1 rhinoplasty & 1 revision - was hoping for a more round & smooth tip

These photos are recent. 1 Rhinoplasty surgery & 1 Revision surgery. Curious if outsider opinions.

I’m looking for opinions based on my photos that I have submitted. In my opinion it’s very choppy work. The one side looks good and natural and the other I’m not sure what they were What are your thoughts?

I had 1 rhinoplasty surgery and 1 revision surgery done. Side profiles are good. The tip throws me off a bit. One side looks a bit more natural than the other. What are your thoughts. I had two doctors that were quick in their evaluation process. Was hoping for a more round and smooth tip. First doc gave me a square tip that was off centered. Second doc tried to balance it out but was unsuccessful in my opinion. Still looks like an unfinished product. Curious for outsider opinions. Thanks.