Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Facelift REVIEWS

Facelift Nightmare......can't Believe It Happened - Dallas, TX

ORIGINAL POST

Had a facelift in 2012 and it looked amazing for...

Leisa1
$7,600
Had a facelift in 2012 and it looked amazing for about 15 months, then a very prominent bulge appeared on the left side of my face. Went back to my PS and asked him to " only tighten up the are where the bulge was." He wanted to do a buccal fat pad reduction. After much research I told him I didn't want a buccal fat pad reduction and I didn't want any fat removed. Only the area tightened where the bulge was. He agreed. He said there would be no preop bloodwork necessary. On February 2014 I went back to have the area "tightened up." I was put to sleep using IV sedation and when I woke up he said " you had a great deal of subcutaneous fat in your lower face so I removed it, so I think you will like this sculpted look." The nightmare started! Very asymmetrical, gaunt, face. The pictures will tell the story. I asked for my money back and he refused!!

Leisa1's provider

Warren J. Katz, MD (retired)

Warren J. Katz, MD (retired)

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

Leisa1 rating for Dr. Katz:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (24)

August 31, 2015
Sorry you are going through this. The area beneath your chin can be fixed by fat graft. There are many surgeons capable at this. I can make suggestions if you like. I do think you are still very pretty but see the areas of concern. The good news is that I do know they can be completely corrected.
August 31, 2015
Please make suggestions
August 31, 2015
I'm sorry you had to go through this. I am sure you will find someone to fix this but it must be very upsetting to have this happen. Wishing you the best!
September 1, 2015
i hear dr Lyos in Houston is very good. Maybe you can consult with him for a revision. It looks like the kind of issues that can be corrected.
September 2, 2015
Thank you
September 2, 2015
Am sorry, who was the doctor so no one else goes to him?
September 2, 2015
Dr. Warren Katz Dallas, Texas
September 4, 2015
There are so many doctors that do fat grafts. Let me ask which ones are best on the other forum I go to and then I will post them here.
September 4, 2015
Thank you
User Avatar
February 12, 2017
Private messge me!
UPDATED FROM Leisa1
3 years post

Dr warren Katz ruined my Face

Leisa1
Katz took large amount of subcutaneous fat out of my face and now my skin is very loose and sagging!

Replies (3)

January 16, 2016
I can't believe this doctor thinks he did a good job. Please rate him so that others will be able to find your review.
User Avatar
January 17, 2016
I am so confused as to why that large bump appeared on your face so long after the procedure. That is scary. What is even scarier is the "sculpted look" he gave you. You are still beautiful and I hope you are able to find a competent PS to fix this.
February 4, 2016
I see the small dent but that should be easliy fixed with a fat graft. Also the removal of the fat from the lower face might look good with a revisionary facelift. Dr. Stuzin in Florida does revision facelifts. There are other I could recommend if you are interested. I agree with the other poster you are still beautiful! Hugs.
UPDATED FROM Leisa1
3 years post

Face is getting rapidly worse

Leisa1
Losing shape and volume rapidly 2 years after PS removed large amount of fat from face.

Replies (25)

User Avatar
March 2, 2016
You really do need to see a different, more qualified surgeon. Your results are very disturbing. You are a very pretty woman!
March 3, 2016
I am having a revision this month. I am very nervous, but it's something I need to do for myself, because my face just continues to deteriorate due to the excessive defatting Katz did.
User Avatar
March 3, 2016
Who are you using for your revision
User Avatar
March 3, 2016
I pray everything goes well for you with more satisfactory results from your revision. You are a beautiful woman and it just breaks my heart that this happened to you...and after you told him NOT to take the fat out!! I'll be rooting for you and also following along to see your new results.
March 3, 2016
Thank You
March 3, 2016
Sissy, I have surgery scheduled with Simeon Wall Sr. In Shreveport, Louisiana. March 17th.
User Avatar
March 2, 2016
you should make his name public , so we all would stay away from his practice
March 3, 2016
There are other sites to post your reviews- I would recommend doing so.
March 3, 2016
Please rate this doctor and warn others. He has a 5 star rating on Real Self but your results are anything but 5 stars. I hope you find a qualified doctor to do a revision.
March 3, 2016
I rated him a 1 but I have no idea what happened to my review!
March 3, 2016
REAL SELF moderators please explain why her negative review is missing? This makes me question the integrity of this site!!
User Avatar
March 3, 2016

Hey there ladies, I just investigated this and I think I see what happened. Leisa1, I have sent you a personal message so please check your inbox.

March 4, 2016
Thank you Angie for investigating and making it so his name is rated.
March 3, 2016
Can you get a fat transfer or dermal fillers done?
March 3, 2016
I am getting fat transfer done, but as each day passes, my face is deteriorating.
March 4, 2016
Wishing you all the best with the revision/fat transfer.
Its really horrific when doctors breach their patients trust and just do whatever they want!
March 4, 2016
Yes, Ivana.....this has definitely affected my quality of life and has put an immense amout of stress on me!
User Avatar
March 3, 2016
I am so sorry you've had this experience. I have seen several other ladies on Real Self who've also had buccal fat extractions that went poorly. One who subsequently had a revision was really pleased with the results. I'll be praying that your outcome is wonderful - you deserve it after all you've been through. And judging by your photos, you are already lovely!