Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

Disaster Rhinoplasty - Chatswood, AU

ORIGINAL POST

I went to see Dr. Gerarchi for a rhinoplasty based...

Bbebe
$12,000
I went to see Dr. Gerarchi for a rhinoplasty based on some good online reviews. I now live to regret it.I really liked him when I first met him; he seemed competent and kind and that he understood my concerns. I saw him around 4 times before actually having the procedure done to make sure that we were on the same page. We went through things in detail over and over again and I was surprised at his patience. He did do computer imaging which he does state is not a guarantee of results. I think computer imaging is an important tool so that you and your surgeon understand the outcomes you want and the outcomes that are achievable. I felt really confident that I had made the right decision and despite the enormous cost I went through the surgery.BIG MISTAKE!!! Unfortunately everything that was discussed (even on the morning of the surgery before I went under the anaesthetic) did not carry through to the surgery as I woke up with a much uglier and deformed nose. I had been so clear on what I wanted yet none of those things were done despite Dr. Gerarchi assuring me that it was achievable and would look amazing. There were things done that he didn't even tell me he was going to do; things I never wanted! I gave it time to settle and of course nothing changed. I wish every day that I never walked in to his rooms. It was supposed to be a simple procedure, I wasn't asking for anything too drastic. It's not ok for any surgeon to go into surgery and do whatever he wants on the spot without having first discussed these things with the patient. I have since come to learn a lot of his practice is smoke and mirrors; a lot of the positive reviews on this, and other forums and web pages (the ones without pics) have been written by his staff etc.He claims to be a rhinoplasty and revision rhinoplasty expert however I caution you to seek out a plastic and reconstructive surgeon NOT an ENT "cosmetic" surgeon as they just don't have the same training or experience. Things can go wrong with a plastic surgeon too however it is less likely to happen. I believe Dr. Gerarchi is not an expert in rhinoplasty despite his claims, and considering he charges the same (if not more) than proper qualified plastic surgeons I suggest you find other reputable plastic surgeons who provide photos from all angles of their patients and who have proper training.Having said that, it has now been almost 9 months and I have found a plastic surgeon whom I trust and will be having a revision performed by him in the coming months as I look hideous and cannot go on feeling and looking this way. Dr. Gerarchi failed to answer why he had done things so differently to what was discussed although he has offered to revise (for a fee) I cannot trust him to go anywhere near me again (he stuffed up once that's enough for me to run the other way). My scar will also have to be revised as it was not stitched properly and due to the bulky tip graft being so uneven the scar sits uneven and doesn't look right at all. I also didn't like the fact that his nurse (who was quite rough) removed my stitches as I believe a Dr. should be there to handle all aftercare. Needless to say I am very disappointed with my experience and can only hope this will be fixed in the coming months by a proper plastic surgeon!Lastly I won't be posting photos here however when I have my revision performed I will be reviewing the other Dr. and if all good I will post before and after photos with that review; I just don't have the confidence to put up photos of the way I look right now!

Bbebe's provider

Paul G. Gerarchi, MBBS, FRACS (not practicing)

Paul G. Gerarchi, MBBS, FRACS (not practicing)

Facial Plastic Surgeon, Specialist in Plastic Surgery

Bbebe rating for Dr. Gerarchi:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (34)

May 22, 2015
May 22, 2015
Excuse me please do not be so rude or disrespectful. I am sharing my OWN experience with Dr. Gerarchi. You may have had a good one, and if any doctor does enough operations there will surely be a handful of good ones. You also had a completely different operation to me. Do not try to diminish the pain and suffering I have experienced with this Dr. This is my first review of him so I don't know where you are getting your information from. As stated in my above review after my next operation when I am happy and confident with the way I look and feel I will happily post before and after photos. I do not need the negative comments at this point in time as I am in a fragile state as it is; I look in the mirror and hate the way I look, I don't need to hear any judgement or negative comments. After my next operation which will be in a couple months as I am not yet 1 year out from my operation with Dr. Gerarchi, I will be reviewing the plastic surgeon I have decided to go with for the revision. I will post photos then. Also FYI Dr. Gerarchi is NOT a plastic surgeon he is an ENT surgeon who has some (limited) training in cosmetic facial work. You can research his credentials and check with the Society of Plastic Surgeons - he is not on there. Look him up on the Australian Medical Association website and you will see he is registered as an ENT and head & neck surgeon NOT a cosmetic plastic or reconstructive surgeon. There is no need to be so hateful, everyone is entitled to their experience and it so happens that mine is a negative one, and from what I have since read and seen its not the only one. I am not trying to discredit anyone however he wasn't honest with me, and my experience with him was not good, same goes with his nurse Susi Garrett.
User Avatar
May 22, 2015

Thank you very much for sharing your experience on RealSelf!

May 22, 2015
May 23, 2015
Yes he holds a degree in Bachelor of Medicine/Bachelor of Surgery which means he can operate however his training and speciality as stated on the Australian Medical Association website states Head & Neck surger NOT plastic/cosmetic/reconstructive surgery. Anyone who has a degree in surgery is a member of FRACS however he is not a member of the Australian Socitey of Plastic Surgeons or Aesthetic Plastic surgeons etc. this is because he never specialised in this field therefore he is NOT a Plastic Surgeon. He can call himself a "cosmetic" surgeon because in Australia there is no regulated body for cosmetic surgery. He may have done training as I stated previously in aesthetic facial surgery however he is NOT qualified as a Plastic Surgeon. I understand that you are happy with your outcome and that you may have been offered a discount on your surgery by his staff if you wrote positive reviews (I was offered this too) however you cannot accuse me of being dishonest etc. To say that I have caused a lot of damage is appalling; what about the damage Dr Gerarchi has caused to my face and my life by the botched operation? No one wishes more than me that I had a positive experience and I could rave about him but unfortunately for me this is not the case; I wish I had an amazing result and was happy but it's not how things worked out for me. You are entitled to your feedback and I'm happy that you have had a good outcome but it's not the same for everyone. Also he was misleading in a lot of ways including that he states he is a Plastic surgeon when he is not.
May 23, 2015
May 23, 2015
Twelve thousand is a lot to pay for a botched job, not to mention the suffering you are going through, and the cost of a revision. You are brave to post your experience and hopefully, others will think before they use this surgeon - it seems like everyone wants to be a plastic surgeon nowadays, whether or not they have the prescribed training and artistic flair. I hope your next surgeon is able to help.
May 23, 2015
Hi, yes it was a lot of hard earned money!! I could've maybe come to terms of it was something not the surgeons fault etc. however the fact that what was discussed was blatantly ignored while I was unconscious and had no say. That is the worst thing. I would rather have a surgeon say from the get go that they can't achieve xyz rather than say yes yes yes then take the liberty to do whatever they please during the operation. It can ruin lives not just faces. He is misleading by stating he is a plastic surgeon when he isn't. That should be the first thing to be rectified and then he should take a more honest approach. I was offered a discount if I agreed to write positive reviews after my surgery but I chose not to as I had no intention of writing reviews etc. I'm only sharing my experience now because I think it's important that others know how unregulated the "cosmetic" surgery industry is. Also I felt so safe and trusted this surgeon however it didn't work out for me. Others need to be aware. Thanks for your kind words, I hope this can be fixed as well and will be reviewing my plastic surgeon after my next operation as well!!!
May 25, 2015
Thank you for writing this review, have now cancelled my appointment. Could I please ask you who you are going to for revision?
May 25, 2015
Hi there, I can private message you who I am going to see if you like? I don't want to recommend or give good reviews to the plastic surgeon as yet as I haven't had the revision done yet (will be having the op in a couple months) but can give you the name and you can check him out and see if you feel comfortable?!
May 26, 2015
That would be great, thank you.
UPDATED FROM Bbebe
8 months post

Photo

Bbebe
This is the hardest and most embarrassing thing but I think it needs to be done to make people aware. This is a photo of me now after Dr Gerarchi operated and left me with a hideous, huge and badly scared nose. All other before, after etc. photos will be posted when I have my next surgery and am more confident.

Replies (20)

June 1, 2015
I'm so sorry you're going through this. Unfortunately I'm in the same boat and it was also with and ENT/Facial plastic surgeon. I also wish I hadn't gone that route and that was for a revision so now I'm potentially looking at a 3rd surgery. He keeps insisting I won't need one but my nose looks horrible and isn't getting any better. I feel for anyone that has to go through the daily torture this creates!
June 1, 2015
Thanks for your support!! Yes it is devastating. My whole life is on hold because of this. Surgeons purporting to be something they are not should be disallowed; I wish I had done more research and investigated my surgeons claims instead of just believing him and taking his word for it. I am now consulting with a properly qualified and trained real plastic surgeon so hopefully this can all be fixed! Hope things work out for you too xx
June 2, 2015
thank you for posting ur photo i know how hard it must be. Will be watching this space for more updates, hopefully very happy updates after your revision :)
June 2, 2015
Thank you Hun.. It is hard but if it helps others make the right decision and avoid what happened to me then it's worth it!! Will definitely be updating and hopefully it can be fixed. Sending positive thoughts your way too [RS bleep]
June 2, 2015
Thank you for your generosity in putting your photo on realself. I know it was not easy for you, looking forward to seeing a happier you very soon.
June 2, 2015
Thank you so much for all your support and your lovely words! Me too, hope I can get this fixed and move on with my life [RS bleep]
June 2, 2015
Thanks for sharing your story and posting the photo. It's great you found a different surgeon you can trust. Hope that works out for you!
June 2, 2015
Thank you so much for your well wishes.. I hope it works out too can't live like this anymore! Hopefully I will have a positive update after my next surgery! All the best with you too xx
June 3, 2015
Hoping you have an awesome outcome. Praying for your revision to turn out well.
June 4, 2015
Thank you so much!!! Means a lot [RS bleep]