POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty Reviews
Total Disappointment with Denenberg. Omaha, NE
UPDATED FROM meadowflower
15 years post
Before and after
$7,500
Photo on the left shows how my nose looked horrible after the primary rhinoplasty performed by Denenberg.
ORIGINAL POST
I had my primary rhinoplasty with Dr. Denenberg in...
I had my primary rhinoplasty with Dr. Denenberg in 2001. I chose him after I did a lot of research and after interviewing many surgeons in my area. What attracted me to do my surgery with him –though he was out of my state- was the after photos posted on his website. I saw many noses that looked like my nose with amazing results. I had a hump and my nose was a bit long for my face. So I asked him to shave the hump, a bit shortening of the nose and refinement of the tip. After exchanging a number of emails with him I booked an in person consult and a surgery date. I had the consult and then on the following day I had the surgery. It was an open rhino and recovery went well. The cast came off few days later and I was in total shock! The hump was gone and the profile looked fine but the base of my nose was so wide that I didn’t look like myself. He told me it was still very swollen and it would look better in few months. In fact before the cast came off I noticed that my nose was double its previous width. Unfortunately my nose healed but it continued to look wide. Actually aside from the improved profile that only lasted for few years everything else about my nose looked horrible and opposite to what I asked for. Oh another thing I should mention is that Dr. Denenberg is greedy. I can’t believe I paid over 7k in 2001 for a primary rhino in Omaha!
I was in touch with him during recovery and the first few months post-surgery; he agreed that my nose looked wider than what it used to be. At one point Dr. Denenberg even remarked that my nose looked funny!! I suffered emotional and psychological ramifications because Dr. D didn’t deliver the results I paid for. He offered to revise it; but honestly I didn’t feel comfortable to go back to him since he messed up my nose the first time. In the past few years before my revision my nose kept changing to the worst. The bridge became crooked, the tip very asymmetrical, nostrils uneven, and on top I had difficulty breathing. Because of all these changes in my nose my face started to look different and I first noticed this in photos. It took me nearly 12 years to finally have the revision. Please see my review here http://www.realself.com/review/baltimore-md-revision-rhinoplasty-finally-revision-for-in-march
Last March I had the courage to have a revision and I’m happy I did. It was a very hard decision to make. Breathing has improved greatly since. My revision surgeon said that when my nose was shortened during the primary the tip was left without cartilage and my nose collapsed. The nose was also crooked inside and that seemed to have contributed to breathing issues I had.
My advice to anyone seeking cosmetic surgery: Don’t base your decision in selecting a surgeon on merely their after results. It can be really deceptive. Thanks for reading.
I was in touch with him during recovery and the first few months post-surgery; he agreed that my nose looked wider than what it used to be. At one point Dr. Denenberg even remarked that my nose looked funny!! I suffered emotional and psychological ramifications because Dr. D didn’t deliver the results I paid for. He offered to revise it; but honestly I didn’t feel comfortable to go back to him since he messed up my nose the first time. In the past few years before my revision my nose kept changing to the worst. The bridge became crooked, the tip very asymmetrical, nostrils uneven, and on top I had difficulty breathing. Because of all these changes in my nose my face started to look different and I first noticed this in photos. It took me nearly 12 years to finally have the revision. Please see my review here http://www.realself.com/review/baltimore-md-revision-rhinoplasty-finally-revision-for-in-march
Last March I had the courage to have a revision and I’m happy I did. It was a very hard decision to make. Breathing has improved greatly since. My revision surgeon said that when my nose was shortened during the primary the tip was left without cartilage and my nose collapsed. The nose was also crooked inside and that seemed to have contributed to breathing issues I had.
My advice to anyone seeking cosmetic surgery: Don’t base your decision in selecting a surgeon on merely their after results. It can be really deceptive. Thanks for reading.
Replies (5)

A
September 20, 2014
Thank you for sharing!

M
L
September 22, 2014
I feel like my surgery also worsened my breathing issues. Do you know what your doctor did to improve yours?

M
September 22, 2014
I don't know the details but I remembered him saying that after my nose was shortened it wasn't supported with cartilage and also my nose was crooked inside. So he straightened it and put cartilage to support the tip. If you have breathing issues I would consult other surgeons and get a second opinion. I suffered for too long and was told I had allergies and was put on medication. After my revision I haven't been taking allergy med as I can breath just fine. Good luck to you!
A
October 5, 2014
I did my 3rd rhinoplasty with Anil R. Shah, MD at the Water Tower in Chicago and I love my new nose. The way I chose my first two doctors was through academic background, the 2nd being an ivy league graduate, so I figured I couldn't go wrong-- big mistake in thinking that academic genius means surgical talent. Picking Shah, in all honesty, was a gamble that paid off since 4 years ago, there wasn't much info about him. After all, he was only 36 and relatively new to plastic surgery (in terms of years, not experience) when he performed my revision, so I simply got lucky by choosing him. People are so much nicer to me now, not because they've changed, but because I got better looking. I know it sounds bad, but that's the world we live in.

C
January 16, 2015
Thanks for sharing this. I'm actually going in for my FOURTH surgery this month, possibly next week. It is very emotionally exhausting and seriously takes it's toll. People often say' well , i can't see anything wrong with it' or ' oh another surgery?' people dont really understand how traumitising it is to go through one surgery let alone a revision.

M
January 16, 2015
Wow fourth! I remember I was so scared to go in for the revision. I hope all goes well with you and this is your last rhinoplasty. It's indeed an exhausting journey both physically and emotionally. The swelling also takes long time to resolve. Please keep me updated. Thanks for checking in.

M

C
January 16, 2015
I will do ! Will be posting before and cast removal day pics and of course progress pics. Are you happier with your nose now? It seems a whole lot thinner at the bridge than what it was. I think your surgeon did a good job. I too HATE my wide bridge which got worse after my third surgery. Like you, feel its worse with smiling. I'm not looking forward to the recovery to be honest but pray this is my last one.

M
January 16, 2015
That's wonderful. I look forward to reading your blog. My nose looks much better than prerevision. I'm still hoping the tip will get more refined as it deswell. Good luck to you!

C
A
April 27, 2015
Do you mind sharing pictures of your nose post surgery w/ Dr. Denenberg?

M
April 27, 2015
You can find photos post primary with Denenberg under my revision review at http://www.realself.com/review/baltimore-md-revision-rhinoplasty-finally-revision-for-in-march#

V
February 25, 2016
I'm sorry I went to the link you show here but didn't see your before and after primary photos. I saw many and they were post your secondary revision. Are the primary ones mixed in? If so, I can't tell which is which so I can't give you my opinion.... :o)

M
February 25, 2016
Those were all post revision photos. I had to remove many photos from my post for privacy reasons. I do plan to post some photos soon. Thanks.

Replies (5)