Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

Bad nose job West Orange, NJ

ORIGINAL POST

I was always self conscious about my nose. I'm not...

Jacqueline71891
$7,400

I was always self conscious about my nose. I'm not so huge on my appearance but I also didn't like my nose being a distraction to my face. I wanted to get my nose done and just have a "normal" nose. I researched many doctors, all qualified and with an impressive resume; I consulted with 2 in NYC , 1 in Long Island, but I wasn't sure so I went to Dr. joseph and I felt really comfortable with him and I trusted him., so I booked my surgery with him. However, I am 2 months post op and I am very displeased with my results. My nostrils show too much, my nose got shortened a lot ( I didn't want that). My nose is CROOKED- I recently consulted another Dr. In NYC and was told that my Doctor failed to break my bone correctly and I should wait till I am 8 months post op so he can take a Better look because I'm still swollen. I also told Dr. joseph that I had a ball hanging from my upper lip and he told me it was my collumelar strut loose, so he "fixed it" nevertheless, I still feel this shift as I talk or move my mouth. I really like the doctor and his personality but I am not sure what went wrong In that operating room. I used to ask him so many questions before and he would be so responsive but now I'm just over it and will continue my follow ups and make sure there is no sign of infection and see what else or excuses I will be told. There are a few more things I dislike but at this point it doesn't matter. I didn't expect a perfect nose but seriously, too have all these things /errors at once is just ridiculous.

Jacqueline71891's provider

Eric M. Joseph, MD

Eric M. Joseph, MD

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

4.9 | 627 Reviews
PROFILE

Jacqueline71891 rating for Dr. Joseph:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (36)

August 2, 2015
do not worry! its just for couple of months and hopfully the new DR is able to fix it !
August 3, 2015
I consulted with this doctor and was not impressed by his personality at all. i was very surprised as that was one of the reasons i chose to see him. not to mention the only thing he wanted to do with my nose is inject it with silicon. no thanks!
October 18, 2016
I too met with him and was soooooo not impressed with his personality. Also, I have tried to post an honest, yet not-so-positive review about Eric a few times and it has not let me, nor has anyone on real self emailed me back about why, so I'm wondering what the deal is...
User Avatar
August 3, 2015
Hi There, so sorry for you that this Dr has clearly not helped you with surgery.
In the photos your nose looks crooked.
I hope you get the help you need.
Good luck!!
August 5, 2015
Thanks:)
August 3, 2015
I am so sorry, your nose looks crooked like mine. Unfortunately that will not change unless you have other procedure done. Dr Joseph is so famous and have so many reviews. Thank you for sharing, I will definitely don't consider him for my revision
August 8, 2015
August 8, 2015
Hi, Joanne Milia- from Dr. Joseph's Staff.
User Avatar
August 3, 2015
I am precluded from responding to specifics because of HIPAA and state privacy laws. But, I can speak broadly.

We want all patients to have a positive experience with our practice. While the vast majority of our patients are satisfied with their outcome, on occasion, a patient will not be happy with their result. In such circumstances, our policy is to offer a revision procedure, where our professional fee is waived. This affords us the chance to go the extra mile for our patients.

Also, rhinoplasty patients are counseled (no pun intended) on patience. The healing process takes up to twelve months, or longer in those with thick skin. That means at least a year will go by before one knows with comfort what a patient’s final result will look like. The healing process after rhinoplasty surgery is never complete after short time frames – such as one to three months-, and one’s nasal appearance will change as the swelling slowly resolves.
August 13, 2015
August 13, 2015
Not your best work Dr. Joseph
August 15, 2015
You should fix her nose back to normal and give her a refund. This is shameful.
September 27, 2015
I'm shocked, I thought this was a never heard of surgeon who did this not a well regarded one. And for it to look like this after a primary ? Which should be the easiest to do and best chance of success. I agree with the OP that the issues she listed are not ones that will resolve over time. Perhaps if surgeons spent more time in consults and the OR and didn't rush through surgeries this would not happen. They don't realize they are destroying lives when they do this, would you have spent more time and done a better job if it was your own daughter? . I really hope you can spend all your efforts into making this right.
September 27, 2015
Oh and please own up to your mistake and give her her money back so she can go get this fixed. It's really the least you can do and thank you Jacqueline for being brave and sharing your story you are helping so many people
September 27, 2015
Please refund her money. Now she also has to deal with SILIKON 1000. I am not sure who is going to want to operate.
September 27, 2015
October 1, 2015
I don't understand how an experienced surgeon and a revisionist like yourself could give such amateur results? You can clearly see that the cartilages domes are sewn too closely together and the osteotomies are uneven. You gave her a nosejob that looks like it was done in the 1980s.
UPDATED FROM Jacqueline71891
4 months post

4 months later

Jacqueline71891
I can't believe it's been 4 months. I have nothing to say but I have pictures posted; 1 picture is worth 1000 words.

Replies (42)

User Avatar
September 26, 2015
September 26, 2015
Could you please post the letter that you sent to me offering me a reimbursement, however I never received no reimbursement by you. And tell the community how your wife Diana Joseph the office manager calling me to remove my post from realself. Thanks.
User Avatar
September 26, 2015
September 26, 2015
Of course. Also, you don't intimidate me. After the consult we had and I expressed my dissatisfaction you acted like nothing was wrong. Your practice is absolutely unethical. Your wife called me telling me to remove my post and told me do you want to hurt dr. Joseph's reputation and etc. I go to see you afterwards to express how dissatisfied I am, you tell me nothing is wrong with my nose then you repeatedly tell me remove mypost from realself and use the fact that my parents are pastors and you tell me aren't you religious. Sorry it doesn't work that way. Plus there is a Huge conflict of interest when you say we all saw you and you were fine. Are you referring to your wife who was in the room and kept saying I believe you have a good result? She's your wife why would she contradict you ? Also why would anyone employed by you disagree with you? You employ them! I advise you to at least keep your word with my reimbursement. If you decide to continue to lie that's fine. Goodbye
September 27, 2015
I am glad you stood up for yourself. I appreciate your posts and wish you the best.
September 27, 2015
What did he say that was against the rules ?
September 28, 2015
Wow, I feel you are being very unfair with this doctor. He is noted as one of the best in the field. There are a number of factors that could have contributed to your result that might be beyond his control. Please let your nose heal as he mentioned and go back to him for a revision as he has offered. Nobody is perfect including you and he is trying to help you rectify your issues. This is clearly unfair to him. I don't even know this doctor personally, however these attacks on him are ridiculous.
September 29, 2015
October 1, 2015
BS. The guy should own up to his mistakes. I was also the victim of co-workers lying in agreement with their lying boss doctor. It's sick and shameful there is so much lack of care and empathy for patients. They'll lie to your face to save theirs. No responsibility. No ethics. Good for you Jacqueline for speaking up. Don't take their bullying. Enough's enough of this sociopathy.
User Avatar
November 2, 2016
when you spend an enormous amount of money for a SKILLED DOCTOR to do your face you have very RIGHT to expect a good result!
April 17, 2018
I was going to go to him for my revision and now I don't think I will... especially after seeing how he tried to get you to remove the review. It reminds me of the poor experience I had with a doctor here in FL. Except he threatened to sue me. Hope you find someone to fix your nose for you! Best of luck
April 17, 2018
Aelef, smart move. His dialogue on here is highly inappropriate from an adult let alone a “professional”. His use and self promotion of silicone is disturbing and dangerous to say the least. I also as a Christian I find it disturbing to hear another human use God as sales tactic. It goes against what I believe and it makes me question a person’s integrity in their faith. Many of his answers to questions also don’t line up with what the rest of the medical community is practicing/advising. I’ve never consulted or been a patient of this Joseph’s because of this.
September 26, 2015
Did you had any type of alarplasty? like alarbase reduction?
September 26, 2015
Hi sofia10. I messaged you my response.
User Avatar
September 27, 2015
I want you to contact Dr Bustillo in Miami, he does Skype consultations. Look at his website, you'll need to send pics.
September 27, 2015
Hi. I sent you a private message with some questions.
User Avatar
September 27, 2015
Look at the revision part of this webpage.
September 28, 2015
Well done for standing up to him. Its really interesting how he is more concerned about his reputation than his patient. I hope you get some compensation.
October 18, 2016
Totally!!!