Do I really need surgery? (Photos)

I once had braces. I think I was 16 when I got them removed. Then went through late puberty I guess and my jaw got bigger, more masculine. My profile doesn't look bad. Nobody can tell that I have an underbite. I will see my orthodontist next week. I sent some photos to some other ortho just to see what they say. Based on teeth photos only (without the whole face profile) , they suggested that I should break my jaw(surgery)...OR I may choose to get extractions and then braces.

No doctor answers yet