Assuming all are board certified plastic surgeons, you have to go with your feelings on who you feel the most comfortable with. I doubt that if you have any issues post-operatively that any ethical surgeon, regardless of how busy they are, would not address your concerns. If they are all top rated and have great reviews, they are probably all very dedicated and conscientious. You don't need 25 years of experience to be a talented surgeon...you need dedication to your patients, attention to detail, a great bedside manner and a goal of perfection. One other point regarding the surgeon involved with other types of surgeries: Revision Cosmetic Breast Surgery and Breast Cancer Reconstruction are very similar and quite complimentary. If your surgeon does alot of breast cancer revision or post-mastectomy reconstruction, chances are they are familiar with many of the same concepts. You just have to go with your gut.