reply did not show up for some reason...I have considered fat transfer but it is expensive and I’m unsure of the results. I’ve read they can be temporary and I don’t have much fat to begin with. I may do it in the future. How was your experience with it? Thanks for the comment.
July 17, 2020
At first I thought too that it is expensive but my result is very natural and I had no pain at all. Now I think to feel good in your body is priceless and I can think of no way I could have spent that money better. When I look at my breasts now or touch them, it makes me smile... It's hard to determine how much of what I "lost" after the fat transfer was fat or swelling but Dr. Bednar who transferred 505cc per breast told me my retention is very good and my guess is that 80% stayed. Since after the first three months post surgery I haven't lost volume.
July 17, 2020
Thank you for sharing your experience! It sounds like you’ve had wonderful results. It the results really last, then I think it would be worth the money. I’m glad you are happy with them! :)
July 18, 2020
Thank you! Dr. Bednar told me what you have 3 months post procedure stays - if you keep your weight stable. Now I’m 15 months post op... All the best!
July 18, 2020
That’s good to know! You look great!
July 19, 2020
Thank you so much! The best is how it feels: I really hated the feeling of having implants... xo
July 27, 2020
Yes I hated how my implants felt as well! That is awesome the fat transfer feels much better!!
July 15, 2020
Dear surfergirl2016, thank you so much for your post. My story is very similar to yours, i had a baby 1 year ago and i am removing my implants 250cc after 5 years of having them. Hope to breastfeed my second baby with no implants. My surgery is on comming monday. I m so scared, because i also had very smal A Cup and i am not sure how i will Controller my emotions the first weeks after the surgery. My surgeon told me that after the second pregnancy he can try to tighten and make smaller my areola with a laser and withought scars. Maybe u can ask if this procedure is also good for you. I live in munich, germany. I my niples are too stretched as well but still hope for the best. Did you notice some tightening of the skin in the first year? Thank you so much again!
July 15, 2020
Thank you for the comment. I have not heard of this laser procedure for nipples. I will look into because it sounds like what I need. The skin shrank and tightened way better than I expected! My breasts are similar in size and shape of before implants. I am mostly unhappy with my nipples. I had implants 11 years! And they were a little bigger than yours (315cc). It took so long for me to get courage to remove them. Five years is not very long so you may have an even better outcome. I hope you can relax and don’t be nervous. I wish you the best! I honestly enjoy being implant free so much more.
July 15, 2020
Omg, i am so grateful for you and for all this society. Thank u so much for answering so fast. My heart was beating so fast and as i read your post, i immediately calmed down. If you cannot find Information about this procedure, you can call my doc in germany and get more information and maybe he can Tell u who is doing such a procedure in USA. He speaks english as well. Dr. Patrick Bauer in Munich, u can Google it. I plan to have this laser procedure done after an year and a Half (hopefully had my second baby untill then) and can let you know how it went. Thank you sooooo much for your support again and all the best to you!!! U are looking great by the way! I will do my best to keep calm and trust in the universe. I m also so sorry to have gotten implants, but well, we learn from our mistakes;)
July 15, 2020
So glad my comment helped you! I was so nervous to remove them but if you don’t like them you will love being free of them. It is hard to live with the past decision of getting them in the first place. I struggle with that. Live and learn! Good luck. Oh and thank you for the compliment. :)
July 15, 2020
Look up Dr Burns and Dr Bednar for fat transfer in the US. They are the two best with highest fat retention rates. Check Facebook for support pages for them too!
July 15, 2020
Thank you so much for the information!
July 15, 2020
Dr. Matthew Stanwix, Richmond, Virginia, did an awesome lift and fat transfer on me (no previous augmentation of any type) in 2018. My results are stellar. This may be one alternative you could consider. I am thrilled with Dr. Stanwix's work!
UPDATED FROM surfergirl2016
27 days post

One month update

surfergirl2016
Almost one month already! I just wanted to update: I feel great! However I haven't noticed any changes in appearance. My breasts do feel firmer and like the tissue has settled.
I'm just enjoying daily life better without the implants. Sleeping, breastfeeding, exercising, are all more comfortable. I feel lighter and it's great.
The only thing that bums me sometimes is the size difference of my breasts. It's hard to hide and hard to find bras. But it is ok!
No regrets!! If you want to explant, just do it! [RS bleep]

Replies (5)

August 17, 2017
I am so greatful you have shared your experience
! I have wanted to do this for so long but wasn't sure where to begin finding a doctor in ILM. I will be scheduling with Dr. Church in the morning.
September 6, 2017
Oh I'm so glad my review was helpful to you! Dr Church was great. Best wishes!
September 6, 2017
I'm so happy you're recovering well and enjoying your natural self! At my consultations the PS said my asymmetry would still be present after removal due to my left being the larger milk producer. Hopefully yours will be closer to the same size when your finished breastfeeding.
October 3, 2017
Yes, I’m sure my left will shrink. I doubt it will go all the way back to that small. It’s fine. Gonna have more babies anyway! :)
September 30, 2017
Hi, I would like to ask you if you had the muscle reattached in order to get rid of the flex deformity. And also if you were able to gain back strength and free moving without strange sensation inside. I am considering explant in mainly because of this disturb when I move and I would like to know if It can help getting rid of it. Thank you for your advice and good healing! I think you look great and better than with the implants.
October 3, 2017
No I didn’t have any muscle work done. I have full movement and strength, no weird feelings. I feel like my old self! It was such a relief of pressure to remove the implants. I used to have discomfort working out or doing chest movements, now I don’t! I do still have flex deformity and I think that can never be fixed. I regret getting implants mostly because of the flex issue and scares...all permanent damage.:(
January 19, 2018
I had mine removed too and I am so happy I did. I feel so much lighter and healthier. Thanks for the review. I may use him for a different procedure.
November 6, 2018
Hi there, I'm curious if you're still happy with your choice to explant? I am scheduled for my explant surgery on 12/7 in Wilmington. Same office you went to, different doctor. I'm nervous but excited at the same time.