Treatment Provider
Reviews you can trust, from real people like you.
How it works
- Our highly-trained Review Moderation team evaluates all reviews before they're published to ensure they're written by people like you and not a member of a doctor's office.
- This multi-step process takes up to 24 hours from review submission to publication.
- Doctors can't pay to have reviews removed or hidden.
- Reviews are only removed at the reviewer's request or if they violate our Terms of Service.
If you have questions or believe we should re-evaluate a published review, let us know.
Sort by:
*Treatment results may vary
Third Time’s the Sculpted Charm: A Goldilocks Tale of Finding the Perfect Fit with Dr. Caughlin
I know most people won’t read all of this, so let me start by saying: I am beyond happy with Dr. Caughlin and his work. If you’re considering him, look no further. He’s the best, hands down, and I couldn’t recommend him more.
Now, for anyone interested in my journey, here’s a detailed account of my experience, spanning years and multiple surgeons, that ultimately led me to Dr. Caughlin and the incredible results I have today.
How It All Began
My journey started in 2022, although the seeds were planted earlier. I had a significant sports injury in 2021, and as anyone who’s been sidelined from an active lifestyle knows, weight gain can sneak up on you. I went from playing basketball twice a week and lifting five times a week to being much more sedentary. Even though I didn’t feel drastically different, I noticed changes in my face that I couldn’t ignore.
For as fit as I was — I’ve always had a six-pack — my face didn’t match the rest of me. I’ve been told I had a “baby face,” and while that might sound like a compliment, it’s not what I wanted to hear at (now) 33 years old. I felt my face lacked the definition I desired. I wasn’t depressed or deeply insecure about it, but I’ve always believed in improving yourself when the opportunity arises. That mindset led me to explore options like buccal fat removal and neck liposuction.
My First Procedures – Disappointing Results
In 2022, I consulted a maxillofacial surgeon on the East Coast and underwent buccal fat removal and neck liposuction. Unfortunately, the results were underwhelming — in fact, they were worse. Not only did I see no improvement, but I also noticed more asymmetry in my face. At the time, I weighed about 180 pounds at 5'10" (about 15lbs more than what I had been for 10 years), and while I wasn’t unhappy with my body, I was disappointed in the outcome of the surgery.
When I followed up with the first surgeon, they suggested a genioplasty as the solution to achieve the results I wanted. This upset me because I felt I should have been told upfront that my goals weren’t achievable with the initial procedures. I’d already spent thousands of dollars and undergone surgery, only to feel like I was back at square one.
A Second Attempt – Another Setback
In 2023, now on the West Coast, I started exploring options again. This time, I consulted multiple surgeons, all with varying opinions. One refused to see me, saying chin implants weren’t for me after I sent a picture in. Another quoted me an astronomical $20,000 for a procedure. I ultimately settled on a highly reputable but older surgeon for a mentoplasty and submentalplasty.
I was never mad throughout the process, In just assumed that after these two procedures the last two years, I just wasn't a candidate for these things. I didn't notice a difference, and I started to realize the implant made my face more round appearing. The implant was far too small, placed in the wrong spot, and the scar was large and oddly positioned. After living with those results for a year, I felt like I’d taken another step backward.
Finding Dr. Caughlin
By 2024, I was hesitant but determined to fix the mistakes of the past. After a little looking around, I found Dr. Caughlin. From my first virtual consultation, I felt confident he understood my goals. He had a eye for facial aesthetics and knew how to achieve a balanced, natural, yet refined look. His confidence and expertise immediately set him apart.
Unlike my previous experiences, Dr. Caughlin took the time to explain the procedure, suggest the right implant (a larger one than I originally anticipated), and set realistic expectations. What also impressed me was his ability to balance professionalism with approachability. He listened to my concerns, addressed my fears, and made me feel like I was finally in the hands of someone who truly cared.
The Procedure – A Smooth Experience
In June 2024, I underwent chin implant revision, jaw contouring, and neck liposuction with Dr. Caughlin. This time, the procedure was done while I was awake, which initially made me nervous. I’ve fainted from needles in the past, but Dr. Caughlin and his team (thanks James) were incredibly accommodating and supportive throughout.
The surgery itself was quick and efficient. The scar was much smaller and placed in a more discreet spot. Though the swelling was significant at first, the results gradually revealed themselves over the next few months. I noticed immediate improvement in the symmetry and definition of my jawline and chin.
The Results – A Game Changer
It’s been six months since my surgery, and I can confidently say this has been life-changing. For the first time in years, I feel like my face matches the rest of me. I’m more confident in photos, and yes, I’ve even noticed more attention from women I’d never imagined matching with before. It’s a strange but welcome boost to my self-esteem.
Dr. Caughlin not only corrected the mistakes of my past surgeries but exceeded my expectations. I’m now at 160 pounds, in the best shape of my life, and couldn’t be happier with the way I look.
Why Dr. Caughlin Stands Out
Expertise: He understands facial aesthetics in a way that other surgeons didn’t.
Communication: He’s easy to talk to, straightforward, and confident without being dismissive.
Results: The difference is night and day compared to my previous surgeries. He delivered exactly what I was hoping for.
Final Thoughts
If you’re considering facial surgery, take it from someone who’s been through three surgeons in three years: Dr. Caughlin is the one you can trust. His work has truly changed my life, and I’ll continue to recommend him to anyone seeking a skilled and compassionate plastic surgeon.
I hope this review helps someone on the fence about their own journey. Trust me, it’s worth it.
Now, for anyone interested in my journey, here’s a detailed account of my experience, spanning years and multiple surgeons, that ultimately led me to Dr. Caughlin and the incredible results I have today.
How It All Began
My journey started in 2022, although the seeds were planted earlier. I had a significant sports injury in 2021, and as anyone who’s been sidelined from an active lifestyle knows, weight gain can sneak up on you. I went from playing basketball twice a week and lifting five times a week to being much more sedentary. Even though I didn’t feel drastically different, I noticed changes in my face that I couldn’t ignore.
For as fit as I was — I’ve always had a six-pack — my face didn’t match the rest of me. I’ve been told I had a “baby face,” and while that might sound like a compliment, it’s not what I wanted to hear at (now) 33 years old. I felt my face lacked the definition I desired. I wasn’t depressed or deeply insecure about it, but I’ve always believed in improving yourself when the opportunity arises. That mindset led me to explore options like buccal fat removal and neck liposuction.
My First Procedures – Disappointing Results
In 2022, I consulted a maxillofacial surgeon on the East Coast and underwent buccal fat removal and neck liposuction. Unfortunately, the results were underwhelming — in fact, they were worse. Not only did I see no improvement, but I also noticed more asymmetry in my face. At the time, I weighed about 180 pounds at 5'10" (about 15lbs more than what I had been for 10 years), and while I wasn’t unhappy with my body, I was disappointed in the outcome of the surgery.
When I followed up with the first surgeon, they suggested a genioplasty as the solution to achieve the results I wanted. This upset me because I felt I should have been told upfront that my goals weren’t achievable with the initial procedures. I’d already spent thousands of dollars and undergone surgery, only to feel like I was back at square one.
A Second Attempt – Another Setback
In 2023, now on the West Coast, I started exploring options again. This time, I consulted multiple surgeons, all with varying opinions. One refused to see me, saying chin implants weren’t for me after I sent a picture in. Another quoted me an astronomical $20,000 for a procedure. I ultimately settled on a highly reputable but older surgeon for a mentoplasty and submentalplasty.
I was never mad throughout the process, In just assumed that after these two procedures the last two years, I just wasn't a candidate for these things. I didn't notice a difference, and I started to realize the implant made my face more round appearing. The implant was far too small, placed in the wrong spot, and the scar was large and oddly positioned. After living with those results for a year, I felt like I’d taken another step backward.
Finding Dr. Caughlin
By 2024, I was hesitant but determined to fix the mistakes of the past. After a little looking around, I found Dr. Caughlin. From my first virtual consultation, I felt confident he understood my goals. He had a eye for facial aesthetics and knew how to achieve a balanced, natural, yet refined look. His confidence and expertise immediately set him apart.
Unlike my previous experiences, Dr. Caughlin took the time to explain the procedure, suggest the right implant (a larger one than I originally anticipated), and set realistic expectations. What also impressed me was his ability to balance professionalism with approachability. He listened to my concerns, addressed my fears, and made me feel like I was finally in the hands of someone who truly cared.
The Procedure – A Smooth Experience
In June 2024, I underwent chin implant revision, jaw contouring, and neck liposuction with Dr. Caughlin. This time, the procedure was done while I was awake, which initially made me nervous. I’ve fainted from needles in the past, but Dr. Caughlin and his team (thanks James) were incredibly accommodating and supportive throughout.
The surgery itself was quick and efficient. The scar was much smaller and placed in a more discreet spot. Though the swelling was significant at first, the results gradually revealed themselves over the next few months. I noticed immediate improvement in the symmetry and definition of my jawline and chin.
The Results – A Game Changer
It’s been six months since my surgery, and I can confidently say this has been life-changing. For the first time in years, I feel like my face matches the rest of me. I’m more confident in photos, and yes, I’ve even noticed more attention from women I’d never imagined matching with before. It’s a strange but welcome boost to my self-esteem.
Dr. Caughlin not only corrected the mistakes of my past surgeries but exceeded my expectations. I’m now at 160 pounds, in the best shape of my life, and couldn’t be happier with the way I look.
Why Dr. Caughlin Stands Out
Expertise: He understands facial aesthetics in a way that other surgeons didn’t.
Communication: He’s easy to talk to, straightforward, and confident without being dismissive.
Results: The difference is night and day compared to my previous surgeries. He delivered exactly what I was hoping for.
Final Thoughts
If you’re considering facial surgery, take it from someone who’s been through three surgeons in three years: Dr. Caughlin is the one you can trust. His work has truly changed my life, and I’ll continue to recommend him to anyone seeking a skilled and compassionate plastic surgeon.
I hope this review helps someone on the fence about their own journey. Trust me, it’s worth it.
Provider Review
Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon
845 N Michigan Ave., Chicago, Illinois