POSTED UNDER Revision Rhinoplasty Reviews
Horrible experience with Manish Shah
ORIGINAL POST
Horrible experience with Manish Shah
$7,800
I am only giving one star because there's no other option, but if I could, I would give him a 0. I had a revision rhinoplasty done by Shah Manish in April 2019. All I wanted was to breathe better and have a better projection because my nose tip was significantly dropped. I regret so much having had surgery with this doctor as he did a horrible job. Not only did he make my nose worse than it was, but he destroyed my nose. My nose looked ugly. He could not fix my tip; my breathing problem worsens. One year later July 2020, I went back to his office and said he would fix it by doing another office procedure, I trusted him again, and he just made it worse. He left a bump on my nose that was not there.
I absolutely hated my nose, had no confidence, had depression for a while, and could no longer pursue my modeling career because of the results. I kept going back to his office to express how I felt about it, and he never listened to me or let me talk. All he said was that my nose was very swollen and that it would get better eventually, which never did. I spent two years dealing with this awful doctor, and nothing changed. He just wasted my time and money. I spent 8k on the first procedure and $300 on the second one. PLEASE AVOID THIS DOCTOR AT ALL COSTS. HE ONLY CARES ABOUT MONEY AND DOESNT HAVE THE KNOWLEDGE OF WORKING WITH A VARIETY OF NOSES. I HONESTLY DONT KNOW HOW HE HAS HIS BUSINESS RUNNING AND HAS A DEGREE OF IT. HIS WORK IS HORRENDOUS. I WISH HE COULD HAVE BEEN HONEST WITH ME INSTEAD OF DESTROYING MY NOSE AND CONFIDENCE.
I recently got back from Mexico, where I had to find another doctor (a professional one). She recorded the surgery and showed me all the issues he did with my nose, which I was utterly shocked. However, she fixed my nose and breathing problems. Currently, my nose looks completely different and beautiful. I am so in love with my results. She exceeded my expectations even though it has only been a few weeks.
I absolutely hated my nose, had no confidence, had depression for a while, and could no longer pursue my modeling career because of the results. I kept going back to his office to express how I felt about it, and he never listened to me or let me talk. All he said was that my nose was very swollen and that it would get better eventually, which never did. I spent two years dealing with this awful doctor, and nothing changed. He just wasted my time and money. I spent 8k on the first procedure and $300 on the second one. PLEASE AVOID THIS DOCTOR AT ALL COSTS. HE ONLY CARES ABOUT MONEY AND DOESNT HAVE THE KNOWLEDGE OF WORKING WITH A VARIETY OF NOSES. I HONESTLY DONT KNOW HOW HE HAS HIS BUSINESS RUNNING AND HAS A DEGREE OF IT. HIS WORK IS HORRENDOUS. I WISH HE COULD HAVE BEEN HONEST WITH ME INSTEAD OF DESTROYING MY NOSE AND CONFIDENCE.
I recently got back from Mexico, where I had to find another doctor (a professional one). She recorded the surgery and showed me all the issues he did with my nose, which I was utterly shocked. However, she fixed my nose and breathing problems. Currently, my nose looks completely different and beautiful. I am so in love with my results. She exceeded my expectations even though it has only been a few weeks.
Replies (4)
Yes, I completely agree that I came to you from a previous rhinoplasty but the deformation you did on my nose was not even close to the issues I had before. You agreed to operate my nose and made it worse. So sad for your malpractice and negligence. You just don't have enough experience and knowledge!
hi- do you mind giving me the name of the doctor who fixed your nose? id really appreciate it :)
Hey could you send me the dr that fixed your nose please?


Thank you for your comments.
I wish you would have let us know that you felt this way.
Don't forget that someone else had damaged your nose and that is why you came to me to attempt to fix it.
Unfortunately, revision surgery carries no guarantees of success because scarring and poor blood supply can limit the extent of improvement. This was explained to you at your consultation. I have a great warranty for the less than 7% of my rhinoplasty patients that request touch-up surgery after their first rhinoplasty (National Average revision rate is 30-50%). I perform many corrective or revision rhinoplasty procedures with very good outcomes each year. However, no revision rhinoplasty specialist is 100% successful. I am glad that you found a surgeon who was able to meet your needs and that you've been able to find a little peace :)
Sincerely,
Dr. Shah