What Type of Implant is Best for a Breast Augmentation?

Doctor Answers 39

Saline and Silicone Breast Implants Can Both Provide Exceptional Results

The return of silicone gel breast implants raises an important question for prospective breast augmentation patients: are silicone gel implants better than saline implants? The answer, in my opinion, will be different for each patient, and will depend on the patient's personal feelings and opinions about a host of issues related to silicone gel implants, including implant cost, the monitoring required to detect silicone gel implant rupture, the incisions required, and the potential need to replace the implants (as in buy a new pair) if a reoperation is required for capsular contracture or other issues. Additional factors that will impact a patient's choice of implant include the pre-operative breast size and the desired post-operative breast volume. In my Raleigh, North Carolina Plastic Surgery practice I regularly use both silicone and saline implants for breast augmentation.
Breast implant manufacturers have indicated that the cost of gel implants will remain more expensive than saline implants. This adds about $800 to the cost of breast augmentation. Another cost issue associated with silicone gel implants which may, over time, be much more significant than the increased implant purchase price is post-operative monitoring for gel implant rupture. While saline implant ruptures are immediately obvious, silicone gel implant ruptures are not generally detectable by the patient or physician, and an MRI scan is required to conclusively make the diagnosis. The FDA recommends that patients with ruptured silicone gel breast implants have the implants replaced or removed.
The FDA is also recommending that women with silicone gel implants have a breast MRI scan 3 years following breast augmentation, with repeat scans every two years thereafter.
Yet another cost issue to consider is the fact that the FDA has mandated that silicone gel breast implants are a 'single-use item'. Some surgeons have interpreted this to mean that at the time of a reoperation for capsular contracture the implants may have to be discarded, once they are removed from the implant pockets so that capsulotomy / capsulectomy may be performed. Capsular contracture is one of the primary causes for reoperation in patients with breast implants. A physician performing surgical treatment of a capsular contracture would therefore, in order to adhere to FDA guidelines, have to insert a new implant or implants, the cost of which would be passed along to the patient.
As silicone gel implants are pre-filled, they require a larger incision for implant insertion, which of course varies with the size of the implant that is used. Saline implants are filled after insertion, and can therefore be rolled into a long, narrow shape for insertion through a smaller incision. A patient with a small areolar diameter may not be a good candidate for silicone gel implant insertion through a peri-areolar incision, while essentially any patient may have a saline implant inserted through that approach.
Most surgeons agree that silicone gel breast implants, in general, tend to feel more natural than saline breast implants. However, the degree to which this difference is significant varies a great deal with regard to two issues: the amount of breast tissue that exists prior to augmentation, and the size of the implant that is used. The more natural feel of a silicone gel implant will be much more important to patients who are slender and fit in an A cup bra preoperatively, as they have less subcutaneous soft tissue to conceal the implant. The difference will be less noticeable to a patient who is more full-figured.
Smaller saline implants, in my opinion, better simulate natural breast tissue than larger implants. If the goal of breast augmentation surgery is to produce a natural-appearing breast profile, and by 'natural-appearing' I mean that it matches the rest of a woman's figure and does not look like surgery, I think that most patients are best served by an implant smaller than 300cc in volume. Saline implants in this size range, in my experience, tend to produce results that not only look natural but also feel natural.

Raleigh-Durham Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 97 reviews

There is no one best implant for everyone

The great thing about breast implants, is that we have choices. While many of us prefer one implant more often than the other, both saline and silicone implants are good options. So, how do you decide?

Silicone implants will be a little softer and feel a bit more like normal breast tissue in most women. Generally, I prefer the feel of silicone over saline. However, silicone implants are more expensive, require a longer incision, and a little more difficult to know if they have ruptured. Although they had been taken off the market by the FDA for several years due to safely concerns, all the valid scientific studies have shown these implants to be safe. However, some women -- in spite of these studies -- still have some concerns about them. And these concerns frequently center around the possibilty of implant rupture. However, plastic surgeons and the implant manufacturers have worked long and hard to get them back on the market because of thier advantages to women.

Saline, implants on the other hand, are less expensive, require a smaller incision, can be adjusted in terms of the volume, and are very easy to know if they are ruptured. If a saline implant ruptures, it deflates, the body absorbs the saline, and the implant goes completely flat. However, these implants can feel a little firmer in many cases. But there are some women in whom the saline implants can feel as natural as the sliicone. Generally these women have a fair amount of their own breast tissue and are not using very large implants.

What I usually tell women, is that I feel that silicone implants are a bit more natural, but they can be a little more complicated than saline. So, you need to choose the implant that you will be most comfortable with, once it's inside your body. If cost and incision size are concerns, then go with saline. If you have concerns about having silicone in your body, then go with saline. If, however, you want the most natural feeling implants, then silicone is your best bet. This may particularly be the case if you have very little breast tissue to start with. The smaller your breasts are to begin with, the better option silicone implants will be..

But the bottom line is that both implants are good choices. You choose the one that seem best for you.

David B. Reath, MD
Knoxville Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 101 reviews

There are many options and many factors to consider.

There are many options and many factors to consider when deciding what type of implant to use for breast augmentation. Some decisions that need to be made include: saline or silicone; moderate, moderate-plus, or high profile; round or anatomical; smooth or textured.

The implant is only part of equation to achieve a nice breast augmentation result. Of course, it is very important to choose your surgeon carefully. A nice place to locate some board certified plastic surgeons who are committed to aesthetic surgery is www.surgery.org, the website for The American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery.

Sanjay Grover, MD
Orange County Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 166 reviews

Smooth walled, round, cohesive silicone gel implants.

These are my favorite for most women. If a patient is afraid of silicone, or if there is asymmetry to correct, then I use saline filled implants. These give good results too, as long as they are overfilled.

I don't use textured implants, or tear drop shaped ("anatomical") implants. These implants don't give better results and they are associated with more problems.

George J. Beraka, MD (retired)
Manhattan Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 9 reviews

The "best" is in your hands

Choice of implant type is a personal one and may be guided by consultation with your board certified plastic surgeon. During the consultation you may have the opportunity to feel each type and the surgeon will assess your body characteristics to determine which type may best suit your individual needs. Good luck!

The answer depends on your priorities

Both saline and silicone gel implants can give patients a happy result from a breast augmentation. In my practice about 80% go with gel and the rest saline.

Those that choose saline are willing to accept some potential wrinkles and ripples especially laterally when leaning forward in exchange for something their gut instinct tells them is "safer."

Those that choose gel place the "feel" of the result as a high priority and accept the extensive work done by the FDA which indicates that the gels are safe. Either way, and with either implant, patients can get a very nice outcome.

Silicone may look and feel more natural, but some women are more comfortable with Saline

Many women prefer silicone implants to saline implants because they feel and look more natural. However, they are more expensive and although the safety of these implants is well documented, some women are more comfortable having saline implants. The pros and cons of each type should be discussed with your board certified plastic surgeon.

Andrew Kleinman, MD
Board Certified Plastic Surgeon
Westchester, New York

Andrew Y. Kleinman, MD
Westchester Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 4 reviews

What Type of Implant is Best for a Breast Augmentation?

Thank you for the question. Choosing a breast implant comes down to a number of factors. From the patients perspective it is probably best to discuss with your surgeon what look you ultimately want to achieve and then utilising their knowledge come up with a plan that will meet your expectations. The best information you will receive is from your Specialist Plastic Surgeon, they have the knowledge and expertise to help choose the right implant.

In terms of the implants themselves there is a lot of information on the internet and certainly there is many differing opinions among surgeons about which is best. I personally prefer silicon implants as they can avoid a number of the problems associated with saline implants. There has been significant improvements in technology and constructions of the implants over the years and ultimately they are a very safe form of breast enhancement.

The choice of anatomical (shaped) or round implants can also be a challenging decision to make. My personal opinion is that round implants are an excellent choice for most patients however there are a few exceptions that do better with shaped implants. These patients include thin patients, those with minimal breast gland or in the reconstruction setting. 

The more surgeons you ask the more opinions you will have. The best advice is to find a qualified Specialist Plastic Surgeon that you trust and together choose the right procedure and implant for you.

Dr Guy Watts 

Best Breast Implant

As one might expect, there is no single answer to this question. The wishes, goals, expectations, physical examination and price constraints of the patient all factor in to the type of implant chosen. The bias of the surgeon also comes into play. Some surgeons have strong preferences about the fill material of the implants they use - I know of surgeons who will only use saline implants and I know of surgeons who will only use silicone implants.

I believe the best way to get an answer to this question is to consult with a board certified plastic surgeon with particular expertise in aesthetic breast surgery. If you do not have a recommendation from a friend or your physician, the website surgery.org is a good place to start.

Below is a link to a page on my website that lists in table form pros and cons of the different implants. Hopefully you will find this to be helpful.

Implant Choices and Breast Augmentation

Deciding on which implant to use is always a difficult decision for women. The benefit is that in this day and age is that there are so many choices of implants that the augmentation can be tailored to each patient.

Truly the best thing that you can do is be open with your surgeon about your desired results so they can help guide you in choosing the best implant for you.

First of all I would tell you that you are going to be happy with which everyone you decide to use for your augmentation. I would pick the one that fits your breast best. You want the implant to be about the same with as your breast. This will help give you some medial fullness but also keep you from looking heaving because the implant is too wide.

It is important to see your board certified plastic surgeon to help guide you to an implant that will give you an aesthetically pleasing breast.

These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.