The determination of whether rib or ear cartilage could be used depends on how high you want your nose to be. Based on your simulation, it appears that you will need rib cartilage to achieve the size you desire. Please consult with a board certified specialist who can assist you with achieving the results you seek. 3-dimensional computer imaging can also help you visualize what you may look like afterwards and help you communicate with your surgeon the results you desire.
I believe it is possible to obtain the results you outlined from rib grafting. It is important to determine that the supporting structures are strong enough to support a rib graft. I would suggest that you
Depending on what was done during your previous surgery it is unlikely that rib cartilage will be needed. I would augment your nose using diced cartilage, harvested from your septum or ears, wrapped in fascia. Your morphed results are realistic.