Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Scar Removal REVIEWS

Immorality - Erie, PA

ORIGINAL POST

A few years ago, I got a terrible result from Dr....

David55651
$650
A few years ago, I got a terrible result from Dr. Stephen J. Heaney in his Erie, PA office. I feel that he totally destroyed my self-esteem by performing an operation that he should NOT have chosen to do! Here are the facts: I originally consulted with him about very thin, flat, pale, (almost un-noticeable) linear scars located on my arm that bothered me because they looked self-inflicted, and were difficult to hide and explain under public discretion. During the consultation, it was decided that Dr. Stephen J Heaney, MD would remove them by excising a large chunk of skin from my arm in a SINGLE STAGED OPERATION! This surgery left me with a scar almost 1-inch wide, and is still angry red several years later----even after multiple treatments from the pulsed dye laser at a facility in New York. Stephen J Heaney, MD would most likely argue that the manner in which a wound heals is unpredictable, unique to each individual, and that there is no way to guarantee a satisfactory result. While these arguments are valid and generally true, it is well documented throughout the medical literature, and widely accepted by other plastic surgeons and doctors that the volar forearm is an area of the body that DOES NOT generally heal well because of the location and amount of tension present on the skin due to the underlying muscle tissue. When I asked Stephen J Heaney, MD. about the width of the scar he drew a line with his pencil. He then went on to say that I was his miracle patient. I trusted his knowledge and experience and was horribly disappointed. In fact, upon completion of the operation he told me to keep the tape on the scar forever........indicating he knew well ahead of time that the resulting scar would be unsightly. Dr. Stephen Heaney DID NOT thoroughly address these issues during the consultation. The only positive thing I can say about the operation is that there were no major complications (ie. infection, wound dehiscence)... Because of my questionable psychological state of mind, Stephen J. Heaney MD. should have tried his best to talk me out of surgery. Ultimately, if you are considering plastic surgery and live in the Erie area------------go else where, preferably to a reputable plastic surgeon in a larger city.

David55651's provider

Steven Heaney, MD

Steven Heaney, MD

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

David55651 rating for Dr. Heaney:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (4)

December 17, 2013

Hi David,

Thank you for sharing the details of your procedure with the community.  

December 18, 2020
He is the worst. Never have this doctor do anything to your face. I had blepharoplasty 7 months ago and my eyes are uneven, sunken in and look horrible not to mention he charged 8000.00! Also the worst part is that I am no longer able to wear my left contact lens. For 33 years of surgery the job was terrible and he just wanted the money
March 5, 2021
He has only done a few blepharoplasty surgeries. He is terrible and thinks there is nothing wrong. Dr. Heaney charges more than double for his services and the outcomes are horrific.
March 8, 2021
He destroys every face. I can't say about other procedures, but my eyelus are sunken in my head, because he took out too much skin and fat. The undereye area is also sunk egg n in due to the same reason. He charged me $7700.00 to make me look horrible, changed the shape of both eyes and now I can't wear makeup or even wear a contact in my left eye. Worst botch job ever. Wish he could see some of these after photos of ladies who are so happy and look so beautiful. Do not ever let this man touch your eyes if you live in or around the Erie, PA area. He is the worst. For 32 years in practice you would think he would be able to do this surgery. I was talked into a blepharoplasty by someone who worked there (not her fault) but I really just went in for Erbium laser under eyes to smooth out some wrinkles