
Oculoplastic Surgeon, Board Certified in Ophthalmology
Dr. Joel Kopelman a leading facial plastic surgeon. Over the past 35 years he has performed facelifts, eyelid surgery, browlifts. He approaches each patient’s cosmetic surgery through an artistic lens. Dr. Kopelman prides himself in setting the highest standar
Asked By: Compassionate416739
ANSWER
When one eye looks more tired than the other, the cause is usually a small difference in how the two sides are built, and the right procedure depends on what is creating the tired look. A few common reasons include a lid that sits slightly lower, called ptosis, which makes the eye look smaller and sleepy, a heavier fold of upper lid skin or a lower brow on that side, more hollowing or a deeper groove under that eye, or a bag from a fat pad. Each has a different fix. A low lid is corrected with ptosis repair, extra upper lid skin with an upper blepharoplasty, a brow that sits lower with a small brow lift, and under eye hollows or bags with filler, fat grafting, or lower blepharoplasty. It is also very common for faces to be slightly asymmetric, and sleeping on one side, allergies, or a prescription difference can make one eye look more tired. If this is a long standing difference, a conservative fix aimed at the single cause usually works better than operating on both sides. If it is a recent change in lid position or swelling, I would have it examined first, since new asymmetry can sometimes have a medical cause. I would suggest an exam with an oculoplastic surgeon, who will measure both lids and tell you which of these explains the difference.
Asked By: PRINCESS3835
ANSWER
Both procedures are reasonable for what you describe, and the fact that you constantly use your forehead to lift your lids is an important clue. That habit usually means the upper lids are heavy from extra skin, a descended brow, or a lid that sits low, which is ptosis. It is worth finding out which, since the treatment is different for each, and constant forehead use can cause tension headaches and deepening forehead lines over time. If extra skin is the main problem, upper blepharoplasty is often a good fit and can make a significant difference in a tired look. If the lid itself sits low, ptosis repair would be the better procedure, and sometimes it is combined with blepharoplasty. A low brow may also need a modest lift. Fat grafting under the eyes makes sense if you have hollowing at the tear trough or lid cheek junction, and it often pairs nicely with upper lid surgery, since both together address the heavy upper lids and the hollow lower area. If your main issue is bulging fat pads rather than hollows, a lower blepharoplasty may be a better choice than grafting. I would suggest an exam with an oculoplastic surgeon who will measure your lid height, check your brow position, and tell you which combination suits you, since your age and concerns suggest you are likely a good candidate for treatment.
Asked By: pvparekh
ANSWER
Your reasoning is sound, and your anatomy is well described. With a negative vector, filler and fat can help, but they work best when used to soften the transition rather than to try to push the eye back. Filler or fat placed below the eye and over the cheek can add support and reduce the look of the eye sitting forward, but too much volume in a flat midface can make the face look puffy, and it cannot change the position of the bone. Filler in the upper lid hollow adds fullness, which can reduce exposure, but in someone who already has prominent eyes, adding volume above can make the eye look more prominent rather than less, so it has to be placed sparingly. Fat grafting is more durable and can be shaped more precisely, but it carries similar limits. For the one side with more scleral show, a lateral canthopexy can help raise and support the lower lid, and it is often combined with support from the cheek when there is a negative vector. If your jaw or face is slightly tilted, that can change how the eyes sit, so any plan should account for it, and it might not be possible to fully balance the sides. Starting with a measured filler trial in small amounts is a sensible way to see how your face responds before considering implants or surgery.
Asked By: Tiffany.bkr
ANSWER
I am sorry the result has affected your confidence, and what you describe is a real and recognized outcome. Medical blepharoplasty is designed to remove skin that blocks the field of vision, not to preserve the look of the lid, so it often changes the shape of the eye, even when the vision improves. The most common reasons the eye looks different are that the fold has moved higher, the upper lid has lost volume, so it looks sunken, and the amount of visible lid between the lashes and the crease has increased. Getting closer to your old appearance is often possible, although a complete return is not. The most common step is to restore volume in the upper lid, with fat grafting for a more lasting result, or with filler to try it first. If the crease is too high, lowering it requires a revision to release and reposition the crease, which is a more delicate operation, and a brow position that has changed can be addressed separately. Because you want something permanent, fat grafting and crease revision are the best candidates. I would see an oculoplastic surgeon who has experience in revision and ask to see results from patients who wanted a more natural look after a functional surgery. Please ask them what is realistic, so you can make a calm decision.
Asked By: Dynamic721700
ANSWER
Infraorbital rim implants are a reasonable option for someone with a flat midface and a negative vector, and they are often considered when fat grafting and filler have not achieved a durable result. The idea is to add forward projection to the bony rim under the eye, which supports the lower lid and cheek, reduces the look of the eye sitting forward of the cheek, and can soften a deep hollow. They do not treat bulging eyes in the medical sense, such as thyroid eye disease, so it is worth confirming there is no underlying medical cause. The implants come in a range of sizes and materials, and they are placed through an incision inside the lower lid or the mouth, so the operation must be carefully planned. Important risks include irritation of the nerve beneath the rim, which can cause numbness, implant shifting, infection, and in some cases lower lid position changes, so selecting a surgeon with experience with these implants is critical. A scan of the face can help decide the size and shape that match your anatomy. Because you have already tried fat and filler, you may also be a candidate for a combined plan, with the implant providing structure and a small amount of fat to smooth the transition. I would see an oculoplastic or facial plastic surgeon who does these regularly and ask to see results in patients with a similar flat midface.
Asked By: Practical664405
ANSWER
It is hard to recommend a procedure without knowing what bothers you about your eyes, since the right option depends entirely on the goal. In men in their early twenties, the concerns I see most often fall into a few groups. Heavy or hooded upper lids, or lids that sit at different heights, are corrected with a conservative upper blepharoplasty or ptosis repair. Under eye bags or a dark hollow at the lower lid are treated with filler, fat grafting, or a lower blepharoplasty, depending on whether the problem is fat or volume. A tired or negative look from the shape of the lower lid or a hollow cheek often comes from structure, and may call for support under the eye rather than lid surgery. A younger person with good skin often does best with the most conservative option first, and a lot of what looks like a lid problem is really a matter of sleep, allergy, or natural anatomy that does not need surgery at all. If you tell me which feature bothers you most, or bring that to a consultation along with a clear front facing photo, a surgeon can tell you which option is realistic and what the risks are. I would encourage you to be cautious about irreversible surgery at your age until you are sure of the goal.
Asked By: Dynamic721700
ANSWER
Your description makes anatomic sense. When the bony rim and midface are deficient, the lower lid and cheek have little to rest on, so the thin skin sits against the eye and the hollow looks deep, and filler can fill the cheek without addressing the true problem. The strip just below the lash line that bulges without feeling like fat is often the pretarsal part of the orbicularis muscle, which can look full when it has no support from underneath, and filler placed there tends to look lumpy and can worsen the bulge. For people with a structural cause like yours, the most reliable fix is to rebuild the support rather than layer more filler. Options include infraorbital rim implants or a bone based augmentation, a midface lift to bring the cheek support back up, and fat grafting to the lid cheek junction for a smoother transition. A conservative lower lid procedure to tighten the support structures can also help, but the plan has to come first from the bone and cheek, since removing tissue could worsen the hollowing. In some patients, a small amount of neuromodulator in the muscle strip softens the bulge, but this has to be dosed carefully to avoid lid weakness. I would see an oculoplastic surgeon who does rim implants and midface support, since a structural plan is more durable than repeated filler.
Asked By: Vivid252850
ANSWER
The right surgery depends on why one eye looks bigger, so the first step is figuring out the cause. When one eye looks larger with a bigger upper lid, there are a few common explanations. One is that the other upper lid is drooping slightly, which is ptosis, and so the opposite eye looks smaller by comparison. Another is that one upper lid carries more skin or a lower brow position, which covers part of the eye on that side. A third is that the eye itself is slightly more prominent or the lid is retracted, which shows more of the white above the iris. These look similar in a photo but are treated differently. Ptosis is corrected by tightening the muscle that lifts the lid, extra skin is corrected with upper blepharoplasty, and brow asymmetry may need a small brow adjustment. It is also normal to have a small difference between the two eyes, and some asymmetry is simply part of every face. If the difference is new or has been getting more noticeable, I would have it checked, since sudden changes in lid position or eye size can sometimes come from medical causes. I would see an oculoplastic surgeon who will measure the height of each lid, check the brow, and tell you which of these applies.
Asked By: cbiscuit9
ANSWER
What you describe sounds like hollowing at the inner upper lid, in the area where the upper lid meets the nose and the brow. This region is the medial upper lid and the glabellar area. It is a very common finding, and it is usually due to a deep groove at the upper inner orbit from a prominent brow ridge, a lack of fat in the area, or both. Because the cause is volume, an upper blepharoplasty is usually not the right fix, and removing more skin or fat can actually make the hollow look deeper. The most common treatments are a very small amount of soft hyaluronic acid filler placed carefully in the hollow, which is reversible and lets you see if you like the effect, or a small fat graft for a longer lasting result. The inner upper lid is a delicate area with important vessels nearby, so injections here should be done by an experienced injector or oculoplastic surgeon who understands the anatomy and uses a slow, cautious technique. Sometimes the look comes from a muscle pattern that pulls the inner brow down and creates a shadow, in which case a small amount of neuromodulator can soften it. I would start with an exam to look at the volume and the muscle pattern and decide which approach, if any, suits you.
Asked By: Adventurous911070
ANSWER
Your concerns about both treatments are reasonable, and you have thought about this carefully. Small pliable bumps at the ends of an upper blepharoplasty incision are common, and they usually represent a bit of scar tissue, a small fold of extra skin or tissue at the end of the incision, called a dog ear, or a small buried cyst. Since two doctors disagree about whether there is tissue to treat, an in person exam by someone who does a lot of eyelid scar work is the best way to decide. Steroid injections can flatten a thickened scar, and the risks you mentioned, skin thinning and an indentation, are real. They can be minimized by using a very low concentration, injecting small amounts, and spacing the sessions out, and many surgeons start with a test dose. Fractional CO2 laser can improve scar texture, but with a hypopigmentation tendency, you are right to be careful. A vascular or non ablative laser, or lower energy settings with test spots, are safer approaches. Silicone gel or tape is a gentle first step with no pigment risk. If a small piece of excess tissue at the end of the scar is the cause, a minor surgical touch up can sometimes be done even if there is not much tissue. Since you mentioned an autoimmune history, mention it to every provider, since it can affect healing. I would ask about test spots and a gradual plan.