Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Smart Lipo Reviews REVIEWS

So Disappointed - Foster City, CA

ORIGINAL POST

I am a 35 year old mother of 2. I first met with...

encantar
$9,600
I am a 35 year old mother of 2. I first met with Dr. Beck in 2013, and we explored options for removing some excess fat; he told me I was a good candidate for Smart Lipo and that the recovery would be nominal (down time of 4 days) and that I would see results quickly, 80% within 6-8 months and 100% at a year. In October of 2013, he performed the procedure in 2 sessions on 6 areas: upper abdomen, lower abdomen, flanks, inner thighs, outer thighs and lower back. There were issues from procedure day forward. I have waited this long to write the review because I wanted to allow ample time for healing and final results.
Pre-op, I was given a Post-Op instruction paper that was half a page long and didn’t address many standard issues that arose, and I had to do online research and keep calling his office for info that should have been included in the instructions (as a comparison, a colleague of mine had Smart Lipo in one area and received a 5 page Post-Op instructions from his physician). The next issue was the pain. Dr. Beck did not offer anesthesia as an option and said there would be minimal discomfort during the procedure and that the standard painkillers would be sufficient (pill and local injection, if I recall). I have a pretty high pain threshold and I have to tell you that the procedure was excruciatingly painful, both sessions. I cried so much that I was congested. Again, in comparison, I went to another surgeon (Dr. Hoffman in Palo Alto) for a special post-op laser treatment that wasn’t available at Dr. Beck’s office), and they said they always recommend anesthesia for a procedure involving 2 or more areas because pain can be an issue. When I spoke to Dr. Beck about the level of pain in a follow up appt, he said that they weren’t equipped to offer anesthesia at that time and he didn’t think it would be necessary. The recovery time and level of discomfort was also much more prolonged and intense than what I was told it would be. There were complications with the upper abdomen that have never resolved, and besides outer thighs, I haven’t noticed a difference, but was hoping it was because I had gotten used to the changes. I went in today to take final pictures (17 months after) and compared pre and post pics with Dr. Beck side by side. The only area with a noticeable change is outer thighs and the low abdomen BUT his abdominal incisions were high (well above the bikini line) and one of the scars is very noticeable in a bikini. When I asked why he didn’t make the incisions lower so that they could be hidden, he said that the equipment he was using at the time wouldn’t allow him to get the upper abdomen with lower incisions and that he has since gotten new equipment that does allow for it. My upper abdomen protrudes more than it did pre-op because of scar tissue and the other areas look no better than they did pre-op. I exercise much more now and my diet is good, so it is not because I have gained weight back. I expressed my disappointment to Dr. Beck today and he has offered no solution. To pay nearly 10k and go through the pain and a much longer, more painful recovery than described with nearly no result is beyond upsetting. I highly encourage you to go somewhere else.

encantar's provider

Joel B. Beck, MD, FACS

Joel B. Beck, MD, FACS

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

4.9 | 289 Reviews
PROFILE

encantar rating for Dr. Beck:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (5)

User Avatar
March 27, 2015
Thank you for your very detailed review. I would be very disappointed also. Would be very helpful if you could post your pre and post pics (no head of course). Thanks!
July 7, 2015
Had it done almost 2 weeks ago - you can go to my page and see my results. I think I see the light at the end of this incredibly long tunnel!!!
March 28, 2015
So sorry you had such a disappointing experience. Mine is still up in the air - just abdomen - have problems above belly button and above partial hysterectomy scar that the PS caused when he did the revision - he went in on one side of the scar and apparently the fat transferred to the other side - now will probably have to pay again to fix these spots. None to happy, but what are you going to do? Will see him again in 6 weeks, so we shall see.
July 6, 2015
Hello RS sister - I am so sorry that you had to go through such pain and didn't get the results you wanted. Thank you for sharing and rest assured that you have helped other women (including myself) make a different decision regarding this Dr.
I hope that you are one day, able to have the shape/body that you desire - no doubt you are already beautiful! S
July 7, 2015
So sorry you had such a horrid experience!!! I can't imagine paying that much money with very little results and no offer from my PS to at least try to make things right!!! I had smart lipo of my upper and lower abdomen only for $4800 under general anesthesia last July. From day 2 I developed a huge crease right above my belly button that never went away - albeit much smaller - still there. He recommended velashape (a vicious machine that rolls and sucks your skin in while also incorporating heat which can burn you) after the initial procedure for $425 - it hurt like hell at day 12 and made no difference whatsoever. At 6 months I say him and he did my 1st revision- $650 - they wanted $850, but I negotiated it down - only 5 incisions done under local with pain meds - didn't hurt, but still did not get rid of problem area above belly button and he created a problem above my hysterectomy scar when he went in on one side only and pushed the fat to the other. I saw him for follow-up and told him the cost which was supposed to be for supplies only - not the room, too. He said he would do another revision - this time only $85. I just had my 2nd revision done (it will be 2 weeks Thursday) and I am starting to see the results I should have gotten initially. He told me to massage, massage, massage. I've read that scar tissue forms quickly so I bought a hand massager that I use daily to break up the scar tissue that's starting to develop, I ice daily to keep swelling done and finally at night I massage by hand and then into the CG garment I go. I've maintained my 135 weight (started at 148 a year ago, but lost to my current weight within a couple of weeks) - I have walked 4-5 miles every day since, golf 2-3 times a week - a very active person and eat correctly. I am hopeful that with all the work I am putting in that I can stop the scar tissue formation - he told me with smart lipo that that includes heat which forms scar tissue. This last revision, he used 2 different sized cannulas and broke up all of the old scar tissue - have to admit I was sorer than initial procedure, but I do believe it is working. I wish you all the luck in world to get the results you want and will be praying for you.